Kiper & McShay Rankings of Cowboys Draft Picks

[Aliencowboy]

Okay, so let's take the average of Kiper and McShay's scores, not to say that they are the draft Oracles, but just for an exercise.

Smith 34 drafted at 26 34-26=8 lost value points.

Schoonmaker 75 drafted at 58 75-58=17 lost value points

Overshown 92 (91.5) drafted at 90 92-90=2

So, according to Kiper and McShay, the Cowboys lost a total of 27 points. A total round in the draft is 32 points.

The Cowboys lost almost a total round in draft value according to Kiper and McShay.

It's almost as if the Cowboys drafted an equivalent of a low 2nd, another low 2nd, and mid 3rd pick instead of a low 1st, low 2nd, and low 3rd.

.......according to Kiper and McShay.

This is some faulty thinking. You are not considering where Dallas is picking which is end of round, You are also not factoring in position value and team need.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Never forget

“If Jimmy Clausen is not a successful quarterback in the NFL, I’m done. That’s it. I’m out.”

Replied McShay: “What is your time frame, Mel? When do we make that assessment?”

Kiper: “I want eight years.”

McShay: “It will only take three years, Mel. We can tell inside three years.”

Kiper: “I want eight.”

Haha well could give him eternity and the answer is the same…..Clausen couldn’t play lol.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

This is some faulty thinking. You are not considering where Dallas is picking which is end of round, You are also not factoring in position value and team need.

Yeah that’s one of the oddest posts I’ve seen on the matter.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Okay, so let's take the average of Kiper and McShay's scores, not to say that they are the draft Oracles, but just for an exercise.

Smith 34 drafted at 26 34-26=8 lost value points.

Schoonmaker 75 drafted at 58 75-58=17 lost value points

Overshown 92 (91.5) drafted at 90 92-90=2

So, according to Kiper and McShay, the Cowboys lost a total of 27 points. A total round in the draft is 32 points.

The Cowboys lost almost a total round in draft value according to Kiper and McShay.

It's almost as if the Cowboys drafted an equivalent of a low 2nd, another low 2nd, and mid 3rd pick instead of a low 1st, low 2nd, and low 3rd.

.......according to Kiper and McShay.

Only issue though is Kiper and Mcshay aren’t the gospel…

 

[Acceptablename]

Kiper:
Smith – 30
Schoonmaker – 79
Overshown – 94

McShay:
Smith – 38
Schoonmaker – 71
Overshown – 89

Solid picks. Getting a run stuffing DT is the cherry on top. These players wouldn't have lasted until the next round. Emphasis on stopping the run on defense and improving the run offense. Love that! Excited to see what Saturday brings!!!

R it’s a pissing in moaning happens every year. I do feel a little underwhelmed by the second and third pitch but they have more way more knowledge of their needs of course my expectations for a guard and running back are still hanging

 

[bigE79]

Holy crap. Is that word banned too?

I'm offended by that word,I protest.. lololol