NFL Draft Grades

ShortRound

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,096
Reaction score
80,117
Sports Illustrated: A+
https://www.si.com/nfl/2020/04/26/nfl-draft-2020-team-grades-picks-analysis

DALLAS COWBOYS
1 (17). CeeDee Lamb, WR, Oklahoma
2 (51). Trevon Diggs, CB, Alabama
3 (82). Neville Gallimore, DT, Oklahoma
4 (123). Reggie Robinson II, CB, Tulsa
4 (146). Tyler Biadasz, C, Wisconsin
5 (179). Bradlee Anae, DE, Utah
7 (231). Ben DiNucci, QB, James Madison

With Randall Cobb joining Houston, the Cowboys needed a new slot receiver. What they smartly realized is if they found one who could also play the “Z” position, going in motion and aligning outside, that would allow them to slide pricey star Amari Cooper into the slot, where he’s guaranteed to avoid the press-jam coverage that sometimes gives him trouble. Even better is that CeeDee Lamb himself can also play significant snaps inside, affording offensive coordinator Kellen Moore the ultimate flexibility with his first-round wide receivers. Expect to see even more of the creative pre-snap motioning and stack-release tactics from Moore this season.

Having Lamb and Cooper together almost assures that Michael Gallup, who is quietly developing into a nice “X” receiver, will often face one-on-one coverage. And in that same vein, it could mean lighter run boxes for Ezekiel Elliott. This is a quality pick with a potentially significant domino effect.

Right corner Byron Jones departed in free agency this year, and next year the Cowboys face losing left corner Chidobe Awuzie and/or slot/utility corner Jourdan Lewis, as both are finishing up their rookie deals. Don’t be surprised if Awuzie is retained and Lewis walks. But even if both return, an immediate and direct replacement for Jones is prudent, since it would allow Lewis to keep providing valuable, versatile depth on the back end. Trevon Diggs is a long-armed, physical corner and is stepping into a Mike Nolan-led scheme that, thanks to its expected emphasis on blitzing, will feature press-man on the outside. Dallas hit another home run in this draft, filling an important, specific need with a top-level talent at a later-than-expected draft slot. And in case they wind up losing both Awuzie and Lewis, they got a jump on replenishing their depth by also drafting Reggie Robinson in Round 4.

Up front, Neville Gallimore was yet another Cowboys selection whom many expected to be taken a lot higher. He is not a particularly large or long-limbed man, and so quickness and mechanics are key to his success. He showed those traits at Oklahoma; if he plays with more consistent leverage, he has a chance to be a contributing pass rusher.

Lastly, the Cowboys in Round 4 went after another Wisconsin center, Tyler Biadasz, after their previous one, Travis Frederick retired suddenly earlier this offseason. Biadasz was a three-year starter in a Badgers offense that had a dominant run game.

Grade: A+
 

ShortRound

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,096
Reaction score
80,117
PFF
COWBOYS A+
https://www.pff.com/news/draft-2020-nfl-draft-grades-for-all-32-teams

NFC EAST
DALLAS COWBOYS

Round 1 (17): WR CeeDee Lamb, Oklahoma
Round 2 (51): CB Trevon Diggs, Alabama
Round 3 (82): DI Neville Gallimore, Oklahoma
Round 4 (123): CB Reggie Robinson, Tulsa
Round 4 (146): IOL Tyler Biadasz, Wisconsin
Round 5 (179): Edge Bradlee Anae, Utah
Round 7 (231): QB Ben DiNucci, James Madison

Day 1: Dallas was one of the biggest winners of the first round, and it’s all because a few teams ahead of them made mistakes and handed them CeeDee Lamb at the 17th overall pick. Lamb was the sixth-best prospect on the PFF Big Board and is actually the third-best wide receiver prospect we have ever evaluated — behind only Amari Cooper and Jerry Jeudy. He’s a refined route-runner, has great ball skills and is lethal after the catch. Lamb is coming off a season in which he broke 26 tackles on 62 catches and averaged an incredible 11.0 yards after the catch per reception — both of which cracked the top five in the FBS.

Day 2: And the Cowboys’ steals didn’t stop with just Lamb — they continued to thrive on Day 2 with their 51st and 82nd overall picks.

“Cowboys are ripping the doorknob off this draft. Every pick they've made was much higher on the PFF Draft Board: 17 – CeeDee Lamb (PFF board: 6th), 51 – Trevon Diggs (31st), 82 – Neville Gallimore (51st).” – PFF Lead Draft Analyst Mike Renner on the Cowboys’ draft after Day 2

Trevon Diggs isn’t a fit for every scheme due to his athletic limitations, but he is the perfect fit for Dallas’ press-heavy scheme. In press this past year, Diggs allowed only nine catches on 33 targets while intercepting three and forcing seven incompletions.

There were a handful of interior defensive linemen taken over Gallimore who shouldn’t have been, and the Cowboys once again took advantage of others’ mistakes. Gallimore has incredible power and can be defined as a people-mover. There was some inconsistency with his performance in the pass-rush, but his power and burst is everything you could want at the position. If he can learn a few more moves, Gallimore will be an impact player.

Day 3: Dallas’ dream draft continued into Day 3 when they got two guys for great value in Tyler Biadasz (87th-best prospect on PFF Big Board) and Bradlee Anae (130th-best prospect on PFF Big Board). He’s one of the most accomplished run-blockers we’ve graded at PFF, with grades above 80.0 in all three years as a starter. The step back in pass protection this past season is concerning, though. He’ll have a chance to make an impact early with Travis Frederick’s retirement. As for Anae, he doesn’t have great athleticism for the position, but he has the skills that should have made him an earlier pick.

Draft Grade: A+
 

ShortRound

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,096
Reaction score
80,117
Sporting News
COWBOYS A+

https://www.sportingnews.com/us/nfl...-best-worst-classes/2bs9w101joku1lruu8r1xwt9f
3. Dallas Cowboys
Draft picks: WR CeeDee Lamb, CB Trevon Diggs, DT Neville Gallimore, CB Reggie Robinson, G/C Tyler Biadasz, Wisconsin, DE Bradlee Anae, QB Ben DiNucci

How about that guy Jerry Jones? Drafting from a yacht, he had the Cowboys living the absolute high life finding extreme value throughout the draft, starting with Lamb at No. 17 overall. Jones was laser-focused on their biggest needs and didn’t let the best available player pass him up, either. Lamb is a massive upgrade from Randall Cobb. Diggs and Robinson are good rebounds from losing Byron Jones in free agency. Gallimore gives them another way to get to the QB inside and Anae is capable of filling the edge void created by Robert Quinn. After seeing another reliable interior Badger retire from their offensive line in Travis Frederick, Biadasz was a steal, too.
 

ShortRound

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,096
Reaction score
80,117
SBNATION
COWBOYS B-

https://www.sbnation.com/nfl/2020/4/25/21235709/nfl-draft-grades-2020-winners-losers-final

Dallas Cowboys
I’m seemingly in the minority of not liking the selection of wide receiver CeeDee Lamb in the first round. It just didn’t make sense to draft a No. 2 wide receiver with the 17th pick when the team had so many glaring needs on defense. K’Lavon Chaisson, who was taken a few picks later, had value and filled a need.

Cornerback Trevon Diggs, nabbed in the second round, gives the Cowboys the player they needed in the secondary. He’s a big cornerback who should push for a starting job following the departure of Byron Jones. Defensive tackle Neville Gallimore was a nice pickup in the third round. If his production ever matches his athleticism, watch out. Tulsa defensive back Reggie Robinson II in the fourth round was a smart depth addition.

Grade: B-
 

ShortRound

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,096
Reaction score
80,117
USA TODAY A+
https://cowboyswire.usatoday.com/20...-nfl-draft-report-card-national-draft-grades/

Touchdown Wire: A+
“The Cowboys were already fairly loaded at receiver with Amari Cooper and Michael Gallup, but Jerry Jones decided to make Dak Prescott’s life even better with the first-round selection of Oklahoma’s CeeDee Lamb, the best overall receiver in this draft class. Yes, Jerry Jeudy is a slightly better route-runner, and Henry Ruggs III is faster, but nobody in class brings the complete package at the position like Lamb does. He’ll be a force multiplier outside and in the slot.

“Then, Dallas took Alabama cornerback Trevon Diggs in the second round — a natural press-man cornerback who has some elements of early Richard Sherman in his game. He’s a very different kind of player than Byron Jones, who went to Miami in free agency, but he gives Mike Nolan lockdown ability to one side.

“The Cowboys went with great players throughout their draft. I love the pick of Utah edge-rusher Bradlee Anae in the fifth round — he’s a smaller, twitched-up guy who can make bad things happen for quarterbacks. And defensive tackle Neville Gallimore from Oklahoma, their third-round pick, is a perfect one-gap interior disruptor. Add in Wisconsin center Tyler Biadasz, and Tulsa press cornerback Reggie Robinson II, and the Cowboys not only got a great haul, but they also established a clear paradigm for their cornerbacks.”
 

ShortRound

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,096
Reaction score
80,117
New York Post: A+
“Cowboys apparently trust their Southwest area scout. Lamb was the steal of the first round and the Diggs-Robinson combination softens the blow of losing free agent Byron Jones.”

Washington Post: B+
“Some were worried about what owner Jerry Jones would do with no one in the room to stop him, thinking of the time in 2014 that Jones supposedly had to be prevented from drafting quarterback Johnny Manziel over guard Zack Martin. The fears were unfounded. The Cowboys did well: WR CeeDee Lamb fell to them at No. 17 overall, and they came back to get the CB they needed with Trevon Diggs in the second round.”
 

RamziD

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,124
Reaction score
2,863
SBNATION
COWBOYS B-

https://www.sbnation.com/nfl/2020/4/25/21235709/nfl-draft-grades-2020-winners-losers-final

Dallas Cowboys
I’m seemingly in the minority of not liking the selection of wide receiver CeeDee Lamb in the first round. It just didn’t make sense to draft a No. 2 wide receiver with the 17th pick when the team had so many glaring needs on defense. K’Lavon Chaisson, who was taken a few picks later, had value and filled a need.

Cornerback Trevon Diggs, nabbed in the second round, gives the Cowboys the player they needed in the secondary. He’s a big cornerback who should push for a starting job following the departure of Byron Jones. Defensive tackle Neville Gallimore was a nice pickup in the third round. If his production ever matches his athleticism, watch out. Tulsa defensive back Reggie Robinson II in the fourth round was a smart depth addition.

Grade: B-

Lol, ok guy
 

ShortRound

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,096
Reaction score
80,117
https://fansided.com/2020/04/25/nfl-draft-grades-cowboys-packers-dolphins/

Dallas Cowboys: A
The Cowboys absolutely nailed the first two days of the draft. CeeDee Lamb falling to them at No. 17 was an absolute gift, but Dallas deserves credit for prioritizing his talent over the team’s needs.

Coming back on Day Two and landing Trevon Diggs and Neville Gallimore only strengthens the team’s grade. Both guys will play meaningful snaps for Mike McCarthy in his first season at the helm in Dallas.

Don’t lose sight of the team’s work on Day 3 either. Tyler Biadasz will help provide valuable depth at center after Travis Frederick’s decision to retire. Bradlee Anae could do the same at defensive end. Add it all up and the Cowboys had the best draft in the NFL.

New York Giants: C-
Another draft for Dave Gettleman and another poor exercise in resource usage for the Giants. Andrew Thomas is a talented tackle, but the team should have traded back from No. 4 to scoop him up.

Xavier McKinney has some fans in the scouting community, but he’s just not enough of a playmaker to merit a second-round pick. Higher upside safeties were definitely available when New York selected them.

Nothing about New York’s work on Day 3 did anything to raise their grade. Cam Brown is an intriguing choice at linebacker but he needs to show he can run much faster than he did at the Combine. Chalk this up as another bad draft from Gettleman and his front office.

Philadelphia Eagles: C
The Eagles threw two of the biggest curveballs of the draft. Jalen Reagor has a lot of athleticism, but there were certainly more polished options available at wide receiver when Philadelphia scooped him up in the first round.

Then came the Jalen Hurts pick in Round 2. That’s a steep price to pay for a backup even if he finds a way to contribute in special packages right away. Do the Eagles know something about Carson Wentz that fans don’t?

Both John Hightower and Quez Watkins improve the team’s speed at wide receier, but there’s a reason both guys lasted until Day Three. Prince Tega Wonogho ups the team’s grade slightly as a quality reserve at offensive tackle. The Eagles just took too many wild swings to earn a good grade.

Washington Commanders: B+
The Commanders draft class will be defined by just how great Chase Young can become. Getting the most talented player in the draft is always good for your final grade. He’ll do wonders for the Washington defense.

Antonio Gibson in Round 3 was a curious reach. He flashed big play potential at Memphis, but it’s unclear how he’ll get the ball at the NFL level. At the very least, the Commanders should have filled a more pressing need with that selection.

In sharp contrast, Keith Ismael could turn into a real steal for the Commanders. Getting a potential starter on the offensive line in Round 5 is good value for any team. Young is the difference maker here, but Washington could have done slightly more to fill around him with more quality.
 

Tangle_Foot

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,187
Reaction score
28,405
This is a great draft and I hope it is the sign of things to come.
Tangle_Foot gives this draft a Platinum AA++ :thumbup::thumbup:
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
77,324
Reaction score
95,981
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
USA TODAY A+
https://cowboyswire.usatoday.com/20...-nfl-draft-report-card-national-draft-grades/

Touchdown Wire: A+
“The Cowboys were already fairly loaded at receiver with Amari Cooper and Michael Gallup, but Jerry Jones decided to make Dak Prescott’s life even better with the first-round selection of Oklahoma’s CeeDee Lamb, the best overall receiver in this draft class. Yes, Jerry Jeudy is a slightly better route-runner, and Henry Ruggs III is faster, but nobody in class brings the complete package at the position like Lamb does. He’ll be a force multiplier outside and in the slot.

“Then, Dallas took Alabama cornerback Trevon Diggs in the second round — a natural press-man cornerback who has some elements of early Richard Sherman in his game. He’s a very different kind of player than Byron Jones, who went to Miami in free agency, but he gives Mike Nolan lockdown ability to one side.

“The Cowboys went with great players throughout their draft. I love the pick of Utah edge-rusher Bradlee Anae in the fifth round — he’s a smaller, twitched-up guy who can make bad things happen for quarterbacks. And defensive tackle Neville Gallimore from Oklahoma, their third-round pick, is a perfect one-gap interior disruptor. Add in Wisconsin center Tyler Biadasz, and Tulsa press cornerback Reggie Robinson II, and the Cowboys not only got a great haul, but they also established a clear paradigm for their cornerbacks.”

I am shocked they gave us an A+. They usually don't like anything Dallas, but a few articles this off season they have given us some props.
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
77,324
Reaction score
95,981
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
So this year we CARE about draft grades. Lol....;)

I don't get into rankings or grades too much, but sometimes it is fun to see them good or bad, as most cases they have some bias to them. But nice to see all the good things they are saying this year. But when they hit the field, we shall see.
 

ShortRound

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,096
Reaction score
80,117
The score is still around?

https://www.thescore.com/nfl/news/1969308

Dallas Cowboys

Grade: A
It's difficult to envision a bigger winner from the 2020 draft than Jerry Jones' squad. Though receiver wasn't the Cowboys' biggest need, selecting Lamb - easily the top remaining prospect on the board - was a no-brainer. The value picks didn't end there. Diggs, Gallimore, Biadasz, and Anae each could have been selected earlier than their slot, and all of them address Dallas' greatest needs. The Cowboys might be NFC East favorites after a stellar draft.

New York Giants
Grade: A-
Kudos to Dave Gettleman. The Giants general manager came into the draft with a plan and he executed it well. Thomas wasn't the consensus top tackle prospect but he has All-Pro potential and will make life easier for Daniel Jones. McKinney represents outstanding value at No. 36 and fills a major weakness. From Round 3 onward, New York hauled in a few solid players at key roster positions - including Peart, who has long-term starter potential at right tackle. After two questionable drafts, Gettleman's 2020 class looks great on paper.

Philadelphia Eagles
Grade: C

It's easy for Eagles fans to be disappointed. With CeeDee Lamb within striking range, the famously aggressive Howie Roseman opted to stay put and allowed a premier wideout to fall to a division rival. Reagor addresses the team's biggest need, but he still feels like a reach. Meanwhile, the Hurts selection was among the draft's most puzzling. Roseman may want to build a "quarterback factory," but there were numerous talented prospects available that would have immediately aided a Super Bowl contender. Philadelphia uncovered a ton of value on Day 3, but it wasn't enough to compensate for the team's early woes.

Washington Commanders

Grade: B
Washington came away with a solid, if unspectacular, 2020 class. As the consensus top overall prospect, Young should immediately terrorize opposing blockers, while Gibson, Gandy-Golden, and the two offensive linemen help improve Dwayne Haskins' supporting cast. We especially love Gibson as a versatile weapon. Overall, the Commanders nabbed a handful of potential contributors while addressing most of their weaknesses.
 

KingintheNorth

Chris in Arizona
Messages
17,449
Reaction score
23,975
I absolutely agree with the grade and think it's between us and Baltimore on who had the best drafts.

I just want to point out some of the hypocrisy going on in this forum. When the Cowboys draft, let's just say not as well, and these websites and newspapers grade it low, everyone on here is screaming "These guys are morons!" and "way too early to tell."
 

ShortRound

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,096
Reaction score
80,117
Wu2mHuD.png
 

aria

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,543
Reaction score
16,793
https://fansided.com/2020/04/25/nfl-draft-grades-cowboys-packers-dolphins/

Dallas Cowboys: A
The Cowboys absolutely nailed the first two days of the draft. CeeDee Lamb falling to them at No. 17 was an absolute gift, but Dallas deserves credit for prioritizing his talent over the team’s needs.

Coming back on Day Two and landing Trevon Diggs and Neville Gallimore only strengthens the team’s grade. Both guys will play meaningful snaps for Mike McCarthy in his first season at the helm in Dallas.

Don’t lose sight of the team’s work on Day 3 either. Tyler Biadasz will help provide valuable depth at center after Travis Frederick’s decision to retire. Bradlee Anae could do the same at defensive end. Add it all up and the Cowboys had the best draft in the NFL.

New York Giants: C-
Another draft for Dave Gettleman and another poor exercise in resource usage for the Giants. Andrew Thomas is a talented tackle, but the team should have traded back from No. 4 to scoop him up.

Xavier McKinney has some fans in the scouting community, but he’s just not enough of a playmaker to merit a second-round pick. Higher upside safeties were definitely available when New York selected them.

Nothing about New York’s work on Day 3 did anything to raise their grade. Cam Brown is an intriguing choice at linebacker but he needs to show he can run much faster than he did at the Combine. Chalk this up as another bad draft from Gettleman and his front office.

Philadelphia Eagles: C
The Eagles threw two of the biggest curveballs of the draft. Jalen Reagor has a lot of athleticism, but there were certainly more polished options available at wide receiver when Philadelphia scooped him up in the first round.

Then came the Jalen Hurts pick in Round 2. That’s a steep price to pay for a backup even if he finds a way to contribute in special packages right away. Do the Eagles know something about Carson Wentz that fans don’t?

Both John Hightower and Quez Watkins improve the team’s speed at wide receier, but there’s a reason both guys lasted until Day Three. Prince Tega Wonogho ups the team’s grade slightly as a quality reserve at offensive tackle. The Eagles just took too many wild swings to earn a good grade.

Washington Commanders: B+
The Commanders draft class will be defined by just how great Chase Young can become. Getting the most talented player in the draft is always good for your final grade. He’ll do wonders for the Washington defense.

Antonio Gibson in Round 3 was a curious reach. He flashed big play potential at Memphis, but it’s unclear how he’ll get the ball at the NFL level. At the very least, the Commanders should have filled a more pressing need with that selection.

In sharp contrast, Keith Ismael could turn into a real steal for the Commanders. Getting a potential starter on the offensive line in Round 5 is good value for any team. Young is the difference maker here, but Washington could have done slightly more to fill around him with more quality.
Sounds like a Cowboys fan wrote this one? C- for the Giants? That’s laughable. The writer acts like the Giants had an offer to trade back when there has been no indication of that. They addressed one of their biggest areas of need with 3 of the first 5 picks. I think their GM is an incompetent jerk but almost every site has given them an A- higher.

On the other end of the spectrum, I’ve seen the Commanders graded much lower on several sites.

All of these rankings are such a joke. As dumb as they are, thanks for consolidating them all into one thread @ShortRound131
 
Top