Is warner HOF material?

[Tio]

This topic made my head hurt. If you had the vote, would you vote kurt warner in the hof?

 

[Doomsday101]

This topic made my head hurt. If you had the vote, would you vote kurt warner in the hof?

No I don't think so, He did have a couple of great years but a couple of years in my opinion should not get you in the Hall Of Fame

 

[Rocco]

I don't think so. He had a couple of great years and then really nothing after that. Injuries killed him. To me, an extended period of greatness is necessary for HOF consideration..

 

[Yeagermeister]

No....a two or three year run doesn't not make you a HOF'er unless you played for the 70's Steelers.

 

[Tio]

Yah, but those few years were unbelievable...I guess not, but if the class is weak...maybe...

 

[joseephuss]

No.

His career is incomplete at this point. When he was on, he was one of the best, but three great years is not a career.

Heck, over the last two seasons, he has been outplayed by a drugged up Quincy Carter. (I am a big QC fan, so no one better get offended.)

 

[TNCowboy]

This topic made my head hurt. If you had the vote, would you vote kurt warner in the hof?

I went back once and compared his 3 great years to other HOF QBs best 3 yrs, and few if any others stacked up to Warner's 99-01 seasons.

But, IMO, 3 yrs just isn't enough. I think there's too many players getting in now. I think only the elite (the Reggie Whites, Emmitt Smiths, and Dan Marionos) should be in.

For example, I love Darren Woodson, but again, IMO, he was never an elite player that should be in the HOF. He was a very good player and an integral part of the team of the 90s, but I think only a couple of players each year should get in.

 

[dbair1967]

This topic made my head hurt. If you had the vote, would you vote kurt warner in the hof?

This is a joke right?

David

 

[Big D]

umm ..... No!

 

[blindzebra]

He falls in with Davis of Denver, great for a short time. It worked for Sayers when the number of players were less, but I think that there is too much competition to get in today.

 

[Danny White]

Is there a Hall of Flashes in the Pan?

Seriously, however, if he can somehow ressurect his career in NY, and put up another 4-5 years of solid numbers he might have a claim. I don't think that'll happen, however.

 

[kmp77]

Hahahahahahaha...no! But I bet his wife will demand it and make a fuss over it.

 

[Chuck 54]

No way....he's not even close....he won't even make the ballot, imo.

Now, let him make a come back, play 4-5 more years, turn the Giants around, keep Eli on the bench and win another SB or two? Then he's a candidate for sure....right now he was just the trigger man on the "greatest show on turf" with the RAMS.

Name me a QB who couldn't be successful with the WR's and RB on the RAMS.

 

[TNCowboy]

No way....he's not even close....he won't even make the ballot, imo.

Now, let him make a come back, play 4-5 more years, turn the Giants around, keep Eli on the bench and win another SB or two? Then he's a candidate for sure....right now he was just the trigger man on the "greatest show on turf" with the RAMS.

Name me a QB who couldn't be successful with the WR's and RB on the RAMS.

Quincy Carter. Chad Hutchinson. Clint Stoerner. Ryan Leaf.

 

[Yeagermeister]

Quincy Carter. Chad Hutchinson. Clint Stoerner. Ryan Leaf.

Tony Banks, Anthony Wright

ummm I notice a pattern