Michael Irvin: 70% of the offensive problems are Mike McCarthy; Co-host says 80%

WillieBeamen

BoysfanfromNY
Messages
16,137
Reaction score
47,080
LOL yourself at thinking McCarthy is actually quality being held back by Dak.

They both are failing.
Dak has failed for 8 years now.

We have seen McCarthy turn a QB into an MVP.

The offense is bad because the coach does not trust the QB to throw interceptions. Idont know how much more evidence you need to see.




B b but Mccarthys last two years in GB!
 

VaqueroTD

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,804
Reaction score
17,698
Was listening to a show on Fox sports while driving home.

1. McCarthy does not play to the strengths of his receivers
2. Bland, basic play calling
3. Needs to be more creative with play design to get receivers open
4. Everyone knows when a run is coming
5. If you know Dak needs to get the ball out of his hands, run routes that allow that to happen

He didn't absolve Dak or the receivers.

1. Dak needs to know when to kill a play. He does things an 8-year vet should not be doing.
2. Receivers need to fight for the ball and get more separation. Dallas receivers are the third worst in the league in getting open.

But...Dak and the receivers are only running the plays called by McCarthy.

They brought up Aaron Rodgers thoughts as well: "I had to bail him out (MM) when the situations got tough. He made one wrong play call after another. He is the lowest IQ offensive coach I ever worked with."

Take heart fellow fans, we are not the only ones ripping McCarthy apart.
I just want to point out that the Playmaker was riding these guys's jocks pretty hard week 1-2.
 

beware_d-ware

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,790
Reaction score
9,574
Forget all that. What is the reason 8 years in, an offense has to to be dumbed down to short sale throws? Enormous hint; so it doesnt end up landing in the wrong jersey. Code name: West coast offense.
Homeboy was dummying it down when he had Aaron Rodgers. McCarthy is a stooge.
 

Mr_437

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,327
Reaction score
20,146
This is the longest football week I've experienced in a long time. The Cowboys are getting roasted and it's kinda good because these jokers get so cocky after a win.

Look no OC is perfect, and that's what ppl demand for Dak. No QB has the perfect WR group, and that's what ppl demand for Dak. There will never be a season where anyone will say Dak has the perfect support system around him. At some point, a QB has just make some s*** happen if your team is ever going to win big. Anyway, I so ready for Dallas to play the Chargers, so everyone can begin to move on.
 

foofighters

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,421
Reaction score
7,104
It all starts with the guy selecting the coaches.
The sad thing is that this is being set up perfectly for Jerry. Half the fans will hate MM. The other half will hate Dak. At the end of the season, one or both will be gone and a good number of the fanbase will be appeased. We will then start this vicious circle all over again.
 

phildadon86

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,481
Reaction score
32,240
LOL

Romo was an all pro under Linehan and Herbert is playing like an all pro under Kellen
Romo was an all pro because he had Demarco running for a franchise record amount of yards in a season.

Romo was also doing what Rodgers was doing. And completely changing plays at the line. Remember how many times the cowboys were snapping the ball with 1 second left on the play clock? Lol. Coaching has been an issue for a lot longer than McCarthy. People seem to forget.

Remember Dez? When I saw Romo move him into the slot I knew a slant was coming and we were going for 10 plus. Every time. Yet the coaching staff never put dez into that position on their own. I could go on but you get the point.
 

jblaze2004

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,982
Reaction score
11,225
Moore called the same type of plays. So Monday maybe a snooze fest.
In the beginning of the season Moore used a lot of motion and pre-snap movement. It just didn't continue to happen as the season went on. its like someone pulled the plug on it. I haven't watched the chargers this season so I don't know if they do much pre-snap movement on offense.
 

Adreme

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,892
Reaction score
3,704
LOL

We heard this w Linehan

We heard this w Kellen

We are hearing it w McCarthy

Who is the common denominator?
Except when we heard it with Kellen it was from people somehow not satisfied with being one of the top 3 offenses in football during his entire tenure. They somehow thought an offense should score 30 points every single game no matter who the opponent is. Those people are delusional.
 

glimmerman

Well-Known Member
Messages
30,560
Reaction score
30,276
In the beginning of the season Moore used a lot of motion and pre-snap movement. It just didn't continue to happen as the season went on. its like someone pulled the plug on it. I haven't watched the chargers this season so I don't know if they do much pre-snap movement on offense.
I remember that because first game of the season the commentators were even talking about it. Lasted about 3-5 games and they stopped it. I dont recall any confusion or penalties because of it. And I refuse to believe it was to hard for Dak to understand. People keep saying they can’t do this or that because it confuses Dak and he can’t handle it. He called the plays in preseason. Looked like he has a pretty good grasp of things. It’s time to let him take the wheel IMO. If he fails he can go. If he does a better job than the coach then that tells you something. I wonder if JJ don’t want Dak calling the plays because he can’t call down and have MM change things. If that was the case then we are all screwed. To find out he is that involved in the game would be insane.
 

nate dizzle

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,745
Reaction score
17,319
CowboysZone DIEHARD Fan
The sad thing is that this is being set up perfectly for Jerry. Half the fans will hate MM. The other half will hate Dak. At the end of the season, one or both will be gone and a good number of the fanbase will be appeased. We will then start this vicious circle all over again.
Check the poll. About 95% have it right.
 
Top