So here's my take:
When someone puts "you're gonna love this" as part of a post's title I think the gloves are pretty much off. Frankly, I rarely go for being told what I'm gonna love, but that's just me.
I did not get the impression that the content was written to stimulate an honest, thought-provoking discussion, especially in light of the dozen or more Jimmy Johnson threads that have hit the boards in the last couple of days (ok, maybe it's not a dozen), several of which have had more of the question-asking flavor to them. Items like "wouldn't this be cool???" and "the above is realistic" don't leave me with the impression that the content was thought through at all.
What happens to the next poster with less than X posts that creates yet another off-the-wall thread? They may not all fit in the ridiculous coching suggestions category. Maybe we need a comic relief zone where these things can be moved at the mods' discretion.
Now as sarcasm, I think it's brilliant, but we need a sarcasm smilie in that case.