Nick Wright's NFL QB Pyramid

[Yobwocs]

Even Nick Wright, one of Dak's biggest critics puts him in an upper tier, among names who the media claims are great. Hmh.... I wonder who I should trust.... members of this forum or the NFL media. Tough one.

 

[Robbieac]

This is a Joke.
Why is Williams even on here? He isn’t even in the NFL. The list is completely invalidated.

Dake above Stafford? Yeah right.

Dak IS Kirk Cousins until he proves otherwise.

And Dak was simply outplayed by Mr Irrelevant Purdy, who is way far down the list.
If we swapped Dak with Purdy, we would have beat the 49ers.

 

[Yobwocs]

This is a Joke.
Why is Williams even on here? He isn’t even in the NFL. The list is completely invalidated.

Dake above Stafford? Yeah right.

Dak IS Kirk Cousins until he proves otherwise.

And Dak was simply outplayed by Mr Irrelevant Purdy, who is way far down the list.
If we swapped Dak with Purdy, we would have beat the 49ers.

This guy doesn't understand that the 49ers were better than us on most positions... LOL. WR, TE, DL, LB, RB, PK. We can even argue the others.

And yes, Dak is above Stafford. His one Super Bowl doesn't change the fact that he had to be traded for that to happen. He had 1 Pro Bowl prior to that despite being in the league for 15 years. and never once above 100.0 rating before that year.

 

[RoboQB]

It appears that the "NFL media" doesn't even know who plays QB in
the NFL.

"Williams, Williams... Buehler, Buehler?"

 

[RoboQB]

I'd question anyone who thinks Jared Goff is a 6th tier QB.
Yet, Detroit is everyone's pick as an up and coming team primed to
make some noise.

Dude threw 7 picks all year. None after week 9. They were the hottest
team in the second half of the NFL season. There was a collective
sigh of relief when they barely missed the playoffs. Nobody wanted to
play them.

 

[Yobwocs]

I'd question anyone who thinks Jared Goff is a 6th tier QB.
Yet, Detroit is everyone's pick as an up and coming team primed to
make some noise.

Dude threw 7 picks all year. None after week 9. They were the hottest
team in the second half of the NFL season. There was a collective
sigh of relief when they barely missed the playoffs. Nobody wanted to
play them.

I agree, Goff is underrated in general, and a Top 10 QB. He was among the 4 QBs who destroyed the Eagles defense.

Still, Dak is Top 10. Nick isn't wrong there. Dak was also among that 4. And all of them are in Nick's top 10. It's no coincidence.

 

[Robbieac]

I agree, Goff is underrated in general, and a Top 10 QB. He was among the 4 QBs who destroyed the Eagles defense.

Still, Dak is Top 10. Nick isn't wrong there. Dak was also among that 4. And all of them are in Nick's top 10. It's no coincidence.

You know you can trust a guy who has Caleb Williams in his top 6. It’s all completely legit.

Williams destroyed the Eagles defense too, if I’m not mistaken….

 

[RoboQB]

I agree, Goff is underrated in general, and a Top 10 QB. He was among the 4 QBs who destroyed the Eagles defense.

Still, Dak is Top 10. Nick isn't wrong there. Dak was also among that 4. And all of them are in Nick's top 10. It's no coincidence.

Doesn't his mistakes deter your trust in the NFL media though?

My dog is smarter than Nick Wright... and I don't even have a dog.
I'm saying I could go to the pound tomorrow, adopt any dog and that
pooch would be smarter than this guy. (lol)

If he's wrong about Goff and is unaware of Williams still being in college,
can't he be wrong about Dak too? I think most sane people will put Dak
somewhere between 8 and 12 overall. That's top 25-33%. Nothing to be
upset over.

 

[America's Cowboy]

Doesn't his mistakes deter your trust in the NFL media though?

My dog is smarter than Nick Wright... and I don't even have a dog.
I'm saying I could go to the pound tomorrow, adopt any dog and that
pooch would be smarter than this guy. (lol)

If he's wrong about Goff and is unaware of Williams still being in college,
can't he be wrong about Dak too? I think most sane people will put Dak
somewhere between 8 and 12 overall. That's top 25-33%. Nothing to be
upset over.

11-12? That's a joke. Dak is easily a top 10 QB...still...every year.

 

[Yobwocs]

Doesn't his mistakes deter your trust in the NFL media though?

My dog is smarter than Nick Wright... and I don't even have a dog.
I'm saying I could go to the pound tomorrow, adopt any dog and that
pooch would be smarter than this guy. (lol)

If he's wrong about Goff and is unaware of Williams still being in college,
can't he be wrong about Dak too? I think most sane people will put Dak
somewhere between 8 and 12 overall. That's top 25-33%. Nothing to be
upset over.

If there's nothing to be upset about, I don't understand what you're combating. He has Dak in exactly the same spot you claim most sane people have him at.

I'll ignore the Williams thing and chalk it up as fanboy enthusiasm.

 

[RoboQB]

11-12? That's a joke. Dak is easily a top 10 QB...still...every year.

I literally said between 8-12.
Dude threw 15 picks last year, so, no, not every year.

 

[America's Cowboy]

I literally said between 8-12.
Dude threw 15 picks last year, so, no, not every year.

Big deal. Almost half of those picks weren't even his fault. Romo TWICE threw for more picks in a season, but I bet you never chastised him for it.

 

[RoboQB]

If there's nothing to be upset about, I don't understand what you're combating. He has Dak in exactly the same spot you claim most sane people have him at.

I'll ignore the Williams thing and chalk it up as fanboy enthusiasm.

I'm not combating anything. Must every discussion be war?
Geez, nobody knows how to conversate anymore.

 

[NotForLong]

Trust your eyes

Even Nick Wright, one of Dak's biggest critics puts him in an upper tier, among names who the media claims are great. Hmh.... I wonder who I should trust.... members of this forum or the NFL media. Tough one.

 

[Robbieac]

Big deal. Almost half of those picks weren't even his fault. Romo TWICE threw for more picks in a season, but I bet you never chastised him for it.

You are either being ignorant or dishonest.

Dak threw 15 INTs in only 12 games!!!

It took Romo 16 games to accomplish what Dak only did in 12.

 

[America's Cowboy]

You are either being ignorant or dishonest.

Dak threw 15 INTs in only 12 games!!!

It took Romo 16 games to accomplish what Dak only did in 12.

You're simply incapable of admitting almost half of those INTs were not Dak's fault. Mike Martz broke every interception down. You think you know more than him?

 

[Robbieac]

Again. Most SANE people have Dak somewhere between 8-12.

"Oooh, that's ignorant! He's top ten every year!"

How about you just walk away.

Agreed. And what is worrisome is that Dak has shown signs of regressing these past 2 years with leading the leage in INTs in only 12 games as well as 2 embarrassing playoff loss performances.

I hope he gets it corrected, but time will tell.

 

[Yobwocs]

You are either being ignorant or dishonest.

Dak threw 15 INTs in only 12 games!!!

It took Romo 16 games to accomplish what Dak only did in 12.

Romo threw 19 INTs twice. 16 games. 1.18 per game

Dak threw 15 INTs in 12 games. 1.25 per game

Not much of a difference to me. I don't think Dak is Cousins. Cousins always underwhelms in primetime games. Dak shines in 55-60% primetime games... I think that's their biggest difference.

 

[RoboQB]

Agreed. And what is worrisome is that Dak has shown signs of regressing these past 2 years with leading the leage in INTs in only 12 games as well as 2 embarrassing playoff loss performances.

I hope he gets it corrected, but time will tell.

I'm hopeful that with Big Mike calling plays, some of that regression will
go away.

It's difficult to discuss football on here, or even just have a little fun.
There always seems to be someone's kid stirring up nonsense that
seemingly goes undetected.

 

[America's Cowboy]

I'm completely comfortable with a fool like yourself judging me.
You come off as a spoiled child unable to carry on a conversation
with anyone that may disagree with you.

Again, for the third time, most sane people have Dak between 8-12.
That's 8, 9, 10, 11, 12. You threw a tantrum over two spots.
Talk about ignorant. Settle down, son.

Name those sane people with NFL experience. Like I said, the experienced ones clearly have Dak in the top 10...and it obviously bothers you.