Nick Wright's NFL QB Pyramid

[ChronicCowboy]

So stupid…these ranking can change week to week. NFL coverage is just annoying now.

 

[Adreme]

This is a Joke.
Why is Williams even on here? He isn’t even in the NFL. The list is completely invalidated.

Dake above Stafford? Yeah right.

Dak IS Kirk Cousins until he proves otherwise.

And Dak was simply outplayed by Mr Irrelevant Purdy, who is way far down the list.
If we swapped Dak with Purdy, we would have beat the 49ers.

Again pretty much every GM, scout, and coach has Dak in the top 10 and Kirk in the 12-17 range. So when you say you think Dak is Kirk you should probably also explain why a group of people whose job it is to evaluate players, see film on all of them, and know their strengths and weaknesses, have all placed Dak far higher than Kirk, and why you are right and they are wrong.

 

[GINeric]

This is a Joke.
Why is Williams even on here? He isn’t even in the NFL. The list is completely invalidated.

Dake above Stafford? Yeah right.

Dak IS Kirk Cousins until he proves otherwise.

And Dak was simply outplayed by Mr Irrelevant Purdy, who is way far down the list.
If we swapped Dak with Purdy, we would have beat the 49ers.

Dak above Stafford is EXACTLY correct. Dak's career winning percentage smashes Stafford's.

Did you realize that Matt Stafford's record vs winning teams is a whopping 11-72?? Yeah... exactly.

And if you're going to bring up winning a Superbowl with the Rams... he led the league in interceptions that year, so the Rams won inspite of Stafford.

15 other quarterbacks would have won the Superbowl with that particular Rams team that season.

 

[Momanpr100]

Who the hell is Williams lol

 

[GINeric]

Again pretty much every GM, scout, and coach has Dak in the top 10 and Kirk in the 12-17 range. So when you say you think Dak is Kirk you should probably also explain why a group of people whose job it is to evaluate players, see film on all of them, and know their strengths and weaknesses, have all placed Dak far higher than Kirk, and why you are right and they are wrong.

Believe it or not.... you actually have people here that said they believe that they know more about football/NFL quarterbacking than other NFL scouts, coaches and GMs who are paid millions to do this daily.

It's hilarious when these lil minions believe in themselves that much.

 

[Chuck 54]

It’s his rating. He’s basically saying that he'd take Caleb Williams as “his” QB if he owned a team over all the QBs below him. The only reason Rodgers is lower is his age, not his ability for 2023.

 

[charron]

This is so wrong it's almost comical.

 

[Robbieac]

And if you're going to bring up winning a Superbowl with the Rams... he led the league in interceptions that year, so the Rams won inspite of Stafford.

15 other quarterbacks would have won the Superbowl with that particular Rams team that season.

Huh? Did you even watch the playoffs that year? Stafford had one of the best playoff stretches for a QB in NFL history with a QB rating of 108. He was on fire during that run.

If Dak would do the same, we would all about be guaranteed to with the Super Bowl as well.

And don't even bring up Stafford's time with the Lions. If Dak was drafted by the Lions, he would have been out of the league after a few years.

 

[Robbieac]

And if you're going to bring up winning a Superbowl with the Rams... he led the league in interceptions that year, so the Rams won inspite of Stafford.

Foot meet mouth.

Dak led the leage in interceptions last year but played in 5 less games than everyone else. Did the Cowboys win in spite of Dak last year?

Lolololol

You can't make this stuff up. Dakvidians will say anything!

 

[blueblood70]

Romo threw 19 INTs twice. 16 games. 1.18 per game

Dak threw 15 INTs in 12 games. 1.25 per game

Not much of a difference to me. I don't think Dak is Cousins. Cousins always underwhelms in primetime games. Dak shines in 55-60% primetime games... I think that's their biggest difference.

troy Aikman td-int ratio is worse in the regular and post season than either of those guys,, roger also had years where he averaged more than 1int per game.. ie 14 games 15-16 INts.. the difference is none of the guys were perfect they had far better coaching and teams.

roger

td 153-109 ints Playoffs 24td 19INTs(umm none of those critical LMAO) UMM OK



Troy-

165-141 playoffs 23tds-17 INts(right none critical huh?) no way jimmy would have put up with that



Dwhite

155-132 playoffs 15-17 WOW no way TL puts up with mistakes at critical time LOL



Romo

248-117 playoffs 8 tds 2 INts show me the critical INts hmm his td-int ratio is much better



Dak

166-65 playoffs 11-5ints

 

[PackersNation]

The only reason Rodgers is lower is his age, not his ability for 2023.

Did you not see Aaron play last season? Why do you think the Packers happily traded him to the Jets for a fairly big haul? One, they are extremely confident in J-Love, but two, Aaron played like crap for a majority of the season last year.

I love Aaron and think he WAS one of the best to ever do it, but Aaron is not now what he was even two years ago. No doubt, he is on the decline. Does he now suck? Not totally yet, but this year and the future is no doubt brighter with J-Love.

No one here rated Hurts anywhere near the top of QBs before last season. You can say anything you want, but J-Love is more talented than Hurts. The arm strength of Jordan Love is light years above Hurts for one.

No one outside of Wisconsin is at all prepared for Jordan Love to be a very good QB. This time next year a lot of people are going to be singing a different tune.

Stay tuned...

 

[baltcowboy]

I like Caleb Williams but he is barely over 6’0. I think there is a good chance that Maye goes ahead of him. The kid is 6’4 and has a rocket for an arm.

 

[MonsterD]

Who the hell is Williams lol

Caleb Williams USC going to be 1st pick overall 2024.

 

[Chuck 54]

Did you not see Aaron play last season? Why do you think the Packers happily traded him to the Jets for a fairly big haul? One, they are extremely confident in J-Love, but two, Aaron played like crap for a majority of the season last year.

I love Aaron and think he WAS one of the best to ever do it, but Aaron is not now what he was even two years ago. No doubt, he is on the decline. Does he now suck? Not totally yet, but this year and the future is no doubt brighter with J-Love.

No one here rated Hurts anywhere near the top of QBs before last season. You can say anything you want, but J-Love is more talented than Hurts. The arm strength of Jordan Love is light years above Hurts for one.

No one outside of Wisconsin is at all prepared for Jordan Love to be a very good QB. This time next year a lot of people are going to be singing a different tune.

Stay tuned...

Did you see his OL? Did you see his receivers? Rodgers forced his way out of GB because he wanted out. Give me a playoff team, and Mahommes is the only QB I’d take over him.

 

[GINeric]

Foot meet mouth.

Dak led the leage in interceptions last year but played in 5 less games than everyone else. Did the Cowboys win in spite of Dak last year?

Lolololol

You can't make this stuff up. Dakvidians will say anything!

Ok, now let's compare Dak's overall career record and winning percentage to Stafford's.

Conversation over.

I'll give you an "A" for effort though kid!!

 

[PackersNation]

Did you see his OL? Did you see his receivers? Rodgers forced his way out of GB because he wanted out. Give me a playoff team, and Mahommes is the only QB I’d take over him.

Ummm, the roster was very good. Aaron himself never said the roster was bad. He didn't want to leave Green Bay. Aaron said MANY times he wanted to play his whole career in Green Bay.

Aaron after the trade: "The Packers were ready to move on. I have nothing but love and gratitude for Green Bay."

You haven't seen every snap of Aaron's career like I have. He is not now the same QB he was from 2008 thru 2021. Like I said, I'm not saying Aaron is a horrible QB right now, but he is no doubt on the decline.

 

[5Stars]

Big deal. Almost half of those picks weren't even his fault. Romo TWICE threw for more picks in a season, but I bet you never chastised him for it.

Romo.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

This guy gets it.

he would, probably. it would have to be a back up getting him the rings. he would be injured on the sideline.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Believe it or not.... you actually have people here that said they believe that they know more about football/NFL quarterbacking than other NFL scouts, coaches and GMs who are paid millions to do this daily.

It's hilarious when these lil minions believe in themselves that much.

those same folks hopped on the Cowherd band wagon, because he criticized Dak. they made Cowherd into an idol on their worship mountain

 

[Robbieac]

Ok, now let's compare Dak's overall career record and winning percentage to Stafford's.

Conversation over.

I'll give you an "A" for effort though kid!!