Overrated / Underrated

[Pessimist_cowboy]

Overrated :
Demarcus Ware -so many offsides in his career . Talk about an unclutch player throughout his career , no discipline or contain vs the run .

Bruce Carter - i have a bad feeling about this guys work ethic. He looks slow and overweight compared to last season.

Ernie Sims- i dont think this guy belongs in the NFL

JJ Wilcox- yes i know its hard to put this guy on this list after 2 starts but he takes some bad angles and i am not impressed with his tackling thus far

Ron Leary- He has poor lateral movement and has been average to below average pass blocking. He is by far our worst OL.

Tyron Smith - He has been our 2nd worst OL this season. Costly penalties and often seem to get overpowered on run plays.

Dez Bryant- yes i know dez is a beast. But, he has costs us huge this season. That 3rd down drop against the chiefs , that HUGE 3rd down drop against the chargers to kill the drive and that huge fumble against denver. He has so much talent but he needs to become a smarter player.

Demarco Murray- he is 4th in rushing in the entire league but the more i watch him the more i miss a runner with a good center of gravity , great balance and good vision. Murray is a decent RB but i wouldnt hesitate taking a RB in the top 2 rounds next year. An explosive back with ability to break tackles is needed.

Underrated :
Tony Romo - the guy is having his best season of his career and he has this embarrassing defense . Its so sad if he had a good defense we would easily have won this game today.

George Selvie- he is having a great season , if i am jerry jones i sign him now to a cap friendly deal (we are going to lose spencer and with ware owed 12 million next year who knows ?

Brandon Carr - its rare teams even throw at him , he is a very solid CB

Orlando scandrick - he is having an outstanding season he held welker to just one catch today (when he was covering him)

Doug Free - has been our best OL this season and maybe he was injured last season ? props to free for getting himself together this offseason.

Phillip Tanner - i say give this guy a chance , he seems to make plays.

Cole Beasley - great hands , great route runner , he just makes good things happen when he has the ball.

 

[CowboyStar88]

Can't take this post serious when you include
Ware
Dez arguably our best player on the team man? Overrated? Guy has almost 500 yards and 6 TDs already. Yikes
Smith
In the overrated category and say that Sims doesn't belong in the NFL. That tells me you don't know much about Ernie at all. Also including a rookie who has started all of 3 games? That's insane man. He made need some work but that's ridiculous how do you expect people to take you serious? You made some good points on some players but you won't be taken serious with posts like these

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

Can't take this post serious when you include
Ware
Dez
Smith
In the overrated category and say that Sims doesn't belong in the NFL. That tells me you don't know much about Ernie at all. Also including a rookie who has started all of 3 games? That's insane man. He made need some work but that's ridiculous how do you expect people to take you serious?

ernie sims is terrible , go watch film. Dez is a beast but he has cost us huge this season. Ware is washed up.

 

[danielofthesaints]

It's past your bedtime OP. You need some sleep.

 

[Gameover]

Agree on Beasley. I wouldn't even say Dez is our best receiver, he isn't close to being our best player.

 

[CowboyStar88]

Agree on Beasley. I wouldn't even say Dez is our best receiver, he isn't close to being our best player.

Huh?? Who is our best WR? Oh boy are you serious?

 

[popp1234]

Agree on Beasley. I wouldn't even say Dez is our best receiver, he isn't close to being our best player.

Who is our best receiver, if not Dez?

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

Agree on Beasley. I wouldn't even say Dez is our best receiver, he isn't close to being our best player.

Dont get me wrong i love Dez . BUT , he does have critical mistakes this season and huge costly ones. The only other knock i have is late in games he tires down. He goes all out every play so he may get tired at the end. Work on conditioning and being smarter thats all.

 

[Gameover]

Huh?? Who is our best WR? Oh boy are you serious?

I'm really starting to like this Williams kid. Warts and all. Look at the production the last two weeks and not just td.

 

[Bay10]

You said Tyron has been the 2nd worst O line man this year. Dude you are tripping. Tyron has been damn good this year. He's becoming that that tackle we all hoped he could become when we drafted him.

 

[CowboyStar88]

Dont get me wrong i love Dez . BUT , he does have critical mistakes this season and huge costly ones. The only other knock i have is late in games he tires down. He goes all out every play so he may get tired at the end. Work on conditioning and being smarter thats all.

He worked his butt off on conditioning. I think what you see is Dez is one of those rare guys who doesn't take plays off and it shows when he tires out.

 

[tico]

I stopped reading after Dez, really you should of waited until hangover Monday!

 

[CowboyStar88]

I'm really starting to like this Williams kid. Warts and all. Look at the production the last two weeks and not just td.

I like him as well but let's be real Dez is a generation talent and he is a beast to say he isn't the best WR in the team just isn't the case at all. The kid is one of the best in the league. I think him and Williams compliment each other a lot

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

You said Tyron has been the 2nd worst O line man this year. Dude you are tripping. Tyron has been damn good this year. He's becoming that that tackle we all hoped he could become when we drafted him.

smith has been okay . But Free , frederick have been our best this season. Waters / Smith almost tied and leary has been our last. I am not saying Smith has been bad but he has been far from the best ( especially run blocking)

 

[CowboyStar88]

smith has been okay . But Free , frederick have been our best this season. Waters / Smith almost tied and leary has been our last. I am not saying Smith has been bad but he has been far from the best ( especially run blocking)

I agree on Free this guy has been consistent and solid and looks like a totally different player. He isn't getting beat and he is playing smart football with good feet and leverage

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

I stopped reading after Dez, really you should of waited until hangover Monday!

I dont know i think most of you only see the positive plays . I have seen too many critical drops on 3rd down to truly call him an elite WR. I cant picture Irvin or Rice dropping these passes like Dez does, And the fumble today ? I dont know dez is a likable guy but lets be real here he has made huge mistakes . Go watch all his drops this season on 3rd down. He has ALOT TO IMPROVE ON.

 

[tico]

yes but that doesn't make them overrated! I see superstar potential

 

[blackbull]

Calvin drops passes as well. Get the hell out of here. Smh

 

[Cebrin]

I dont know i think most of you only see the positive plays . I have seen too many critical drops on 3rd down to truly call him an elite WR. I cant picture Irvin or Rice dropping these passes like Dez does, And the fumble today ? I dont know dez is a likable guy but lets be real here he has made huge mistakes . Go watch all his drops this season on 3rd down. He has ALOT TO IMPROVE ON.

You're comparing three entirely different players. Rice was probably the best route runner EVER. He had great hands. Irvin was probably the most physical receiver I've ever seen. He had great hands. Dez is a pure athlete compared to these other two. He also has great hands. They all dropped some balls in their time. None more than T.O. and he still holds a mighty long list of records and achievements. Dez is a stud and still very young. He's probably top 5 scariest dude in the red zone in the entire NFL. I'd say that makes him pretty elite. Granted, of course he has some improvements to be made. It's part of the game.

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

Calvin drops passes as well. Get the hell out of here. Smh

Does Calvin drop on 3rd down consistently ? Im just saying if Dez is "so " elite he should be opened to critique . I know for a fact CJ doesnt drop on 3rd downs and fumble as much as Dez. Dez needs to work on those things . If people want to bash our great Qb for one mistake a game then i am certainly going to critique our so called elite WR for his mental lapses.