Jets punch incident to be reviewed by NFL

Hoofbite

Well-Known Member
Messages
40,865
Reaction score
11,566
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2015/08/19/ik-enemkpali-under-review-by-nfl/#comments

Now here is the thing. Why are they going to open this can of worms? If they are going to get involved with the Geno incident shouldn't they investigate Imoan Claiborne for his punch? What is the difference? Because he didn't break his jaw? Same intent, different result.

Players are punched all the time. The fact that the Ik situation will be looked at is a clear indication that the league views this particular situation quite a bit differently.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,981
Reaction score
48,728
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Not saying they should investigate, but
Surely you see the elephant in the room difference.

Is Dez going to miss 1/4 to 1/2 the season?
From what I hear, he won't miss anything.
Night and day
 

AmericasTeam81

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,301
Reaction score
5,730
Where was the investigation when Clint Longley sucker punched Staubach? Where was the investigation when Irvin supposedly assaulted Everett McIver?
 

JDSmith

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,273
Reaction score
5,680
Where was the investigation when Clint Longley sucker punched Staubach? Where was the investigation when Irvin supposedly assaulted Everett McIver?

Maybe you could use examples from this century? Sorry, but how the league handled an incident in 1974 isn't all that relevant to the discussion. Even an incident from the mid 90's might as well have happened in ancient Greece with the way social media has altered the landscape for any public organization.
 

AmericasTeam81

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,301
Reaction score
5,730
Maybe you could use examples from this century? Sorry, but how the league handled an incident in 1974 isn't all that relevant to the discussion. Even an incident from the mid 90's might as well have happened in ancient Greece with the way social media has altered the landscape for any public organization.

Don't believe the media and you sure as hell shouldn't believe "social media".
 

JDSmith

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,273
Reaction score
5,680
Don't believe the media and you sure as hell shouldn't believe "social media".

It's not about believing social media. Public perception is formed through social media, and the league is very cognizant of it. The league cares more about public perception than anything else. Additionally, things that were barely reported in the 70's are tweeted and retweeted and whatever else people do with bits of information now. And, at least in the Staubach incident, there was no harm done. Longley hit him and ran away like a girl.

Geno Smith is a starting QB in the NFL, he had his jaw broken by another player in the locker room and he's going to miss 6 - 10 weeks. That will always draw the attention and ire of the league office, because they protect QBs more than any other group.

For people saying the league shouldn't do anything let me ask a simple question - what if one of the Rams players had walked up and broken Romo's jaw yesterday? Would that be worthy of an investigation? Is it only investigated if the player is on the other team? What about when the teams are practicing together? What about offense or defense? For all of you who think the league is overstepping its bounds, when is it OK for a player to break another player's jaw? Frankly I think the Jets should have had him arrested on the spot. At the very least I'd make sure that even if he makes the Bills he won't earn any money this year, because I'd be suing him for the loss of Geno Smith's services.
 

Toruk_Makto

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,242
Reaction score
17,336
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2015/08/19/ik-enemkpali-under-review-by-nfl/#comments


Now here is the thing. Why are they going to open this can of worms? If they are going to get involved with the Geno incident shouldn't they investigate Imoan Claiborne for his punch? What is the difference? Because he didn't break his jaw? Same intent, different result.

Surely you understand a fight on the field in the heat of competition and an assault in the locker room.
 

Sportsbabe

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,968
Reaction score
5,039

Sportsbabe

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,968
Reaction score
5,039
Maybe you could use examples from this century? Sorry, but how the league handled an incident in 1974 isn't all that relevant to the discussion. Even an incident from the mid 90's might as well have happened in ancient Greece with the way social media has altered the landscape for any public organization.

Social media doesn't change the acts only invites more unwarranted pontification.
 

Sportsbabe

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,968
Reaction score
5,039
Yeah! Let's go back decades to make a point!

A player broke another player's jaw. It SHOULD be reviewed.

A Raider bust one of his teammates in the head a few years ago. Today, everybody is cable/internet revolutionary.
 
Top