McFadden > Randle

[myslamsareolder]

It isn't even close. Now the question is can he stay healthy? I'm not holding my breath, but he is superior in every way.

 

[illhurtya]

Based on a couple of runs in a preseason game? Cool story bro.

 

[DallasBlockersClub]

He looked better today, but Randle looked better last week. Let's wait and see.

 

[TwentyOne]

McFadden ran against 6 and 7 man fronts. Also Minny didnt play all their starters at that time.

Randle ran against 8 man fronts most of the time.

McFadden seems to get down very easy if someone touches his feet or lower legs. He falls forward all the time still i'd like to see him break those wanna be tackles.

 

[CATCH17]

You guys crack me up..

Randle has guys in the backfield when he gets the ball so he sucks and McAfadden gets space to run in and he's amazing..


Guess what guys??? They'll all do good if we get it blocked and they'll all do bad of we don't.

 

[Arkyvarminter]

Sometimes 20 is greater than 21.......

http://i335.***BLOCKED***/albums/m472/jdkyle/rbs_zpse9rvzflj.jpg

 

[conner01]

A week ago people said he was done
If they can stay healthy I think the RB position will be just fine
Probably not as good as last years but good enough with a healthy romo to start the season

 

[conner01]

You guys crack me up..

Randle has guys in the backfield when he gets the ball so he sucks and McAfadden gets space to run in and he's amazing..


Guess what guys??? They'll all do good if we get it blocked.

Always look better when there are holes to run through and randle had a ten yard run called back

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

The talent is no comparison .

 

[ActualCowboysFan]

Sometimes 20 is greater than 21.......

http://i335.***BLOCKED***/albums/m472/jdkyle/rbs_zpse9rvzflj.jpg

Or nah.

 

[Arkyvarminter]

I think McFadden is ahead in the RB race so far. Still time for Randle to catch up but I think McFadden is just simply a better runner and that's not a shot against Randle...

 

[hornitosmonster]

He did look better.

 

[Wolf2k5]

I still say we trade for an RB... *ducks*

 

[DoctorChicken]

Neither are as good as Tyler Clutts though.

 

[Arkyvarminter]

He did look better.

All we can go by is what we see in preseason even if it is very little......

 

[Alexander]

McFadden was impressive with his speed and burst, but again, he went down when faced with resistance.

I don't know what to make of it at this stage. It looked like we were running completely different plays between the two of them.

 

[theogt]

I get the feeling it doesn't matter one bit who we put back there. We're going to run the ball well.

 

[JDSmith]

I think the biggest difference is that McFadden is very good at blitz pickup.

 

[CATCH17]

The talent is no comparison .

It's hard for most RBs in the NFL to match McFaddens talent.


I know a lot of people on this forum think he sucks and point to his YPC in Oakland as proof.

I don't buy it though..

What I do buy is him being injury prone so I would say that debating Randle vs Mcfadden is pointless because the Cowboys are not going to feed him a ton of carries week in and week out.

 

[Stinger_Splash]

Won't matter who start. They will split the carries. My biggest question is not who runs better but which one of them have better intangibles. What I mean is, which one of them can make people miss more? Which one of them can pass protect? Finally, which one of them can catch better out of the backfield. I hope the Cowboys have that in mind to see which one of them get the most carries.