Is Tony Romo a Hall of Famer with 1 Super Bowl win?

[Qcard]

I know...he never sniffed the Super Bowl. But let's just say back in 2007 Dallas doesn't gets beat by the Giants, beats the Packers and then NE in the Super Bowl. Would you say he gets in the Hall eventually?

Cabo Trip Nullified the Zero chance Tony Romo HOF call...

https://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/30/sports/football/30giants.html
“No, no, no plans,” Manning said. As an afterthought, Manning added: “My plans to Cabo fell through, so I am going to sit here. That is a joke, by the way.”

 

[Qcard]

I know...he never sniffed the Super Bowl. But let's just say back in 2007 Dallas doesn't gets beat by the Giants, beats the Packers and then NE in the Super Bowl. Would you say he gets in the Hall eventually?

Romo completed half his pass 1TD and 1INT....NOT a Franchise QB playoff standard

 

[OGCowboy]

Another what if conversation...geezzzz
Man...Training camp can’t get here soon enough

 

[kskboys]

No.

 

[NumOneQB]

I actually agree with you there. He will be in the HOF.

He better hope it’s for his work as a broadcaster and that’s starting to go by the wayside. Just waking up and announcing games with no preparation isn’t going to cut it anymore.

As a player? Not even close.

 

[leeblair]

I know...he never sniffed the Super Bowl. But let's just say back in 2007 Dallas doesn't gets beat by the Giants, beats the Packers and then NE in the Super Bowl. Would you say he gets in the Hall eventually?

If Romo had gotten one he would have gotten four or five.
He bought into Garrett's pass happy philosophy and that is what led him down the wrong path.
He had the talent, just not the teaching.

 

[OmerV]

If Romo had gotten one he would have gotten four or five.
He bought into Garrett's pass happy philosophy and that is what led him down the wrong path.
He had the talent, just not the teaching.

That really doesn't make sense. No QB other than Brady has 4-5. It's just not that easy regardless of how good the teaching is.

 

[leeblair]

That really doesn't make sense. No QB other than Brady has 4-5. It's just not that easy regardless of how good the teaching is.

Those Cowboys teams had the talent to win repeatedly, but not the leadership.

 

[DuncanIso]

I know...he never sniffed the Super Bowl. But let's just say back in 2007 Dallas doesn't gets beat by the Giants, beats the Packers and then NE in the Super Bowl. Would you say he gets in the Hall eventually?

he gets in due to his work as a broadcaster.

give it time.