Biggems;1927559 said:
I can't believe you left off Randy Moss, Lawrence Phillips, and Sean Taylor.......all of whom had a decent laundry list prior to the draft. And then there is Reggie Bush, who knowingly broke NCAA violations......come on Reggie, do the right thing, give Vince the Heismann that you stole.....
Then there are those boneheads who do one or two things just before the draft....like Najeh DooDooport.....
Oh, I was down on them to, to varying degrees... I just cited a couple-three times I've gotten judgemental on players before, the first ones that came to mind...
My point is, before any of us go labelling any player a "character issue", we really ought to go find out exactly what it is he supposedly did... the things that have gotten McFadden that label are NOTHING, when you look at them closely... this has all been discussed before, but I'll repeat the facts here briefly:
1) He got into an altercation outside a bar before the start of one season, in the process of the melee he kicked at somebody and broke his toe on the curb... sounds bad, but it seems that he and some friends caught some thieves stealing his cousin's car... I mean, the were in the car, had the engine started, when they were caught in the act and pulled from the car... and when the cops came, McFadden wasn't charged with anything...
2) He got into another fight a few weeks back, again outside a bar, where he got pissed because somebody sucker-punched his brother... this time, there was no brawl, but apparently when the cops got there, he was ranting and raving, and they put him in cuffs for a time to chill him out... again, he wasn't charged with anything...
In these two incidents, all we learn is that he hangs out around bars late at night, and that when provoked, he can get angry... but from where I sit, two things stand out-- he WAS provoked in both situations, and the police ultimately judged that what he did was not sufficiently egregious to cause them to arrest him... I'd suggest that if the NFL went to putting red flags on every player who likes to hang out in bars, and can get angry when provoked, they wouldn't be able to fill out two teams' rosters...
3) A local TV station ran a story about McFadden's mother getting an expensive Cadillac Escalade, and D-Mac was seen driving it... the story went that an agent had brokered the deal for her... well, the problem is, the agent in question is strictly an agent for NBA players, he's not even licensed to represent NFL players, and the agent can apparently prove that he was not in Little Rock at the time in question... that TV station ultimately ended up having to publicly apologize to both the agent and McFadden himself...
Of course, that still leaves the question of how McFadden's momma could afford such an expensive vehicle, but I'm guessing that once the story blew up on the TV station, that station and the rest of the Arkansas media looked into the matter REAL close, and nobody found anything inappropriate...
Those are the three "character issues" that we have been told about; I ask you, does any of that sound like a big deal to you?? Can you think of a reason to move this guy down your draft board based on THAT??
BTW, I don't like DMac and I don't want him in Dallas.....I would be irate if we sold the farm to draft him.....and this has nothing to do with character....
Can you elaborate?? Do you have some problem with his game, or is it just the "sell the farm" thing that bothers you??