BouncingCheese;1508221 said:
Judging recievers by their stats for HOF measurement is very difficult.
Look at Lynn Swann: his numbers are atrocious comaratively, even to third-string wideouts like Wayne Chrebet comparatively....but that doesn't exactly mean that Chrebet is HOF material now, is he?
Art Monk only had three pro bowl appearances and only four 1,0000 yard seasons in fifteen nfl campaigns. Heck, he wasn't even the leading recieving leader on his team occasionally. But that still doesn't mean that Art isn't HOF worthy. He has had so many clutch catches that he is deserved of HOF status ( I CANNOT BELIEVE THAT I AM SUPPORTING AN NFL PLAYER)
Irvin and Keyshawn have almost identical stat markings; however, can any of us deny that Irvin was the most important player of the two? Stats are going to be so inflated (even though they are already) in the passing game, what with all the qb's throwing little checkdown passes to beef up their accuracy and qb ratings... Terry Bradshaw wasn't the most accurate qb, but he also loved to chuck the ball up in the air alot more than we do today IMO.
Personally, I don't think making a clutch play should put you in the HoF. I think it can help! I think the first thing that should be looked at is your average production over your career limited by the overall length of your career. (meaning, if you played 3 years and had three great years that won't make you an HoF player) Maybe their should be a minimum required playing time; say 8-9 years. Divide those years, by your total production and then set a mark for what you accomplish.
Like Michael Irvin. Some say, his stats arn't quite what they think they should be. He did play 11 season. (two of them didn't even equal a single season of games combined) yet he still averaged over 1,000 yards a season for every single season he played. Top it off with 5 Pro Bowls, and 3 Super Bowls, and 90s All-Decade Team. It's clear Irvin dominated the game.
Art Monk averaged less than 800 yards a season. He did win 2 Super Bowls, but one he didn't even
play in. Monk attended 3 Pro Bowls. While I'm not against Monk making the HoF, he wasn't in the class of Irvin. Although, whomever filled in
his Wikipedia article brings up the point that Monk has more yards than Irvin and yet Monk was passed over, they just forget to point out who was far more of a dominate player.