Not sure I agree totally on that one. McFadden has or had elite straight line speed (4.3 40yd). Whether he still has that straight line speed or whether he trusts it is totally different. I recall 2 years ago he broke the line of scrimmage on more then one occasion and then seemed to not be able to hit the 4th gear he used to have. Far as juke ability I absolutely agree. He doesn't have many moves or possess the ability to make folks miss. Probably never did. He was a big back with lots of speed but with not much lower body strength. Has always had bird legs and bird legs don't generate much lower body strength. I think conversely Zeke does everything better then McFadden. Also a lot less wear on a 2 year old car frame then a 8 year old car frame.