Our defense in the 5 playoff losses in last decade

Bobhaze

Staff member
Messages
19,753
Reaction score
79,380
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
In the last decade, the Cowboys have played in 7 playoff games, winning 2 and losing 5. The two wins in the last decade were a 2018 wild card win vs Seattle and a 2021 wild card win vs Tampa.

The five playoff losses in the last decade are what I want to focus on here because the similarities in what caused those losses are glaring. Those losses aren’t all on the defense. Yes, Dak has some blame for sure. But it’s not all on him either.

Here are the 5 playoff losses in the last decade:
  • 2016 L 34-31 vs packers in divisional round at home.
  • 2018 L 30-22 vs rams in divisional round on the road.
  • 2021 L 23-17 vs niners in wild card round at home.
  • 2022 L 19-12 vs niners in divisional round on the road.
  • 2023 L 48-32 vs packers in wild card round at home.
I want to look at our common problems in these playoff losses and whether they have been addressed. Here are some stats that show patterns in the 5 playoff losses:
  • Cowboys defense in the 5 playoff losses:
    • Avg giving up 31 points per game. (Take out the GB loss and still avg giving up 27 ppg)
    • Avg giving up 157 yards per game on the ground. (Take out the 273 in the 2018 rams L and we still avg giving up nearly 130 yds per game on the ground)
    • 3rd down conversions. In the 5 playoff losses of the last decade, our defense allowed 30 of 58 3rd downs to be converted. 52%!! Horrible.
    • Despite being one of the best sack teams in the league, the Cowboys only had 4 total sacks in all 5 playoff losses. Less than 1 per game.
    • Despite being one of the better defenses to create TOs, our D only had 3 TOs created in the 5 playoff losses.
These 5 losses weren’t all on the defense. Yes, Dak has played poorly at times, especially the last two playoff losses. But if we are being objective, he’s not been as bad as our defense.

Because if you avg giving up 30 points in a playoff game, avg giving up 157 yards rushing in the playoffs, and allow the opponents a 52% third down conversion rate, can’t sack the QB or get TOs, it’s pretty hard to win.

Does the FO understand this yet?
 
You would think that a team would TIGHTEN up on a part of the season where it's 1 loss and your out, we actually LOSEN up!! We've got to fix this, hopefully CULTURE changes will help us get better in these games!
 
In the last decade, the Cowboys have played in 7 playoff games, winning 2 and losing 5. The two wins in the last decade were a 2018 wild card win vs Seattle and a 2021 wild card win vs Tampa.

The five playoff losses in the last decade are what I want to focus on here because the similarities in what caused those losses are glaring. Those losses aren’t all on the defense. Yes, Dak has some blame for sure. But it’s not all on him either.

Here are the 5 playoff losses in the last decade:
  • 2016 L 34-31 vs packers in divisional round at home.
  • 2018 L 30-22 vs rams in divisional round on the road.
  • 2021 L 23-17 vs niners in wild card round at home.
  • 2022 L 19-12 vs niners in divisional round on the road.
  • 2023 L 48-32 vs packers in wild card round at home.
I want to look at our common problems in these playoff losses and whether they have been addressed. Here are some stats that show patterns in the 5 playoff losses:
  • Cowboys defense in the 5 playoff losses:
    • Avg giving up 31 points per game. (Take out the GB loss and still avg giving up 27 ppg)
    • Avg giving up 157 yards per game on the ground. (Take out the 273 in the 2018 rams L and we still avg giving up nearly 130 yds per game on the ground)
    • 3rd down conversions. In the 5 playoff losses of the last decade, our defense allowed 30 of 58 3rd downs to be converted. 52%!! Horrible.
    • Despite being one of the best sack teams in the league, the Cowboys only had 4 total sacks in all 5 playoff losses. Less than 1 per game.
    • Despite being one of the better defenses to create TOs, our D only had 3 TOs created in the 5 playoff losses.
These 5 losses weren’t all on the defense. But if you avg giving up 30 points in a playoff game, avg giving up 157 yards rushing in the playoffs, and allow the opponents a 52% third down conversion rate, can’t sack the QB or get TOs, it’s pretty hard to win.

Does the FO understand this yet?
Offense is 11 players + Scheme+Playcalls+execution by 22 players on Offense , Offense is spelled OFFENSE not DAK Prescott...​
You know what as much as some of that make sense,​
you're leaving out things why do you use the word dak has some blame how about the offense has some to blame yes, the offense, the total offense that would be the offensive line, who in one game had 11 penalties, so our quarterback was supposed to function playing behind a chains all game? The one common thing on offense if you want to stay away from the defense, I get it the defense is responsible for most of the losses in the playoffs going back to the Romo days... However,​
the one game 11 penalties on the offensive line, the most consistent thing is no run game under 3 YPC with no big runs, no significant key plays, is what they bring to the playoffs..​
that would be on the offensive line, that will be on the runner ,that would be on the game plan, the execution, and then when there is any time to throw which every once in a while it did happen, there was a lack of separation, so let's bring in all of the offense when you're blaming the lack of scoring or the lack of 3rd down percentage put it on the offense not DAK alone....​

I mean,

I'm doing this from memory,

I don't need to go back and look and by the way one of those 49er games, I don't care if it was a six point low scoring game,

in the first half they gave up 10 yards per carry to Deebo Samuels and kept the ball away from our offense and didn't give us much chances and it must be the same game or one of the 49er games that Trayvon Diggs dropped an easy interception and then failed to make contact with Kittles on a pass that he was bobbling..

if you just were to make contact, he probably doesn't catch that ball that was a big and I mean a big play in that game. Those were key bad execution by a defender that is supposed to be one of our prime time players but once again he's on defense and he didn't make the place he should have he didn't make the plays he's paid to make...

We're going to do this whole yes the defense is to blame and yes Prescott is somewhat to blame no no no no no let let let's call it the offense and not name our offense, prescott, he's one of 11 players ,he's not the coaches he's not the referees he's not responsible for all those mistakes yeah he looked bad in some of those games but there was a reason he looked bad it's called the offensive line and the run game was nonexistent in many of those games so let's stop calling our offense prescott that's not how it's spelled...

That's just some of the ones from memory but if we want to go just to the Green Bay game that looked mostly defensive and I realized Prescott made some mistakes but go cherry picked the two interceptions let's break those down and you'll realize the interference on Brandon Cooks not once but twice cause the leverage that created the interception had nothing to do with Prescott and also Lamb who didn't finish running his crossing route or post or whatever was supposed to be Prescott released that ball thinking that's what was going to happen and Lamb went rogue he went off script he broke his plate upfield because I guess he felt like the play was broke down and supposedly that is all on the quarterback now the interceptions must be on the quarterback unless we actually go reasonably break them down..

So yeah everyone blaming Prescott always started the game real bad it must be him the interceptions are not always on the quarterback we learned that in 2022 so why don't we just keep the blame where it needs to be we lost as a team there are significant problems across the entire three phases and the coaching staff in every one of those games...
 
Just these 3 stats are mind blowing!

Giving up 31 ppg, 157 yds rushing and allowing 52% 3rd down conversion rate! You can’t beat anybody with that kind of defense!
Over under 6 pages . I’ll take the over and btw you are spot on
 
Just these 3 stats are mind blowing!

Giving up 31 ppg, 157 yds rushing and allowing 52% 3rd down conversion rate! You can’t beat anybody with that kind of defense!
Yes almost all defensive and when you look at the offense you do realize in all our losses it's under 3 yards per carry and there are no impact plays from the run game at all and the offensive line for the most part played horrible they played on our side of most of those games of our side of the line of scrimmage it was a dirty pocket it's a dirty word using the word pocket the fact that they couldn't open up any holes and then one game they had eleven penalties I mean it's easy to see the trenches are the worst part of our teams and then our quarterback had struggles because of those problems..

Not winning games if you can't run the football and stop the run we all know it but there are bigger problems that mental mistakes and execution on all three phases and coaching that is why we need to stop the nonsense...

They are not giving our quarterbacks from the last two decades a chance to win these games when you can't run the football and you're losing time of possession by not being able to stop the run it's just needs to be blamed on the entire team..

It gets all we have to keep revisiting this but most of us even with our memory can tell you where the problems were and it wasn't at quarterback the quarterback yes he struggles but most quarterbacks are going to struggle when the defense knows they can use four players to stop the run on the way to the quarterback and then use a zone that's so dirty and hard to get players open then it pretty much shut your offense down and then your defense is just bad from the first snap to the last snap in most of those games even the ones they look good in they....e they gave up ten yards per carry to Samuals.. When you can eat up time of possession in a low scoring game and it looks low scoring so it must be great defense no it was solid defense at times but they were still getting ran over in those scoring drives that ate up so much clock it gave our offense less opportunities..
 
I've been saying this all off-season and all I got was "YoUrE A DaK fAn" when I'm clearly not. Smh
Well it's not just this offseason we've been saying this for 20 years it's happened to Romo it's happening to the Prescott when you can't win in the trenches you can't run the football you can't stop the run or play defense in almost all the losses it's been a glaring problem on the offensive line OH-1 game they had 11 penalties and they couldn't run the football and they couldn't block for nothing and even when they finally looked like they could execute receivers were not getting open or they were running the wrong routes or they were going rogue they're creating environments of where you get interceptions yes Prescott plate bed yes he struggled he was not great but there were reasons you can't dismiss on why he didn't play well...
 
5 sacks? Could that be, in part, because Parsons fades down the stretch? Plays too many snaps early on and wears down.

I want to see him more at LB this year. We have all kinds of edge players. Plus, we need help against the run.
 
I am sure the team is aware of all of that. But still choose not to do much about it is a big issue.
You can't fix everything in one off season. But it sure would help if they tried to do more than they have done.

They are probably confident that Eberflus and his new staff can fix, or at least make better the issues with the players they have and what they did with a few lower end FA's.

I know many fans will disagree with that, based on previous bad results. And understandable, we all are.

Again, we are back to, all we can do is see how it works out, and hope for the best.
 
5 sacks? Could that be, in part, because Parsons fades down the stretch? Plays too many snaps early on and wears down.

I want to see him more at LB this year. We have all kinds of edge players. Plus, we need help against the run.
I agree and the coaches won’t even take him out on blowout wins, he is young and wants his stats but it takes a toll on his body. McCarthy should have been stronger than that.
 
I am sure the team is aware of all of that. But still choose not to do much about it is a big issue.
You can't fix everything in one off season. But it sure would help if they tried to do more than they have done.

They are probably confident that Eberflus and his new staff can fix, or at least make better the issues with the players they have and what they did with a few lower end FA's.

I know many fans will disagree with that, based on previous bad results. And understandable, we all are.

Again, we are back to, all we can do is see how it works out, and hope for the best.
Jazz I agree with you that you can’t fix everything in one off-season. But how many offseasons have we known that we can’t stop the run?

Hey I’m glad we got George Pickens. But this defense is still way below what it needs to be and the frustrating thing is, we’ve known it for a very long time. DTs are not as sexy as WRs to Jerry.
 
I agree and the coaches won’t even take him out on blowout wins, he is young and wants his stats but it takes a toll on his body. McCarthy should have been stronger than that.
That has to get annoying for his teammates.

In hindsight, McCarthy was kind of a fraud. He thought everything was like anything else.
 
And our leaders on defense (the all pros) are the worst group of leaders in cowboy history on defense. Good luck improving those numbers in December/January
 
5 sacks? Could that be, in part, because Parsons fades down the stretch? Plays too many snaps early on and wears down.

I want to see him more at LB this year. We have all kinds of edge players. Plus, we need help against the run.
TJ watt 0-4 1 sack in 4 games SOOOOOOOO.. Maybe it's because when they double and triple him nobody else is making any plays..similar for Garett 1-3 1 sack in 3 games.. Joey bosa not much better. The only pass rusher I know of with a big name that Nick Bosa has a great winning record and a great amount of sacks in the payoffs.. Now could that be because of the San Francisco defense has more guys who can pressure along the defensive line and at linebacker that they don't count on just one guy?
Can we stop doing this I mean on offense everyone picks out prescott is the scapegoat everyone blame him one player, On defense now it's Parsons it's his fault


Literally this is a team game and there are problems across the board with the scheme the play calling and all of the players not stepping up when it's necessary that is why we just easier to say the team has been disappointing in the bigger games against the better opponents it's been going on for a while demarcus wear didn't do a whole lot in the playoffs either not with the Cowboys.. I remember some of that was said about him as well no signature plays when it counts you know it's odd though when he goes over to Denver and has Von Miller on the other side how all of a sudden the narrative change..

If we can get to the playoffs this year in some of these players like Fowler and Eazy E and others step up if we can get overshown back and really apply pressure maybe it wouldn't look so bad but when a team looks over there and go hey if we stop that guy there probably can't do anything.. Teams aren't capable of doing that..

Cowboys have to find a way to counter that's why you get to blame the coaches as well....
 
That has to get annoying for his teammates.

In hindsight, McCarthy was kind of a fraud. He thought everything was like anything else.
Well sometimes it is the coaching but calling him a fraud? garrett didn't do much more, dan Quinn's a fraud, he's a regular season beat up on weak team fraud look at what happened to the NFC Championship game look at what happened when he played our backups his team didn't look very good his defense was exactly what we thought it was he was thoroughly embarrassed in that championship game, he looked just like that here in the playoffs as well...

So yeah, I guess the coaches are all frauds or is it just the whole entire team got outplayed and out coached that's what it looked like to me plenty of blame to go around
 
Does the FO understand this yet?
The biggest contributing factor to the defensive woes is being weak up the middle leading to not being able to control the running game which leads to giving up third down conversions.

Management has focused on the flash on the outside and paid lip service to the middle.

It's almost impossible for me believe that a management team with over 3 decades of experience at the pro level doesn't even begin to understand how this works so for me the question becomes, Does the FO care about this yet?
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
465,605
Messages
13,885,921
Members
23,791
Latest member
mashburn
Back
Top