Video: Joe Milton - All-22 Film Review

[gimmesix]

Do you believe after film review that he can be a poor man’s Mahomes?

I think he can be a poor man if he doesn't take care of his money in preparation for when he's possibly out of the league in a few years if he doesn't develop.

 

[Whyjerry]

It’s fine no offense taken, but I compared him to J Allen purely on arm strength and mobility. Not saying he’s an MVP candidate but he fits that same architecture.

Same Architecture? One guy is the Taj Mahal. The other guy is a strip mall in West Virginia.

 

[KJJ]

LMAO. Poor man’s Josh Allen? Yeah right.

Can’t believe some here follow these idiots on YouTube and X.

 

[gimmesix]

Same Architecture? One guy is the Taj Mahal. The other guy is a strip mall in West Virginia.

I think you just insulted strip malls. Maybe a small rifle shop getting by but hoping to do well enough with new investors to expand.

 

[BoyzBlaster]

I think you just insulted strip malls. Maybe a small rifle shop getting by but hoping to do well enough with new investors to expand.

I was thinking more like a cardboard box level of "architecture "

 

[thunderpimp91]

Not to take away from Milton's performance, he did show that he can play at least against lower level NFL talent. A few notes though...

• This was a meaningless game for Buffalo that saw them rest several starters.
• He did have what would have been a league leading 3.33 (pff) or 3.63(nfl.com) second time to pressure if he had enough snaps to qualify.
  • Part of this was excellent protection from his OL, but part of this is also his ability to get out of the pocket and buy time
• Milton faced an insane 44% blitz percentage. Given his time to throw with such a high blitz percentage his high completion percentage should not be a huge surprise

Overall this just isnt a realistic game that Milton would see as an actual starter. He operated largely from a clean pocket. He had a ton of 1st read throws. I'm also seeing a lot of basic coverages from the video and Buffalo seemed to try to confuse him more through pressure and delayed blitzing than through disguising coverages.

Still the arm strength is very real. The mobility is very real. Tough to really hold anything against Milton from this tape, I just think Milton still has a lot of boxes to check before we can label him a potential starter. Still the guy should be able to be a legitimate QB2 from day 1 based on his physical skills alone. Hes sort of the exact opposite of a Cooper Rush.

 

[Whyjerry]

I was thinking more like a cardboard box level of "architecture "

Exactly. Allen is like a 100 year old Oak Tree. Milton is like crab grass.

 

[plymkr]

Everyone is praising the big arm, a deep threat WR would love him!!! Not sure that Dak is always able to get it deep to our guys

I’m excited to see Turpin and Milton is the preseason. A guy who can throw it 80 yards and one of the fastest guys in the league. Should be fun

 

[thunderpimp91]

What’s wrong with that? Without reps Josh Allen worked his way to the accuracy he has now. His first 2 years he had massive question marks as the interception king.

Similar situation with Dak. Not as much from an INT standpoint, but overall accuracy issues. Where Milton is going to struggle to get much sympathy from an accuracy development standpoint is the guy is already 25 years old and played 6 seasons in college. At 25 years old the expectation is that you're pretty close to fully developed. There is a really good chance that what we see from Milton this year will be about what he will be for the rest of his career.

 

[Typhus]

So many great athletes aren’t good football players.

True but I wouldn't be upset if we could stumble upon a little bit of a Cam Newton to be honest.
What is the cost for high ceiling potential, I ask you this with respect.

 

[Chasing6]

The Dallas Cowboys traded for Joe Milton, who has huge potential, lets break down his tape together. I think he is better than any QB we would have gotten on Day 3, and with him being 26 years old - he is mature enough to grow into our QB2.

Let's not forget Dak's injury history. I know Bob commented on 3 players in the last decade including Dak, Purdy and Cousins who have made starters as Day 3 picks. Dak's whole career has come from backing up and winning a starting spot via injury. Romo was an UDFA - this kid has a rocket arm and just needs some better decision making.

What is his floor?

 

[Chasing6]

this is not a Jak thread!!!!

Who is Jak?

 

[Typhus]

I’m excited to see Turpin and Milton is the preseason. A guy who can throw it 80 yards and one of the fastest guys in the league. Should be fun

That is exactly why we needed a strong arm, doesn't have to be that accurate 45 yards down the field, just put the rock out of reach of the defender and WR that can get maybe there in time, speed can really be used when you have a strong arm to match.

 

[Chasing6]

That is exactly why we needed a strong arm, doesn't have to be that accurate 45 yards down the field, just put the rock out of reach of the defender and WR that can get maybe there in time, speed can really be used when you have a strong arm to match.

Sounds like we have become Raider fans. Al Davis would be proud.

 

[NotForLong]

With Milton (poor man's Josh Allen), Mingo (poor man's Jerry Rice) and Javonte Williams (poor man's Jim Brown) we are going to be a force.

And the owner is a poor man's Hugh Heffner

 

[Whyjerry]

True but I wouldn't be upset if we could stumble upon a little bit of a Cam Newton to be honest.
What is the cost for high ceiling potential, I ask you this with respect.

I see Milton as similar to Lance. I don’t see the upside at all. I think they could grab Gabriel in the 5th round. Better option.

 

[Typhus]

I see Milton as similar to Lance. I don’t see the upside at all. I think they could grab Gabriel in the 5th round. Better option.

We can still grab Gabriel in the 5th, there is certainly no reason to think that we are done developing talent at the position.
Keep throwing darts until you finally get lucky and hit the bullseye hopefully.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with getting lucky occasionally.

 

[gimmesix]

I was thinking more like a cardboard box level of "architecture "

I'm hoping he's a little sturdier than that, but we'll see.

 

[plymkr]

And the owner is a poor man's Hugh Heffner

Lol, love it! Post of the day

 

[gimmesix]

We can still grab Gabriel in the 5th, there is certainly no reason to think that we are done developing talent at the position.
Keep throwing darts until you finally get lucky and hit the bullseye hopefully.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with getting lucky occasionally.

We've spent so many years neglecting the position, that I don't think we should be against having two young developmental QBs on the roster.