They hate Eli far more. He's such a weird QB. Went on these two amazing playoff runs, but otherwise, he's turnover machine with an aw-shucks hillbilly mannerism in a place that doesn't like anything hillbilly.
52 and 48 sack defenses will certainly help you out. Manning had a
56.1 completion percentage in 2007 and a passer rating of 73.9. Romo has never had anything like it in ANY season...even 2015. 2011 was indeed a special year for him, with nearly 5,000 yds passing, but even then he only completed 61% of his passes, with a passer rating of about 93. He also had a high number of INTs that year (29 to 16). The division was also horribly weak that year...including a Cowboys team that blew a 12 point lead (in Dallas) with five minutes to play...a game that might have effectively ended the season for the Giants, who had lost four straight games (6-6) coming in.
His career completion percentage is 59.6%.
He is not the QB you want on a team with a bad o-line and an average or bad defense. He has never really been a consistently accurate or prolific passer. I put him in with Donovan McNabb.