This is my first post to this forum, and what a topic I chose to wade in on.. J I have no desire to jump on to the flame train, but I think that there might be a misconception about the realities of the 3-4 vs. the 4-3. It is obvious that the major difference is in the number of down lineman and linebackers, but the philosophy is where the real difference lies.
How many of you remember when BP first arrived in Dallas and made the comment that the linebacking core as a unit was too small? Big D defense had, primarily been based on speed and not size. In the 3-4 your outside linebackers need to be almost DE in size. The theory is on running downs with your 3 mammoth down lineman and 2 large outside LB’s you in essence end up with 5 down lineman against the run. Since many teams in the NFL employ a run, run, pass play-calling scheme the 3-4 is very effective in this regard.
BP’s move to a 3-4 base, and make no mistake he has moved to a 3-4 base centered around not only drafting Ware and Spears but tightening up the secondary as well. The corners have to be solid for the 3-4 to be successful. From a personnel standpoint this season, the entire defense as a unit looks bigger and different. BP has the personnel in place this year for the 3-4. When Bill says he will use a 4-man front because he wants to get his best players on the field this doesn’t translate into a 4-3 defense. The players manning the positions will be designed for a 3-4 offense.
I am excited about this year’s defense and I believe it will be the difference in the season. A solid defense and a good offense had propelled many teams straight to the big game. BP has an impressive track record with defenses, I have to defer to his knowledge of the game and trust that however he lines them up, it will be a dominant defense.
The only other comment I want to make is the one about losing Ferguson, Spears, Ware and hell pick someone else it doesn’t matter, the season would indeed suffer. How Tired were Ellis and Glover last season in the 4th quarter? This is the best rotation we have had on the DL in Dallas in a long, long time. A fresh Ellis and Glover in 4th? Canty and Ware with Gas left in their tank at the end of the game. Spears and Ferguson still game ready in the second half. I wouldn’t want to be an offensive coordinator designing my game plan around that much depth.
Jon