Jerry Jones: McFadden Earned Right To Start

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,663
Reaction score
86,200
I agree with them but this is where they are making a mistake.

McFadden will get hurt.

Just give Michael the bulk of carries and keep McFadden in the Dunbar role.


If you want to increase McFaddens workload in December then go for it. Don't do it now.
 

CowboyStar88

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,161
Reaction score
25,549
I agree with them but this is where they are making a mistake.

McFadden will get hurt.

Just give Michael the bulk of carries and keep McFadden in the Dunbar role.


If you want to increase McFaddens workload in December then go for it. Don't do it now.

Why? I'd rather let C-Mike spell DMC

I think it's obvious that DMC is the most complete back we have and there seemed to be some good chemistry with the line. I say run it until he breaks and by that time Randle will be back and they can figure out another rotation with Randle C-Mike and R.Smith
 

RunDMC

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,407
Reaction score
2,286
I agree with them but this is where they are making a mistake.

McFadden will get hurt.

Just give Michael the bulk of carries and keep McFadden in the Dunbar role.


If you want to increase McFaddens workload in December then go for it. Don't do it now.

People said that about Murray last year and look what happened. You go with the best back on the roster and that's clearly McFadden.

Stripping McFadden of the starting role after the performance he just had makes no sense at all.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,663
Reaction score
86,200
Why? I'd rather let C-Mike spell DMC

I think it's obvious that DMC is the most complete back we have and there seemed to be some good chemistry with the line. I say run it until he breaks and by that time Randle will be back and they can figure out another rotation with Randle C-Mike and R.Smith

Why? I think it made it obvious in my post why.

He'll get hurt. It's what he does.

He is healthy right now because of the role he has been in.

If you want to potentially lose him then increase his workload.
 

CowboyStar88

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,161
Reaction score
25,549
Why? I think it made it obvious in my post why.

He'll get hurt. It's what he does.

He is healthy right now because of the role he has been in.

If you want to potentially lose him then increase his workload.

Why do we have play scared? Injuries are going to happen he could get an injury on his first carry or his 30th. He's healthy and strong right now. Maybe he won't get hurt give him 20-25 carries a game. the o-line responded to him and there was finally chemistry between a RB and the OL why not ride that like we did last year? He need to win some games lets get back to what made this team win games last year, and it wasn't by RBBC or trying to protect someone from injury. If hes confident let him run!

I doubt DMC would agree that he needs to limit his carries because he *might* get injured.
 

AKATheRake

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,968
Reaction score
2,963
Why? I think it made it obvious in my post why.

He'll get hurt. It's what he does.

He is healthy right now because of the role he has been in.

If you want to potentially lose him then increase his workload.


I agree and you're right about McFadden being healthy because of how we used him. I'm sure the coaching staff knew that they would use him toward the end of the year.

Run DMC does get hurt.

However, we need wins and he's clearly still got major talent and will probably get better in the next few games as he gets repetition with the line in game action.

He probably will have to play through pain and or injury eventually and history shows he's not good at doing so.

We have no choice.

We need some juice on offense. Badly!
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,663
Reaction score
86,200
Why do we have play scared? Injuries are going to happen he could get an injury on his first carry or his 30th. He's healthy and strong right now. Maybe he won't get hurt give him 20-25 carries a game. the o-line responded to him and there was finally chemistry between a RB and the OL why not ride that like we did last year? He need to win some games lets get back to what made this team win games last year, and it wasn't by RBBC or trying to protect someone from injury. If hes confident let him run!

I doubt DMC would agree that he needs to limit his carries because he *might* get injured.

Im all for not playing scared but with as much information that is out on McFadden I would say not giving him the bulk of carries is leaning more towards smart and not scared.
 

Bleu Star

Bye Felicia!
Messages
33,925
Reaction score
19,920
I agree with them but this is where they are making a mistake.

McFadden will get hurt.

Just give Michael the bulk of carries and keep McFadden in the Dunbar role.


If you want to increase McFaddens workload in December then go for it. Don't do it now.

Now that McFadden has shown that he might be hitting his stride, I would go with a 60/40 split with CMike. This keeps McFadden fresh all game long and limits the potential for him getting injured while also bring CMike further into the fold. This 1,2 combo can work and would also cause me to retire my Scatback By Committee reference.
 

Zordon

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,289
Reaction score
46,617
Thanks Coach Jones. Use him full time and he'll be on the injury report in no time. Use his burst 5-10 times a game and be happy with it.
 

Alexander

What's it going to be then, eh?
Messages
62,482
Reaction score
67,294
I agree with them but this is where they are making a mistake.

McFadden will get hurt.

Just give Michael the bulk of carries and keep McFadden in the Dunbar role.


If you want to increase McFaddens workload in December then go for it. Don't do it now.

If he is the hot hand, then run him until he blows out a hamstring, which might not be long.

We need to win a game, not worry about "preserving" a historically fragile player.

If that means using up his "juice" in a couple of games, so be it.
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,663
Reaction score
86,200
If he is the hot hand, then run him until he blows out a hamstring, which might not be long.

We need to win a game, not worry about "preserving" a historically fragile player.

If that means using up his "juice" in a couple of games, so be it.

Fair enough.

We are desperate.
 

Toruk_Makto

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,242
Reaction score
17,336
I agree with them but this is where they are making a mistake.

McFadden will get hurt.

Just give Michael the bulk of carries and keep McFadden in the Dunbar role.


If you want to increase McFaddens workload in December then go for it. Don't do it now.

What has Michael done to deserve to be inserted in the starting role?

Once be drafted in the second round?

This Michael hype is utterly ridiculous.
 

StevenOtero

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,826
Reaction score
1,216
People said that about Murray last year and look what happened. You go with the best back on the roster and that's clearly McFadden.

Stripping McFadden of the starting role after the performance he just had makes no sense at all.

Hey, remember when you wanted us to sit/waive McFadden and sign Brandon Jacobs?

49901709.jpg
 

AKATheRake

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,968
Reaction score
2,963
Thanks Coach Jones. Use him full time and he'll be on the injury report in no time. Use his burst 5-10 times a game and be happy with it.

:laugh: Come on man. I was hoping 15-20 carries. 20-25 touches period.
 
Top