One thing is clear of this fanbase on QB talent assessment

[J12B]

A majority of fans are terrible at assessing the talent level at the QB position.

Heard so much about how good Milton is going to be and that he's a real possibility to take over the QB1 spot when Dak is gone.

After what he showed tonight, Milton looks like a QB3. Nothing impressive at all about his game.

A lot of fans here don't know football.

 

[Chasing6]

A majority of fans are terrible at assessing the talent level at the QB position.

Heard so much about how good Milton is going to be and that he's a real possibility to take over the QB1 spot when Dak is gone.

After what he showed tonight, Milton looks like a QB3. Nothing impressive at all about his game.

A lot of fans here don't know football.

Big arm and backflips does not translate to NFL starting QB.

 

[DuncanIso]

A majority of fans are terrible at assessing the talent level at the QB position.

Heard so much about how good Milton is going to be and that he's a real possibility to take over the QB1 spot when Dak is gone.

After what he showed tonight, Milton looks like a QB3. Nothing impressive at all about his game.

A lot of fans here don't know football.

Yup.

NFL scouting puts out a draft profile on all players.

Milton’s is a train wreck.

After Lance left, Jerry had to do something.

 

[DuncanIso]

Dallas needs a vet QB to backup Dak.

Remember 2015?

 

[Kwyn]

A majority of fans are terrible at assessing the talent level at the QB position.

Heard so much about how good Milton is going to be and that he's a real possibility to take over the QB1 spot when Dak is gone.

After what he showed tonight, Milton looks like a QB3. Nothing impressive at all about his game.

A lot of fans here don't know football.

Umm, are you sure you’re not just being selective in your memory of the past few weeks?

All anyone has agreed on is that he has a big arm.

Most people have recognized that he has difficulty with reads, progressions and accuracy.

A small, but not insignificant number of regulars feel he’s worthy of being a project that is brought along for the next year or two.

Maybe three people think he should replace our starter, but they also thought the same about Cooper Rush, Ben Dinucci, Chad Hutchinson and Kevin Sweeney.

 

[leeblair]

A majority of fans are terrible at assessing the talent level at the QB position.

Heard so much about how good Milton is going to be and that he's a real possibility to take over the QB1 spot when Dak is gone.

After what he showed tonight, Milton looks like a QB3. Nothing impressive at all about his game.

A lot of fans here don't know football.

Anyone who thinks Dak Prescott is NFL caliber doesn't know how to judge quarterbacks.

 

[Shane612]

He should convert to a slot receiver or CB.

 

[ShortRound]

 

[plasticman]

A majority of fans are terrible at assessing the talent level at the QB position.

Heard so much about how good Milton is going to be and that he's a real possibility to take over the QB1 spot when Dak is gone.

After what he showed tonight, Milton looks like a QB3. Nothing impressive at all about his game.

A lot of fans here don't know football.

None of us understand football to the degree that we could become professional scouts but even those guys routinely miss.

All 32 teams missed on Tom Brady for 5 rounds. Almost all would have taken Jamies Winston or Marcus Mariota if they had the first pick in the 2015 draft.

And one preseason game doesn't define a career.

 

[FoxF]

Dak’s job security looking good.

 

[KJJ]

I told everyone to tap the brakes on Milton. It’s still early and he could develop but he was a sixth round pick for a reason. Some were spinning that he was better than Dak because they want him to be better. Any QB we bring in they’ll be fans talking them up because they want them to take over for Dak. It was the same thing when we traded for Trey Lance.

 

[Reid1boys]

Anyone who thinks Dak Prescott is NFL caliber doesn't know how to judge quarterbacks.

wait... so you are saying a guy that was 2nd in MVP voting is not an NFL caliber player? Im not even a dak fan, but your statement is IGNORANT.

 

[America's Cowboy]

A majority of fans are terrible at assessing the talent level at the QB position.

Heard so much about how good Milton is going to be and that he's a real possibility to take over the QB1 spot when Dak is gone.

After what he showed tonight, Milton looks like a QB3. Nothing impressive at all about his game.

A lot of fans here don't know football.

I told y'all so.

 

[big dog cowboy]

After what he showed tonight, Milton looks like a QB3. Nothing impressive at all about his game.

And none of that matters going into preseason game #2.

 

[Pass2Run]

A majority of fans are terrible at assessing the talent level at the QB position.

Heard so much about how good Milton is going to be and that he's a real possibility to take over the QB1 spot when Dak is gone.

After what he showed tonight, Milton looks like a QB3. Nothing impressive at all about his game.

A lot of fans here don't know football.

On the other hand, Will Grier flashed some talent.

He's got a little bit of that Romo moxie in him. I'll always remember that game when he beat Texas. My team got beat but he played a memorable game.

 

[Pass2Run]

Yup.

NFL scouting puts out a draft profile on all players.

Milton’s is a train wreck.

After Lance left, Jerry had to do something.

He's more successful when they run shorter to medium routes. He can throw it long. But he tries to sling it in from too far away and it gets him in trouble.

Accuracy has always been his issues. Great took set except for the poor decision making and inaccuracy problem.

 

[Doomsday]

Dallas needs a vet QB to backup Dak.

Remember 2015?

Don't worry the QB isn't going to see the field much with this defense.

 

[DanTanna]

One little indicator I use to judge a young QB is what the fans of his college thought of him. Georgia fans COULD NOT WAIT for Quincy Carter to leave. Tennessee fans thought Milton was average to below average as a college QB. Nuff said.

 

[Kwyn]

He should convert to a slot receiver or CB.

He’s way too big and doesn’t have the speed for either role.

 

[Kwyn]

wait... so you are saying a guy that was 2nd in MVP voting is not an NFL caliber player? Im not even a dak fan, but your statement is IGNORANT.

Don’t give it too much thought. He thought Cooper Rush could be a Super Bowl QB.

That being said, Dak is no longer in the category of a top ten QB imo.