Mel Kiper Jr Invitational Self Analysis Thread (READ HERE BEFORE VOTING!)

sureletsrace

Official CZ Homer
Messages
4,622
Reaction score
4,197
Hi everyone. I'm making this thread to give everyone a chance to do some self-evaluation and explaining regarding your draft.

How did you decide team needs? Did you get anyone that you feel was a steal? Any interesting stories or conundrums? Faced with a dilemma of two great players? Any regrets?

I'd like for the people who participated in the MKJI this year to post in here. Your reasoning may help us grade your draft better. I'll be posting mine at some point tonight in this thread.

I'm curious to hear your analysis and stories!
 

Killerinstinct

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,013
Reaction score
5,870
I was the Bears GM

I started with picks 1(3), 2(36), 3(67), 4(100), 4(106)

I researched several sites to find out the Bears team needs
They were QB, WR, TE, OT and CB

At pick 3 I took MItch Trubisky QB. Bears fans seem to believe he is the best QB for their system and I considered trying to trade down but figured in reality the Bears would probably be lucky to have their pick of QB's at 3 so I stayed and took the one I wanted.

I traded Pick 2(36) and 3(67) for picks 1(31) and 3(95)

I traded up to grab John Ross WR. I lost some points on the trade but since I believe I grabbed a top 20 player I came out way ahead.

In the third round I had a trade worked out with Dallas to move up to 2(60) for picks 3(95) 4(100) and 4(106)
I was targeting the last player I had a 1st rd grade on. Jourdan Lewis CB. The trade was contingent on Lewis being there at 60 but he was selected one pick before at 59.

I then traded up using picks 3(96) and 4(100) for pick 3(69) to grab one of the better OT prospects in DIon Dawkins.

With pick 106 I selected Jordan Leggett TE.

I filled 4 of the 5 needs with my 4 picks. I almost had Jourdan Lewis and would have been very pleased with what I would have considered 3 1st rd talents.

This was a fun exercise and I thank the other players and especially Risen for all of his hard work.
 

RandyOh

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,107
Reaction score
2,958
I'll do this tomorrow. Burned out right now. Let's just say what I did today guarantees the Cowboys win jack for a decade.
i was so pissed when u took Willis a few picks before me in the 4th. I couldnt believe he slid that far. I thought u was gonna draft OL to go along with all your new high power offensive weapons.
 

Trouty

Kellen Moore baby
Messages
31,526
Reaction score
80,467
i was so pissed when u took Willis a few picks before me in the 4th. I couldnt believe he slid that far. I thought u was gonna draft OL to go along with all your new high power offensive weapons.

Tell me about it! CowboysZone stole Ryan Anderson from me!!! So friggin mad. So many players in the first three rounds were on my board and they were taken before my turn. The ire and rue'ing is alive and real :)
 

RandyOh

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,107
Reaction score
2,958
I had the Colts.

My Picks in the draft

15th overall - Ryan Ramczyk T Wisconsin

48th overall- Tre'Davious White CB LSU

78th overall- Joe Mixon RB Oklahoma

111th overall- Derek Rivers DE Youngstown St.

1st of all i already know some will think i reached a little in the 1st but i dont really see a reach. Ramczyk is seen by many as the top OT and a top 20 pick. Andrew Luck would be ecstatic to see the top rated O Lineman being added to his line seeing how he was one of the most sacked and hit QB's last year.

In the 2nd i sat back and let the best player fall to me and i feel i walked away with a legit 1st round defensive talent at 48th overall.

My 3rd round pick is the pick that I know will either cause a high grade or a low grade. I know some highly dislike Mixon as a person and will grade off of something he did when he was 18 years old but i don't see Mixon falling to day 3 in the real draft. Again i got another 1st round talent and Andrew Luck comes to accept him after seeing how versatile an offensive weapon he is. Nothing brings a team together better then winning.

In the 4th i was fortunate enough that the top player left on my board at my pick was an edge rusher which helps fill a big need. Rivers is not only seen as a top 100 talent on many media draft boards but he has even been talked about as a player who could potentially sneak into the end of the 1st round over one of the bigger school rushers like Charles Harris or Takkarist McKinley.

This was very fun, I will absolutely do this again next year. Thank you Commissioner Risen for all the work you put into this.
 

sureletsrace

Official CZ Homer
Messages
4,622
Reaction score
4,197
Tampa Bay Buccaneers

I am going to try to shoot straight with my analysis and give you some strengths and weaknesses in the players I drafted, and I'll give a bit of explanation on how the players fit with Tampa.

After looking around the internet and some Buccaneers forums, I determined that the team needs were as follows:
1) Wide Receiver
2) Safety
3) Center
4) Defensive Linemen
5) Running Back
6) Cornerback

1 (19) - Jabrill Peppers, S - Keith Tandy took over for Chris Conte in the second half of the season, where Chris Conte was rated as 90-of-91 safeties by PFF. Keith Tandy, over the final 5 games of the season, was rated as the highest safety in the NFL. That being said, their SS, Bradley McDougald is a free agent this year, and is expected to leave. Enter Jabrill Peppers. While he does not have the INT numbers you would like from a college prospect, this guy is a true football player and an exceptional talent. While I feel like you could play him at nearly any position not on the line, I think he was miscast as a LB and I believe he'll be a terror at Safety. With this addition, the Buccaneers immediately have an elite secondary with Peppers, Tandy, Grimes, and Hargreaves III.

2 (52) - Tarell Basham, DE - William Gholston is a free agent this offseason and is expected to leave. Gholston is an ace run-stopper, but didn't prove elite in the pass-rush department. Tarell Basham is very good against the run and is getting better at rushing the passer. He has the prototypical length, size, and explosiveness to mature into a reliable starter at the NFL level. His pass-rushing repertoire is pretty basic right now, but he does have a nice speed-to-bullrush move, and he will only improve.

3 (82) - Amara Darboh, WR - Tampa Bay needs a #2 WR to compliment Mike Evans. Amara Darboh has the size and smarts that you look for in a #2 WR. He is football smart. He does not have explosiveness off the LOS, but what he lacks in explosiveness, he makes up for with his smooth route running and ability to adjust his routes to accommodate his quarterback. A very solid run blocker to clear the edge for Doug Martin and Jacquizz Rodgers. Not flashy, but reliable. Every season in college, he has seen increased targets and answered it with increased production.

4 (115) - Jon Toth, C - Tampa Bay's center, Joe Hawley has been serviceable, but he is often injured. Enter Jon Toth. I was truly thrilled that I was able to get Jon Toth at this pick. I was looking at trading up into the back of the third round because I honestly did not think he would make it to me. Toth, in his freshman season, was a backup for the first game of the year. He started the second game and never looked back, starting 48 consecutive games at center (an NCAA best). He had a very solid game against the vaunted Alabama defensive front. He is tough and plays with a mean streak. He is not the best athlete, but I know another center in the NFL who isn't either, and he is the best center in the NFL.

With my 5th-7th round picks, I plan on adding (in no particular order, depending on how the board falls):

Zane Gonzalez, K from Arizona State. As stated by NFL.com, "the most prolific kicker in FBS history." Roberto Aguayo was the worst kicker in the NFL this year. Major need that can be addressed in the late rounds.
A project/depth at CB.
BPA.

Thanks for taking the time to read this. If you have any questions, feel free to ask. Can't wait to read yours!
 

Questfor6

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,881
Reaction score
886
Bengals Draft

Going into this draft defense was going to be our theme. The Bengals have to be able to slow Pittsburgh if they want to win the north and that's hopefully what was accomplished here.

Round 1. Reuben Foster LB Bama - Instant replacement and upgrade over Maualuga and a perfect companion to Burfict.

Round 2. Demarcus Walker DL FSU - I had Budda Baker's name on the card here but Carolina stole him right in front of me. Walker to me can play outside in base to start but could be nasty inside with Atkins on passing downs.

Round 3. Duwaune Shoot DE ILLINOIS - I was kind of shocked he was still available at this point to be honest so I had to pull the trigger. He's a top 50 prospect in my eyes, who's an instant upgrade over Michael Johnson at this point. I also considered Justin Evans S TX A&M & Chad Hansen WR CAL at this pick.

Round 4. Fabian Moreau CB UCLA - Another value pick IMO, Moreau is a top 64 prospect. This pick can could help the Bengals make it easier to walk away from Pacman this off-season. Not to mention they'll get William Jackson back which gives them a great set of young corners.

In all I like how this draft played out although I'd of liked to added a WR somewhere in the top 4 rounds I just couldn't make the value add up at my respected picks.
 

sureletsrace

Official CZ Homer
Messages
4,622
Reaction score
4,197
Bengals Draft

Going into this draft defense was going to be our theme. The Bengals have to be able to slow Pittsburgh if they want to win the north and that's hopefully what was accomplished here.

Round 1. Reuben Foster LB Bama - Instant replacement and upgrade over Maualuga and a perfect companion to Burfict.

Round 2. Demarcus Walker DL FSU - I had Budda Baker's name on the card here but Carolina stole him right in front of me. Walker to me can play outside in base to start but could be nasty inside with Atkins on passing downs.

Round 3. Duwaune Shoot DE ILLINOIS - I was kind of shocked he was still available at this point to be honest so I had to pull the trigger. He's a top 50 prospect in my eyes, who's an instant upgrade over Michael Johnson at this point. I also considered Justin Evans S TX A&M & Chad Hansen WR CAL at this pick.

Round 4. Fabian Moreau CB UCLA - Another value pick IMO, Moreau is a top 64 prospect. This pick can could help the Bengals make it easier to walk away from Pacman this off-season. Not to mention they'll get William Jackson back which gives them a great set of young corners.

In all I like how this draft played out although I'd of liked to added a WR somewhere in the top 4 rounds I just couldn't make the value add up at my respected picks.

You had a very good draft. Bengals need some interior OL help, but I like that you focused on the defense.
 

tm1119

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,946
Reaction score
8,684
Titans- Tennessee Titans (tm1119)
1(5) Jamal Adams S LSU
1(18) O.J. Howard TE Alabama
3(84) Chidobe Awuzie CB Colorado
3(95) Chad Hansen WR California
4(100) Larry Ogunjobi DT Charlotte
4(114) Howard Wilson CB Houston

Went into the draft picking for an up and coming team that had 2 pretty big flaws to fix. 1) secondary and 2) weapons to help Matiota keep getting better.

Round 1- #5- Jamal Adams. Safest player in the for me. Thought about Solomon Thomas and Lattimore here as well but Adams won out as the safer pick at a position of need. Can be an impact player day 1 for a D that needs it.

#18- OJ Howard- I had a trade offer to @Risen Star to move up from #18 to #14 to take Corey Davis, Risen told me he would have accepted my trade...but he saw it too late and already posted his pick (Davis). Quite disappointed as I really wanted Davis.

Howard ended up as BPA for me after the failed trade up and he also still fills a need as an offensive weapon. Howard and Delanie Walker should cause some match up problems

-I had an early 3rd but traded back for 2 picks...a couple of guys I wanted went right before me so decided to trade back for quantity since I liked the depth left at WR instead of reaching.

- After that I really just went with value picks. Everybody has their own opinion, but I would honestly rank Awuzie, Ogunjobi, and Hansen all as top 75 talents in this draft class. Getting those 3 in the 3rd/4th would be a huge boost to any team. All 3 will contribute early and have good starter potential.

- Wilson was honestly a bit of a panic pick. I had 2 pass rushers ready to go as the pick (Rivers and Bowser) but both went within 5 picks of me. Scrambled looking for someone else before Risen pulled the plug on me and came up with a redshirt Soph 6'1 CB with high potential. I was on a Titans blog that literally listed their top 4 draft needs as CB so no problem double dipping at the position.
 
Last edited:

Teague31

Defender of the Star
Messages
18,221
Reaction score
22,842
Once again. I took the home town Chiefs. Didn't honestly do a lot of prep work on prospects but know plenty about the chiefs and their needs. On offense the goals were weapons in the passing game as well as interior lineman. On defense I wanted to draft a replace,met for Johnson at ILB and get a corner opposite Peters.

In Round 1 I was targeting Zack Cunningham. Think he is a perfect 3-4 ILB and was pretty sure he would fall to me. Alas, it wasn't to be as the dastardly raiders took him right before me. At that point I decided to go BPAwiyh my first pick. Took Deshone Kizer out of ND. I've seen him go too 10 in a bunch of mocks so getting him at 27 is a steal. Alex Smith is JAG and Reid should be able to do wonders with Kizer. Feel good about getting a potential franchise guy that late.

In Round 2 I thought again about trying to draft a LB but the value just wasn't there. So I turned myattention to corner. The chiefs other corner was a liability all season as teams started avoiding Marcus peters. Decided I would be happy with either Tankersly or Lewis with this pick. Once again the raiders were reading my thoughts as they took Tanks a few spots ahead of me. That made Jourdan Lewis out of Michigan the easy selection. Dude is a talent, if he was two inches taller he would be a top 20 pick. He will immediately start at one corner for KC.

In Round 3 my original plan was to take the best LB or G available. That all changed when Dede Westbrook fell all the way to the end of the third round. On talent he is a top 15 pick. Is rumored to be running in the 4.3 range. Of course their is the baggage with the Domestics. But KC struck gold with Tyrke Hill a year ago and go back to the well here. Westbrook is a day 1 starter in KC and gives thre chiefs some serious weapons in the passing game with maclin, hill and kelce.

Round 4- I had given up on finding a LB at this point and hope DJ comes back heathy. Targeted a couple of guards but they went before I picked. So went John Johnson out of BC. Insurance against Berry leaving and a good value as well. Not much of a run defender but should be a good coverage safety.

So ultimately I went against need and pretty much went BPA. Got two sure fire starters which alone makes it a good draft IMO. But they key is obviously Kizer. If Reid develops him into a star this is a home run draft
 

Alexander

What's it going to be then, eh?
Messages
62,482
Reaction score
67,294
Not one of my better drafts as I had some issues being online all day, but I think it turned out okay off of a list.

1(16) Dalvin Cook RB Florida St.
2(46) T.J. Watt OLB Wisconsin
3(79) Carlos Henderson WR Louisiana Tech
4(112) Elijah Lee OLB Kansas St.

Came into the draft looking for more firepower on offense and some rush help, plus a replacement for Zack Orr, who abruptly had to retire. Right tackle could be a need with Ricky Wagner as a FA. As bad as this class is, I think they will end up biting the bullet and paying him.

Cook was a target of mine simply because the Ravens need more explosiveness on offense. Kenneth Dixon and Terrence West are okay to move the chains, but a more dynamic player was needed and Cook fit the bill. He can be a weapon in the passing game that is sorely needed since Flacco is tanking it.

I missed my second rounder, thankfully the board vote went to the route I would have gone with an edge. Watt could end up being Suggs' replacement which needs to happen soon.

The third and fourth rounders came off a list. Amazingly, Vero_F250 took Smith-Schuster two spots in front of me and I had Carlos Henderson instead. Henderson's special teams abilities fill another big need as there really isn't a top contender on the Ravens' current roster. Elijah Lee will be tried as Orr's replacement since I think the Ravens are miscasting Correa inside instead of strong outside LB. He needs to bulk up but can play sideline to sideline and rack up tackles when kept clean, just as Orr functioned last season.

In the later rounds, I would load up on the secondary to get depth. Josh Harvey-Clemons, Lorenzo Jerome, Corn Elder, Jeremy Clark, Ashton Lampkin, etc.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,987
Reaction score
48,731
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Detroit Lions

Detroit has a wide range of needs they hope to address through the draft and free agency, including pass rush help, a thumper running back, corner back help, possible oline help if they lose Rief, and additional playmakers. at WR and TE.

1(21) Taco Charlton, DE, Michigan
Detroit badly wants additional pressure on the QB and desires a versatile DE to pair with Ansah. Charlton is a big and exceptionally talented DE who ranked 10th overall by Scout inc and 11th by McShay. He precisely what the Lions are looking for and they would be thrilled to get him at pick 21.. Charlton has steadily improved throughout his career and has nice upside from here to go with overall versatility at the position.

2(53) Gareon Conley, CB, Ohio State
With so much attention going to his teammate (Lattimore) Gareon Conley, a stellar CB in his own right, has been overlooked by some. He's seen rated as high as a late 1st rounder (drafttec) and usually in the 35-45 range, so when he was there at 53, I grabbed him. He has press-cover talent and NFL size and his capable of matching up with a wide range of receivers.
Detroit addresses another key need with value and versatility at corner.

3(85) D'Onte Foreman, RB, Texas
In the 3rd round at pick 85, Detroit was able to fill another big need with value by getting freight train running back Dante Foreman. Foreman was 2nd in the nation in rushing, won the Doak Walker award (nation's top rusher) and reminds many of Marshawn Lynch or a faster Jerome Bettis. The guy is 6'1 240+ and runs a legit 4.4 forty. Detroit has receiving backs but they need a stud. Foreman could be that guy. And often ranked in the 50 range, getting him a full round later at 85 represents great value filling a huge team need. He has part of his game he needs to work on--which is why he lasted into the 3rd round, but Detroit loves him at pick 85.

4(117) ArDarious Stewert, WR, Alabama
Alabama WR ArDarius Stwert represented exceptional value at pick 117 in the 4th round. He 's a crisp route runner who separates well and has great hands. He can play inside or outside and was rated as the 47th best prospect by Scout. CBS had him rated as low at 81, but that is still 1 round earlier than when Detroit grabbed him. He can also contribute on special teams.



You can't address all your team's needs with 4 draft picks--especially when you also want to get the best players you can--but I think Detroit addressed 4 needs with quality and value in this draft.
This a pretty weak line class but I kept paying attention for opportunities to get value there. I just didn't see it…and especially compared to they players Detroit was able to get at each draft slot.
If Riley Reif leaves as in FA, then Detroit will have to fill that void.in the same manner.


Anyway, thanks again for Risen for hosting. It was fun!
 

MichaelWinicki

"You want some?"
Staff member
Messages
47,997
Reaction score
27,917
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Other than the first round I thought I did well in the "Value compared to where picked" category...

Los Angeles Chargers (MichaelWinicki)
1(7) Marlon Humphrey CB Alabama
2(38) Jarrad Davis OLB Florida
3(71) Davon Godchaux DT LSU
4(102) Samaje Perine RB Oklahoma

That first pick was a challenge. I was hoping for one of the safeties, but it didn't happen.

San Diego is like several teams in that they have some offensive weapons, while lacking on the defensive side of the ball.

The rankings on corners seem to be all over the place... In some circles Marlon Humphrey is rated higher in the first round and some places lower.

The other 3 picks were pretty solid IMO. SD can use the help at OLB and at DT. And I think Perine is potentially a good all-around back who's big enough to block but also has some running/receiving skills.
 

KingintheNorth

Chris in Arizona
Messages
18,459
Reaction score
25,866
Cowboys

1(28) Takkarist McKinley DE UCLA – We felt this was a deep defensive draft so there wasn’t much urgency to trade up here, but to be able to get a player we had a top 15 grade on at 28 was a real win. McKinley checks all of the athletic boxes this front office looks for. This was a kid who ran the 100 and 200 meter for the state championships in California. He’s a pass rusher who is also a physical and relentless run defender. He will have a chance to have an immediate impact on defense.

http://www.nfl.com/draft/2017/profiles/takkarist-mckinley?id=2557872
takkarist-mckinley-UCLA_622.jpeg


2(60) Curtis Samuel RB/WR Ohio State – I couldn’t pass up the value here. We envision Samuel as an x-factor on offense and special teams. He can handle the roles the team had envisioned for both Lance Dunbar and Lucky Whitehead, as well as becoming the primary return man.

http://www.nfl.com/draft/2017/profiles/curtis-samuel?id=2558066
Ohio+State+v+Navy+PM3nkfUX5qhl.jpg


3(92) Justin Evans S Texas A&M – Evans is a physical and athletic safety who can play centerfield, allowing the defense to line up Byron Jones on tight ends or in the box. Evans is at times too aggressive, but usually makes up for it with great closing speed and a willingness to make punishing hits.

http://www.nfl.com/draft/2017/profiles/justin-evans?id=2557945
18994602-standard.jpg


4(123) Adam Bisnowaty T Pittsburgh – Another great value pick, we liked Bisnowaty’s Zach Martin-like mean streak. Although he played left tackle at Pittsburgh, we see him as Doug Free’s eventual replacement at right tackle, keeping La’el Collins at guard.

http://www.nfl.com/draft/2017/profiles/adam-bisnowaty?id=2557834
adam-bisnowaty-of-the-pittsburgh-panthers-in-action-during-the-game-picture-id613600622
 

Trouty

Kellen Moore baby
Messages
31,526
Reaction score
80,467
New England Patriots

Historically a defensive-drafting oriented organization, with Belichick at the helm. Their needs this draft are S, TE, LB, CB and G (with rumblings of the org. perhaps wanting to replace Blount). I went to chowderandchampions.com, Patriots.com, and ESPN to assess their top needs prior to the draft. I used CBS, Scout, and NFLDraftScout to assess this year's draft class.

My top three players for the Pats in the first round were TE OJ Howard, S Jabrill Peppers, and TE David Njoku. I had no shot at the 2 former (without a trade up, which I tried, but to no avail), but thought I had a legit shot at the latter. In true Belichick fashion, I even voted OL for DEN's pick, as that was a group pick, and I was trying to stave off my treasured TE. It didn't work. LOL

So:

RD 1 Pick 32 Desmond King CB Iowa

A very instinctive corner, with smallish height, but a wide frame. His speed is a little lacking, which is what dropped him in the class -- if he ran a 4/40, he'd be a top ten pick (he does have a low 40 time of 4.43, tho). King will shore up the Pats secondary and he proved in the Senior Bowl that he is ready for the pros. Won the Thorpe Award in 2015 with 8 ints. Is known and considered a true ball hawk (NFLDraftScout). Extremely physical. CBS has him as the 34th ranked player, while Scout has him 31st, and SI has him as the second best corner in the draft.

RD 2 Pick 64 Duke Riley OLB Iowa

Considered "a modern day linebacker" (Jeremiah), Riley is small and quick (6'1'', 230). He is all heart and gives 100% every play. He was LSU's MVP and Team Captain. Great at shedding blocks and getting to the RB, as he tallied 93 tackles his senior year, 9 for loss, and 1.5 sacks. Has an accurate first step, and standout closing speed (Brugler, NFLDraftScout). With the recent losses of Chandler Jones and Jamie Collins, and Belichick's desire to have a solid LB core, he was the best available pick, and fit the team's need. CBS had him ranked 84 (with a round 2-3 grade), same with NFLDraftScout. A small reach, perhaps, but this is the type of player Belichick loves, and he fits the team's needs.

RD 3 Pick 66 (trade up from 96) Marcus Williams S Utah

My favorite pick of my draft, but also my most costly -- as it costed me a 2nd (2018) and 4th (127) this year. Williams is a standout FS with a Scout rank of 62, CBS rank of 67. At my original pick in this round, there was no way I would land a quality S or TE, the only two pieces left needed to fill my selected team's biggest needs. a 2016 All-Pac-12 2nd Team, and 2015 All-Pac-12 1st Team S. He ranked second in the league in INTs (4), and INTs per game (0.40), 2 forced fumbles, 7 passes defended, 2 fumble recoveries, despite missing two games (2016). At 6'1'' 195, he isn't small by any stretch for his position, and he will fill out his frame as he enters the team's weight training program. Not fooled by play-action, and shows good awereness from the Zone, often staying deeper than the deepest WR in single-high safety. Another all-heart player who would be very coachable in Belichick's complex system.

RD 4 Pick 121 Isaac Asiata G Utah

Still needing a G, and with TE Butt already off the board, I went with the best available G left. At 121, Asiata represented great value for the spot, as CBS had him ranked as their 96th best prospect. NFLDraftScout has him listed at 96 as well. a very aggressive G (sometimes to his determinant), he is a very large body (6'3" 325) who can also swing to C. Extremely hard worker, and again, plays with a ferocious intensity. Think Suh, with Leary's temperament. Rarely, if ever cheated on initial contact and has the power to uproot defenders. A very good land for a team in search of a possible yr 1 starter, in the 4th round to boot.

Thanks for reading! :)
 

L-O-Jete

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,053
Reaction score
92
San Francisco 49ers (L-O-Jete)

As far as needs well... Pretty much everything except maybe 3-4 DE's which they've picked with top ten picks in the last 2 drafts.Mainly QB, where former darling Kaep has come crashing down. So my first problem was having a 2nd overall pick in a draft without any "sure fire" franchise QB and where the top 2 consensus players are DE's. So I wanted to trade out and try to get ammo for next years draft so I can get another crack at a franchise QB...
As anyone whose taken part in one of these trading down is hard and as expected the fish where not bitting, NO came knocking and I countered with a watered down version of the Wentz deal. Success!!! Then no... Luckily the Commish intervened and Vetoed the other deal and I was back on, it was a little lower than I liked (outside top10), but beggars can't be choosers and I still had hope my top guy Rueben Foster could be there since ILB rarely get picked in the top 10...

1(11) Mike Williams WR Clemson
Two picks before my turn the Bengals broke my heart, but when my pick came around I had the JuJo of this draft staring me in the face, he's big, fast, strong, athletic and produced in college and fills a bigger need then my top choice, so maybe this was fate getting me out of my own way and I get my "Playmaker" a year before my QB so when he get's here he has a certified #1 WR.

2(34) Charles Harris DE Missouri
As mentioned SF has spent valuable resources on the DL, but the pressure is not quite there yet, enter one of the best outside rushers in this draft. He's athletically gifted and just starting to scratch the surface since he barely played HS football. Probably the nimblest feet of all outside rushers in this draft.

3(74) Carlos Watkins DT Clemson
Continuing to try and make one of the more dominant groups in the NFL, I see that the main cog in the championship winning D is still available and jump at the chance to add him to the rotation. This is one of those guys that just gets it done, they pry and prod and nothing says he should be more than average, but somehow he gets better every year and his stats jump out.

3(96) Bucky Hodges TE Virginia Tech
By far the best talent available at this spot. In a superb class of TE's Bucky is the most impressive physical talent. New to the position there's a lot to learn, but the sky is the limit.

4(98) Brad Kaaya QB Miami
The couple of trades gave me extra picks in the top 100 and though I didn't see any sure fire franchise QB's there's some talent there that might be interesting to develop and Kaaya is in that group. Sort of reminds me of Dak, where coaches and teammates rave about the kid and scouts complain about mechanics. Let's not forget that he covers all but one of Parcells rules (3 year starter, Sr, graduated, start 30 games, win 23, 2-1 TD-Int ratio, 60+% Comp.) and the one he doesn't... Being a SR. which is probably the least relevant all things considered.

4(127) Marlon Mack RB South Florida
Hyde is a bruising RB and here's the lightning to his thunder. Hyde's running style had him a little fatigued at times now we give him breathers while making opposing D's hold their breath with this elusive HR runner than can score from anywhere.

All this and I got the ammo to be a power broker in next years draft:
Added 2018 1st Round Pick (New Orleans)
Added 2018 2nd Round Pick (New England)
 

Plankton

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,260
Reaction score
18,651
I had the luxury of being the Jaguars rep in this draft. Coughlin made me show up for this event 5 minutes early, so he's laying down the law already.

The Jaguars, despite adding a lot of talent in last year's draft, had an awful season. Much of it had to do with the complete regression of Blake Bortles. Bortles decision making, which was at best average going into the season, was especially bad, and mechanically, he was a mess. Despite having a terrific young receiving corps in Allen Robinson, Allen Hurns, Marqise Lee and Rashad Greene, coupled with a good receiving TE in Julius Thomas (who had a poor season), his production wasn't up to snuff. A good deal of it was on him, but the run game didn't produce as expected and the offensive line was very leaky (LT Kelvin Beachum was especially bad). With the investment in Bortles, and the lack of a real replacement option in this draft, a goal was to improve what was around him on the offensive line. With this draft not especially flush in good offensive line prospects, it removed this from being an option with #4 overall.

The Jaguars had also made some recent roster moves that put a focus on the team's direction. Beachum was released after a poor season in Jacksonville, leaving a hole at LT. There are reports that they are looking to do a trade with the Dolphins, moving another FA disappointment, Thomas, in exchange for Branden Albert, who could fill the vacancy at LT. The Jaguars also resigned FA DT Abry Jones to a four year deal, keeping the run stopper with the team. They also released another FA bust in Jared Odrick yesterday, opening up a need on the defensive line. Their defense, despite having good young talent like Jalen Ramsey, Dante Fowler, Jonathan Cyprien and Telvin Smith, and a big FA signing in Malik Jackson, didn't create turnovers at all. The Jaguars were 30th in the league in turnover differential, generating only 13 turnovers.

To me, this was the biggest need - adding playmakers on defense. Couple that with improving the OL, and possibly looking at a TE or RB prospect were my goals coming into this exercise.

1(4) Malik Hooker S Ohio St. - When looking at this draft class, when you think of playmakers, they don't look much better than Hooker. Despite only starting for a year, Hooker had seven interceptions at safety, and showed exceptional instincts against the pass. In many ways, he reminds me of Ed Reed in terms of his ball hawking skills. Adding him to a secondary with Ramsey, a combo of Cyprien (provided he comes back as a FA) and Tashaun Gipson and Davon House/Aaron Colvin at corner, and the Jaguars secondary is looking much better. He can stand to improve in tackling, but to me, there wasn't a better playmaker available at #4. He was the third ranked player on my board behind Myles Garrett and Jonathan Allen, and I figured that I would end up selecting him with this pick before the draft began. Couldn't be happier.

2(35) Forrest Lamp G Western Kentucky
- As mentioned above, fixing the offensive line was a priority going in, and in terms of value, this area of the draft presented some interesting options. I was keeping an eye on Garett Bolles as a potential steal if he slipped, but he went at #25. With other options such as Christian McCaffrey and Jarrod Davis, I had to balance the need vs. value debate. I had all three in the same tier of prospects, so I went with Lamp. Lamp was a LT for all but three games of his Western Kentucky career, and was a terrific player. He held up well when blocking Tim Williams and Jonathan Allen when WKU played Alabama. Lamp has very good feet, is a real technician, and is very smart. He's somewhat similar to Zack Martin in that he's a college LT whose arm length lends itself to playing inside. Lamp has short arms, but he has huge hands, and is a plug and play player at LG from day one. With Luke Joeckel likely to leave, he walks in as a starter at LG.

3(68) Chris Wormley DT Michigan - I held my breath that he would be available when I selected, as I had my eyes on him from the moment that my selection of Lamp happened. Wormley was the #42 guy on my board, so he was tremendous value, but he also fills a hole. I envision him as being a base LDE on run downs, similar to how the Seahawks used Red Bryant a few years ago, with the ability to kick inside on pass downs. Wormley is a powerful man who really shined last season in Michigan. He's another guy that I think walks in as a starter, replacing Odrick, and will provide needed interior heft against the run games of the Titans and Texans.

4(99) Kevin King CB Washington - I was keeping my eye on Bucky Hodges as he was dropping through the third round, and held out hope that he would drop to my pick here in the fourth round. Unfortunately, the 49ers stole him out from under me three picks before my selection. For this pick, after Hodges was picked, I was looking at both King and Brad Kaaya, who I had as the 79th and 80th players on my board, respectively. Kaaya was taken right before my selection, making my decision to take King a no brainer (I was going to do this anyway). I think that King is a very undervalued player in this draft, and will end up as a steal when this is done for real. King has been overshadowed by Sidney Jones and Budda Baker in the Washington secondary, but I love his length, ability to play press, and his hands (6 INT the last two seasons). Putting him opposite Jalen Ramsey gives the Jaguars two long levered, press corners who will make life difficult for opposing WRs. King will struggle a bit with smaller guys such as T.Y. Hilton, but against #2 guys like Donte Moncrief or Rishard Matthews, he matches up well. Being able to move Davon House to a nickel corner, and having Aaron Colvin available in the dime makes the Jaguars secondary far improved, and much better at playmaking than they were in 2016.

I was happy with my haul. Looking ahead to the fifth round, I was looking at guys like Tyler Orlosky to continue to solidify the offensive line, and then look to follow up with a TE like Michael Roberts or Eric Saubert, and look for a running back like Jamaal Williams or Corey Clement to add a potential weapon on offense.

I thought that the 49ers, the Cowboys, the Lions and the Steelers had very good efforts in this.

Great job as always by Risen Star in running this. Lots of fun, as always.
 
Last edited:
Top