Is Romo in your top 10, QBs playing right now?

[jterrell]

1. P. Manning
2. T. Brady
3. C. Palmer
4. T. Romo
5. M. Schaub
6. D. Brees
7. J. Cutler
8. V. Young
9. E. Manning
10. M. Hasselbeck (spelling)

I'd swap Cutler and Hasselbeck and you'd have my list.

good job imo!

 

[zrinkill]

Easily in the top 4 in my opinion.

 

[vicjagger]

So, just how soon after church was it when you where thinking these impure thoughts?

 

[DragonCowboy]

NO he is not!

ROMO is in my top 3......

uh, you DO know that if Romo's in your top 3, he's kinda in the top 10 by default.

kinda weird how that works, huh?

 

[thekavorka]

id take vince young over mcnabb right now

 

[RomoIsBack]

peyton
brady
carson
romo
matt. from houston i always thought he be good
vince
brett

 

[RW31]

top 10? are you kidding? he should easily be in the top 5. maybe even top 3. the only guys in front of him should be peyton, palmer and brady. thats it.

 

[RomoIsBack]

nobody like brett

 

[Aikbach]

Wher does Romo rank in your all time Cowboys list?

Mine:
1.) Roger Staubach
2.) Troy Aikman
3.)Don Meredith
4.) Danny White
5.) Tony Romo
6.) Craig Morton
7.) Eddie LeBaron
8.) Jason Garrett
9.) Clint Longley
10.) Steve Beurlein

 

[theanimal23]

Tier 1
Manning
Brady

Tier 2
Palmer -- Almost Tier 1, but has not led his team anywhere. Winning is the ultimate measurement tool in this business.

Tier 3:
Brees
Healthy McNabb -- If he plays like the Pro Bowler he once was

Tier 4:
Romo/Bulger

Tier 5:
Hasselback/Young/Farve on a good day

Tier 6:
Big Ben/Rivers/Farve - Bad Day/All the other random QBs

 

[JBond]

Yes!!!

 

[GimmeTheBall!]

I'd take Tarvaris Jackson over Mcnabb

I'd take Rebbie Jackson over McNabb.

 

[sago1]

If we based strictly on his play in first 2 games, you better believe he's in the top 10. But when they list the top 10 QBs, most of the time they give the benefit of the doubt to those who've played longer and have a track record. When the list the top QBs by stats, Romo comes up big. He's gone where many of those so called top QBs may never be & he still has less then 1 years' experience.

 

[Cowboy4ever]

I really don't understand all this love for Palmer. He is a good QB he has the tools.. but he is not elite. He has a good running game and some very talented WR to work with. Again, I think he is good.. but not elite.

Romo Is in my top 5.

 

[vicjagger]

It'd be hard to buy any argument that doesn't have him in the top 5.

 

[ABQCOWBOY]

Brady
Manning
Palmer
Romo
Bulger
Kitna
Garcia
Schaub
Delhomme
Roth

As of right now, in no order outside of the top 3, I'd say those are the QBs who are playing the best football.