Official officiating thread

Yakuza Rich

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,043
Reaction score
12,385
I can't see how the refs call that PI on Brown. Rodgers over-threw the receiver by 25 YARDS. Do they really think that was catchable? I personally think it was holding, but it was PHYSICALLY IMPOSSIBLE to be pass interference.




YR
 

jamesdojr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,036
Reaction score
374
Lets go back to the Seattle/Giants game last week where the Seattle CB tackled the Giants WR and they said the pass was not catchable when it obviously would have been without the mauling. Then yesterday, Brown gets flagged for PI on a very obvious uncatchable ball that Heath picks off and GB keeps the ball and kicks a FG. Worse thing about that play is that if Brown hadn't touched the WR, Heath would have still picked it. That's how uncatchable that ball was. Yet when the refs admit they screw calls up, it's like "oh well". I never fully bought in to the "bias ref" thing until the past two years, and I still can't believe there are some who still think it doesn't exist after watching this years playoffs. I'm not just talking about the Cowboys games. 20 years from now we're going to see some old washed up ref on his death bed admitting to sticking it to certain teams he didn't like or was betting on the other team and there will still be those here that don't believe it happens.....

Yep. They will also admit that the directive came from league offices. It will happen. All the NFL has to do is tick off the wrong person, and the beans will be spilled.
 

Rack

Federal Agent
Messages
23,906
Reaction score
3,106
That mugging of Irving on the Cook pass was ridiculous. Absolutely no excuse for not calling that.

The Brown PI was defensive holding at worst. No way was that PI.
 

Seven

Messenger to the football Gods
Messages
19,301
Reaction score
9,892
I get the mindset, but to me it boils down to 3 questions

1) Why was that penalty called for the first time in what, 30 years? Does anyone think Dallas doesn't get at least 3 points with 1st and 10 from the GB 15?
2) Does anyone not think Witten was interfered with? Does anyone think Dallas doesn't get a TD on 1st and Goal from the 1?
3) On a 3 man rush, with barely any time in the game, how is a DL that gets triangle choked leading to a loss, not called?

And those are just the blatant ones. That changed the dynamic entirely. The story that the "team was asleep", doesn't quite fit when the 10 points in the first half were negated by bad officiating. Being up 23-21, or even being down just 21-17 at end of the first half, is a completely different game.

Yes, there was questionable game management, as there is in every game. But, even calling the obvious hold sends it into OT. In a game that was decided as time expired, bad officiating changed the game.

In a well called game, accurate game, we win. Even just a slightly "less bad" called game, and we probably win. There is no "plain and simple" if that's the case. Rodgers was easily the best player on the field, but the better team lost yesterday. And until someone can prove that's incorrect, those are the facts.

This goes beyond Cowboys football, this is a league issue. When "overcoming terrible calls" and discounting calls that directly influence the game becomes unimportant, the product that we all know and love is going to continue to be a big pile of garbage where Champions are crowned not by skill, but by how hard the officiating decides to screw you.
HOW does Mr. Rodgers NOT get a flag for his chin strap pasted to the side of his helmet during a play not get flagged?

Isn't the NFL all about safety? Isn't that a rule?

Guys have been fined for socks for Christ sake......

I just, for once, would like to compete with GB and not have the refs dictate the game. Just once.......
 

sweetness0986

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,319
Reaction score
2,388
The Dallas Cowboys are a guaranteed ratings bonanza.

The NFL would love to get a Cowboys/Patriots Super Bowl, it would break everything that has ever been measured.


Wow, that's insane.

Anyone have video of the David Irving chokehold on that last play?
 

DogFace

Carharris2
Messages
13,588
Reaction score
16,088
When I visit another team's board and the first thing I see is an officiating thread that is several pages long, I know what I think. You probably think the same thing, when it's another team's fan base.

We lost. It sucks, but only one team gets the trophy at the end of the season.
Examine the evidence and facts and see if there's credibility. Maybe both are wrong. Maybe not.
 

Floatyworm

The Labeled One
Messages
23,018
Reaction score
21,190
I'm absolutely disgusted by the reffing. That was the most atrocious display of obvious bias I have ever witnessed. GB was getting away with holding on the offensive line all day and that last non-call on Roger's last pass was inexcusabley uncalled. I'm done with this game. There is no longer any doubt in my mind that it is a rigged game as far as biased officiating is concerned.

I cashed my chips in 2 years ago after the Dez no catch fiasco. NFL has pretty much lost me as a fan.:rolleyes:
 

Phoenix

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,814
Reaction score
1,419
Question: In the (I think it was) the 1st quarter, when GB QB rushed a play to catch Dallas with 12 on the field, why did the GB offense not get flagged for illegal procedure on the same play? I'm pretty sure the line was never set for even a single second. They all rushed up and immediately the ball was snapped.
 
Top