CFZ McCarthy and Quinn makeover of the Dallas Cowboys

Jumbo075

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,933
Reaction score
7,299
The Cowboys have 12 starters from their last 4 draft classes. Of those starters, they have gone to 7 Pro Bowls, and named All-pro 6 times. They also have 21 backup players on the team. Of the 53-man roster, 33 players have been added as rookies in the last 3-1/2 years.

The Cowboys have also added 7 veteran starters since 2021 via trade or free agency (Anger, Sieg, Hooker, Kearse, Hankins, Gilmore, Cooks), 4 in the past 10 months alone. That is over 75% of the overall roster since Mike McCarthy took over - including 7 new offensive starters (Smith, Biadaz, Steele, Lamb, Cooks, Ferguson, Schoonmaker), 9 new defensive starters (Diggs, Kearse, Hooker, Gilmore, Bland, Clark, Parsons, Odighizuwa and Hankins) and 3 new special teams starters (Anger, Sieg, Turpin).

Only 5 starters remain on offense from before McCarthy (Prescott, Smith, Martin, Pollard, Gallup), and only 3 starters remain from before Quinn on defense (Wilson, Lawrence, Vander Esch). All of the Specialists are new in the last 2-1/2 years. As a result, the Cowboys have led the league in scoring offense over the past two seasons, and also led the league in turnovers generated by the defense for two consecutive years - a far cry from the 32nd ranked historically bad defense of 2020. This is why, despite the clamor of the national media, Mike McCarthy's job is not in jeopardy this season.

2020 Rookie Class - 4 starters, 2 backup players; 5 Pro Bowls, 1 All-Pro
  • WR CeeDee Lamb - starter, 2x Pro Bowl, 2nd team All-Pro 2022
  • CB Trevon Diggs - starter, 2x Pro Bowl, 1st team All-Pro 2021
  • DT Neville Gallimore - backup
  • FS Reggie Robinson - cut
  • C Tyler Biadasz - starter, Pro Bowl
  • DE Bradlee Anae - cut
  • QB Ben Dinucci - cut
  • OT Terence Steele - starter
  • RB Rico Dowdle - backup
  • TE Sean McKeon - cut
  • OL/DL Isaac Alarcon - cut
  • Practice Squad eligible
    • TE Sean McKeon
    • Isaac Alarcon
2021 Rookie Class - 2 starters, 4 backup players, 1 player injured reserve; 2x Pro Bowl, 2x All-Pro
  • LB Micah Parsons - starter, 2x Pro Bowl, 2x 1st team All-Pro
  • CB Kelvin Joseph - traded
  • DT Osa Odighizuwa - starter
  • DT Chauncey Golston - backup
  • CB Nahshon Wright - backup
  • LB Jabril Cox - cut
  • OG Josh Ball - injured reserve
  • WR Simi Fehoko - cut
  • DT Quinton Bohanna - cut
  • FS Israel Mukuamu - backup
  • OG Matt Farniok - cut
  • S Tyler Coyle - cut
  • Practice Squad eligible
    • LB Jabril Cox
    • WR Simi Fehoko
    • DT Quinton Bohanna
    • OG Matt Farniok
    • S Tyler Coyle
2022 Rookie Class - 5 starters, 7 backup players; 1 Pro Bowl
  • OT Tyler Smith - starter
  • DE Sam Williams - backup
  • WR Jalen Tolbert - backup
  • TE Jake Ferguson - starter
  • OT Matt Waletzko - backup
  • CB DaRon Bland - starter
  • LB Damone Clark - starter
  • DT John Ridgeway - cut
  • LB Devin Harper - backup
  • KR Ka Vontae Turpin - starter, Pro Bowl
  • TE Peyton Hendershot - backup
  • S/LB Markquese Bell - backup
  • FS Juanyeh Thomas - backup
  • RB Malik Davis - cut
  • WR Dennis Houston - cut
  • C Brock Hoffman - cut
  • OT Alex Taylor - cut
  • WR Dontario Drummond - cut
  • C Alec Lindstrom - cut
  • Practice Squad eligible
    • RB Malik Davis
    • WR Dennis Houston
    • C Brock Hoffman
    • OT Alex Taylor
    • WR Dontario Drummond
    • C Alec Lindstrom
2023 Rookie Class - 1 starter, 8 backup players, 2 players injured reserve
  • DT Mazi Smith - backup
  • TE Luke Schoonmaker - starter
  • LB DeMarvion Overshown - injured reserve
  • DL Viliami Fehoko - backup
  • OT Asim Richards - backup
  • CB Eric Scott, Jr. - backup
  • RB Deuce Vaughn - backup
  • WR Jalen Brooks - backup
  • OG T.J. Bass - backup
  • FB Hunter Luepke - backup
  • TE John Stephens, Jr. - injured reserve
  • WR David Durdin - injured reserve
  • WR Jalen Moreno-Cropper - cut
  • TE Princeton Fant - cut
  • OT Earl Bostick, Jr. - cut
  • DE Isaiah Land - cut
  • DE Tyrus Wheat - cut
  • LB Durell Johnson - cut
  • CB Myles Brooks - cut
  • CB Josh Butler - cut
  • CB D'Angelo Mandell - cut
  • Practice Squad eligible
    • WR Jalen Moreno-Cropper
    • TE Princeton Fant
    • OT Earl Bostick, Jr.
    • DE Isaiah Land
    • DE Tyrus Wheat
    • LB Durell Johnson
    • CB Myles Brooks
    • CB Josh Butler
    • CB D'Angelo Mandell
 
Last edited:

CT Dal Fan

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,710
Reaction score
20,636
Great work. But just for clarification WR David Durden is on IR after he tore an ACL at practice last week. Maybe he'll get more opportunities if the Cowboys bring him back to 2024 camp.
 

offlimits

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,173
Reaction score
1,010
The Cowboys have 12 starters from their last 4 draft classes. Of those starters, they have gone to 7 Pro Bowls, and named All-pro 6 times. They also have 21 backup players on the team. Of the 53-man roster, 33 players have been added as rookies in the last 3-1/2 years.

The Cowboys have also added 7 veteran starters since 2021 via trade or free agency (Anger, Sieg, Hooker, Kearse, Hankins, Gilmore, Cooks), 4 in the past 10 months alone. That is over 75% of the overall roster since Mike McCarthy took over - including 7 new offensive starters (Smith, Biadaz, Steele, Lamb, Cooks, Ferguson, Schoonmaker), 9 new defensive starters (Diggs, Kearse, Hooker, Gilmore, Bland, Clark, Parsons, Odighizuwa and Hankins) and 3 new special teams starters (Anger, Sieg, Turpin).

Only 5 starters remain on offense from before McCarthy (Prescott, Smith, Martin, Pollard, Gallup), and only 3 starters remain from before Quinn on defense (Wilson, Lawrence, Vander Esch). All of the Specialists are new in the last 2-1/2 years. As a result, the Cowboys have led the league in scoring offense over the past two seasons, and also led the league in turnovers generated by the defense for two consecutive years - a far cry from the 32nd ranked historically bad defense of 2020. This is why, despite the clamor of the national media, Mike McCarthy's job is not in jeopardy this season.

2020 Rookie Class - 4 starters, 2 backup players; 5 Pro Bowls, 1 All-Pro
  • WR CeeDee Lamb - starter, 2x Pro Bowl, 2nd team All-Pro 2022
  • CB Trevon Diggs - starter, 2x Pro Bowl, 1st team All-Pro 2021
  • DT Neville Gallimore - backup
  • FS Reggie Robinson - cut
  • C Tyler Biadasz - starter, Pro Bowl
  • DE Bradlee Anae - cut
  • QB Ben Dinucci - cut
  • OT Terence Steele - starter
  • RB Rico Dowdle - backup
  • TE Sean McKeon - cut
  • OL/DL Isaac Alarcon - cut
  • Practice Squad eligible
    • TE Sean McKeon
    • Isaac Alarcon
2021 Rookie Class - 2 starters, 4 backup players, 1 player injured reserve; 2x Pro Bowl, 2x All-Pro
  • LB Micah Parsons - starter, 2x Pro Bowl, 2x 1st team All-Pro
  • CB Kelvin Joseph - traded
  • DT Osa Odighizuwa - starter
  • DT Chauncey Golston - backup
  • CB Nahshon Wright - backup
  • LB Jabril Cox - cut
  • OG Josh Ball - injured reserve
  • WR Simi Fehoko - cut
  • DT Quinton Bohanna - cut
  • FS Israel Mukuamu - backup
  • OG Matt Farniok - cut
  • S Tyler Coyle - cut
  • Practice Squad eligible
    • LB Jabril Cox
    • WR Simi Fehoko
    • DT Quinton Bohanna
    • OG Matt Farniok
    • S Tyler Coyle
2022 Rookie Class - 5 starters, 7 backup players; 1 Pro Bowl
  • OT Tyler Smith - starter
  • DE Sam Williams - backup
  • WR Jalen Tolbert - backup
  • TE Jake Ferguson - starter
  • OT Matt Waletzko - backup
  • CB DaRon Bland - starter
  • LB Damone Clark - starter
  • DT John Ridgeway - cut
  • LB Devin Harper - backup
  • KR Ka Vontae Turpin - starter, Pro Bowl
  • TE Peyton Hendershot - backup
  • S/LB Markquese Bell - backup
  • FS Juanyeh Thomas - backup
  • RB Malik Davis - cut
  • WR Dennis Houston - cut
  • C Brock Hoffman - cut
  • OT Alex Taylor - cut
  • WR Dontario Drummond - cut
  • C Alec Lindstrom - cut
  • Practice Squad eligible
    • RB Malik Davis
    • WR Dennis Houston
    • C Brock Hoffman
    • OT Alex Taylor
    • WR Dontario Drummond
    • C Alec Lindstrom
2023 Rookie Class - 1 starter, 8 backup players, 2 players injured reserve
  • DT Mazi Smith - backup
  • TE Luke Schoonmaker - starter
  • LB DeMarvion Overshown - injured reserve
  • DL Viliami Fehoko - backup
  • OT Asim Richards - backup
  • CB Eric Scott, Jr. - backup
  • RB Deuce Vaughn - backup
  • WR Jalen Brooks - backup
  • OG T.J. Bass - backup
  • FB Hunter Luepke - backup
  • TE John Stephens, Jr. - injured reserve
  • WR David Durdin - injured reserve
  • WR Jalen Moreno-Cropper - cut
  • TE Princeton Fant - cut
  • OT Earl Bostick, Jr. - cut
  • DE Isaiah Land - cut
  • DE Tyrus Wheat - cut
  • LB Durell Johnson - cut
  • CB Myles Brooks - cut
  • CB Josh Butler - cut
  • CB D'Angelo Mandell - cut
  • Practice Squad eligible
    • WR Jalen Moreno-Cropper
    • TE Princeton Fant
    • OT Earl Bostick, Jr.
    • DE Isaiah Land
    • DE Tyrus Wheat
    • LB Durell Johnson
    • CB Myles Brooks
    • CB Josh Butler
    • CB D'Angelo Mandell
Means nothing unless you win playoff games. That is how you are judged.
 

kevm3

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,700
Reaction score
12,714
The moves I'm seeing look sensible. The only one that should have been kept is Land.
 

75boyz

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,089
Reaction score
9,750
The overall results on the defensive side of the ball with both player acquisition, scheme and coaching has improved drastically since Quinn's hiring.

I'm in a stand by wait and see mode this year to see if new coach staffing, personnel and scheme changes to the offense can give McCarthy the same amount of success.

jmo
 

Cumart21

Well-Known Member
Messages
749
Reaction score
938
Good post. I feel pretty good about the roster. Let's hope it transfers to a hot team down the stretch and a deep playoff run.
 

Jumbo075

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,933
Reaction score
7,299
I can't wait until that comment matures. But you'll just say, "Oops".
You can lose Super Bowls in August by not preparing properly, and not creating a talented enough roster. Dallas didn't lose the Super Bowl this offseason. They are well set up to compete. I'll wait until they are eliminated to complain. At that point, you can point out my comments, and I will still stand behind them.
 

shabazz

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,977
Reaction score
31,267
You can lose Super Bowls in August by not preparing properly, and not creating a talented enough roster. Dallas didn't lose the Super Bowl this offseason.
Perhaps we can make that big jump this year and merely lose in the NFC Championship game .

I don’t want to see Rayne and McCarthy out of a job and living in an Austin Tent City……oh the humanity
 

Havic

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,390
Reaction score
6,933
LB and CB depth are a bit of a concern but we have some moves coming I'm sure.
 

JoeKing

Diehard
Messages
35,632
Reaction score
31,077
You can lose Super Bowls in August by not preparing properly, and not creating a talented enough roster. Dallas didn't lose the Super Bowl this offseason. They are well set up to compete. I'll wait until they are eliminated to complain. At that point, you can point out my comments, and I will still stand behind them.
Yeah, I figured, ego too big to ever admit you were wrong. :muttley:
 

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member
Messages
55,485
Reaction score
36,644
Yeah, I figured, ego too big to ever admit you were wrong. :muttley:
When you believe the structure is being built soundly when it doesn’t meet expectations or the competition has constructed a stronger structure don’t normally find fault In your work.

There will be other factors contributing to the lack of more favorable results. And look to reconstruct or modify the miscalculations. Always looking ahead not bogged down with realizations.
 
Top