NFC East by position-Best three WRs in the division

[jobberone]

Vote for the best three regardless of team. One team may have more than one WR picked. Instead of me boring you all with my reasons let me hear you guys tell us who and why.

 

[Pandora]

Where's Witten?

 

[dstovall5]

In the TE poll, this is for WR only.

My list is

1) Dez
2) Hakeem Nicks (When healthy H.Nicks > V.Cruz)
3) Victor Cruz
4) Miles Austin
5a) Jeremy Maclin
5b) Desean Jackson (More explosive than J.Maclin, but J.Mac is more consistent)
6) Pierre Garçon (Was off to a solid year but got hurt)
7) Santana Moss

 

[Ultimategamer5567]

Where's Witten?

He's a TE, not a WR, though he can be a better reciever than most WRs at times.

 

[dstovall5]

He's a TE, not a WR, though he can be a better reciever than most WRs at times.

I think if you put him in the group of WRs in the NFC East he'd rank between 4 or 5. I love witten, but he makes me mad sometimes when he turns around after the catch and pauses, though it could just be me expecting to much out of him hahaha.

 

[Echo9]

Picking Dez was easy, then I think Nicks is probably the next one on the list. @dstovall5 mentioned that he's better than Cruz when healthy. That reasoning then caused me to pick Austin as the 3rd best. (Although I'm sure my bias has something to do with it).

 

[Sonny#9]

I clicked the wrong one: I meant to pick Bryant over Austin. Mine were Bryant, Nicks and Maclin. Who is a step ahead of Garcon, mostly b/c Garcon was hurt all last year. I want to see him healthy before I pick him as a top-3.

 

[TellerMorrow34]

Bryant #1 - This was without question in my mind.

Nicks #2 - I agree that when he's healthy he's better than anyone else on that list and I really don't think it's very close.

Cruz #3 - Definately better than all the rest. Could make a strong case for him at #2.

 

[DFWJC]

In the TE poll, this is for WR only.

My list is

1) Dez
2) Hakeem Nicks (When healthy H.Nicks > V.Cruz)
3) Victor Cruz
4) Miles Austin
5a) Jeremy Maclin
5b) Desean Jackson (More explosive than J.Maclin, but J.Mac is more consistent)
6) Pierre Garçon (Was off to a solid year but got hurt)
7) Santana Moss

Pretty good list right there.
There are a lot of good WRs in this division!
The top 3 were fairly easy for me. jmo

If he stays healthy, I think Garcon could possibly move into the 4 spot though. He's very talented, but needs to show a full season in Washington.

 

[rkell87]

everybody is saying nicks>cruz but to me the proof is in the pudding, he has out shined nicks and proven himself to be more reliable as a pass catcher, more explosive, and more durable. That said, they are actually a pretty nice compliment to each other as hicks can make the tough contested catches and is a good redzone target while cruz can take it to the house from 80+

 

[tantrix1969]

In the TE poll, this is for WR only.

My list is

1) Dez
2) Hakeem Nicks (When healthy H.Nicks > V.Cruz)
3) Victor Cruz
4) Miles Austin
5a) Jeremy Maclin
5b) Desean Jackson (More explosive than J.Maclin, but J.Mac is more consistent)
6) Pierre Garçon (Was off to a solid year but got hurt)
7) Santana Moss

I'd rank Garcon over Maclin and DJax but otherwise my list is the same

 

[Future]

everybody is saying nicks>cruz but to me the proof is in the pudding, he has out shined nicks and proven himself to be more reliable as a pass catcher, more explosive, and more durable. That said, they are actually a pretty nice compliment to each other as hicks can make the tough contested catches and is a good redzone target while cruz can take it to the house from 80+

Without Irvin, there was no Harper. Without Nicks, there is no Cruz.

Ok, that might be a bit of an exaggeration, but the reality is that Nicks commands a lot of attention, and Cruz certainly benefits from that.

 

[EJ Blue]

Tier 1- Bryant, Nicks, Cruz
Tier 2- Austin, Garcon, Maclin, Jackson
Tier 3- Everyone else.

 

[thechosen1n2]

Bryant, Nicks, Cruz.

 

[dstovall5]

Interesting how Dez isn't a 100% selection, do some here actually believe there's 3 other WRs in the division who are better? Though I'm sure those few who didn't pick him are just trolling ...

 

[5Stars]

I voted for Moss in Washington. I'm not sure why.

 

[SportsGuru80]

Dez, Cruz and Jackson...

 

[BIGDen]

In the TE poll, this is for WR only.

My list is

1) Dez
2) Hakeem Nicks (When healthy H.Nicks > V.Cruz)
3) Victor Cruz
4) Miles Austin
5a) Jeremy Maclin
5b) Desean Jackson (More explosive than J.Maclin, but J.Mac is more consistent)
6) Pierre Garçon (Was off to a solid year but got hurt)
7) Santana Moss

That's how I would rank them as well.

 

[BIGDen]

I voted for Moss in Washington. I'm not sure why.

Perhaps you had just stepped into your time machine and you thought is was like 5 years ago.

 

[Risen Star]

Coale, Dez, Nicks.