Pearl Jam vs. Stone Temple Pilots

[Baileyneverfailey]

They're both great bands, but Pearl Jam gets the nod because after Weiland quit shooting up heroin he was useless.

 

[MetalHead]

Ditto... both suck...

I was afraid to be the first one to say that,but I agree.

I like neither.

 

[Concord]

Ditto... both suck...

...Yep

 

[Concord]

This isn't controversial enough.

Beatles or Elvis.

Skinny or Fat Elvis?

 

[Baileyneverfailey]

Anybody who thinks Ten is not a legendary album doesn't even get to call themselves a music fan. I'm sure you're just a huge fan of only one genre, or old, and the thought of the long haired grunge band just makes your liver hurt, but true fans of music don't judge music solely on genre.

 

[Concord]

Or you like all kinds of music and even enjoy Nirvana...but just happen to think these two bands blow.

 

[MetalHead]

Anybody who thinks Ten is not a legendary album doesn't even get to call themselves a music fan. I'm sure you're just a huge fan of only one genre, or old, and the thought of the long haired grunge band just makes your liver hurt, but true fans of music don't judge music solely on genre.

I'm a music fan and I don't consider Ten a legendary album.
All a matter of taste.

 

[big dog cowboy]

I'm a music fan and I don't consider Ten a legendary album.
All a matter of taste.

No one I know thinks it's anywhere close to being a "legendary" album.

 

[Concord]

I'm a music fan and I don't consider Ten a legendary album.
All a matter of taste.

No one I know thinks it's anywhere close to being a "legendary" album.

I hope you two don't call yourselves music fans.

 

[MetalHead]

No one I know thinks it's anywhere close to being a "legendary" album.

It is not.Rather is more symbolic than musical masterpiece.
The months preceding the grunge movement were saturated with glammed out bands that sounded and looked alike.
Then Cobain showed up with Teen Spirit and in a matter of days was joined by a bunch of other bands wearing flannel instead of spandex and looking like hobos instead of chicks and voila!....grunge was born.
Did not last long,the leader of the movement shotgunned himself in Seattle.

 

[theogt]

It is not.Rather is more symbolic than musical masterpiece.
The months preceding the grunge movement were saturated with glammed out bands that sounded and looked alike.
Then Cobain showed up with Teen Spirit and in a matter of days was joined by a bunch of other bands wearing flannel instead of spandex and looking like hobos instead of chicks and voila!....grunge was born.
Did not last long,the leader of the movement shotgunned himself in Seattle.

Someone with the name "MetalHead" is bemoaning grunge rock music? Say it ain't so!

And to say it didn't last long seems silly. Grunge rock has more influence on today's rock than any other genre. Hell, much of the stuff released today could have been released 20 years ago and sounded perfectly natural.

Check out the Billboard rock charts. Oh, hey, look David Grohl at #1! That's pesky Nirvana kids won't last long at all!

 

[MetalHead]

Someone with the name "MetalHead" is bemoaning grunge rock music? Say it ain't so!

And to say it didn't last long seems silly. Grunge rock has more influence on today's rock than any other genre. Hell, much of the stuff released today could have been released 20 years ago and sounded perfectly natural.

Check out the Billboard rock charts. Oh, hey, look David Grohl at #1! That's pesky Nirvana kids won't last long at all!

Yes I am.I don't like grunge rock...I love metal.TRENKILL!!!
And I don't care what influences music today...I really don't.
Isn't Chris Novoselic working the drive thru at El Pollo Loco in Bakersfield?...yep it lasted for him.

 

[theogt]

Yes I am.I don't like grunge rock...I love metal.TRENKILL!!!
And I don't care what influences music today...I really don't.
Isn't Chris Novoselic working the drive thru at El Pollo Loco in Bakersfield?...yep it lasted for him.

To tell you the truth, I don't care if you care either. I just know that you said something silly/ignorant/wrong and I felt obliged to correct you.

 

[MetalHead]

To tell you the truth, I don't care if you care either. I just know that you said something silly/ignorant/wrong and I felt obliged to correct you.

Apparently you do,because it warranted a response from you.


And who exactly are you to correct me?Who granted you such authority?
The Taste police?...Other than being the most pedant member of this board,Mr Know-it-all,your opinion matters here as much as every one else's.
Learn it,live it,love it.

 

[theogt]

Apparently you do,because it warranted a response from you.


And who exactly are you to correct me?Who granted you such authority?
The Taste police?...Other than being the most pedant member of this board,Mr Know-it-all,your opinion matters here as much as every one else's.
Learn it,live it,love it.

I was not correcting your lack of taste. I was correcting the statement that grunge rock did not last long. I'm not aware of any license I need to note factually incorrect statements on the internet.

 

[MetalHead]

I was not correcting your lack of taste. I was correcting the statement that grunge rock did not last long. I'm not aware of any license I need to note factually incorrect statements on the internet.

So I did not get cited for lack of taste(LOL),but for "incorrect" statements by the Internet Police.

Wait,Palladia has Sonisphere 2010 right now...go see how many grunge bands are in the bill.

 

[theogt]

So I did not get cited for lack of taste(LOL),but for "incorrect" statements by the Internet Police.

Wait,Palladia has Sonisphere 2010 right now...go see how many grunge bands are in the bill.

Guess who headlined ACL in 2009. Pearl Jam.

Who headlined Lollapalooza in 2010? Soundgarden.

 

[MetalHead]

Guess who headlined ACL in 2009. Pearl Jam.

Who headlined Lollapalooza in 2010? Soundgarden.

Lollacoachelooza and ACL....the first 50 fans get to play onstage.

 

[Sarge]

IDk guys i always thought Alice in Chains were much better then the both of them.

:signmast:

 

[theogt]

Lollacoachelooza and ACL....the first 50 fans get to play onstage.

I'm not sure what you're trying to get at here. ACL and Lollapalooza are as big or bigger than Sonisphere in terms of attendance.