PFT: Elliott Case Continues To Be A Bizarre Balancing Act For League

Status
Not open for further replies.

Plankton

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,260
Reaction score
18,651
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.co...es-to-be-a-bizarre-balancing-act-for-the-nfl/


In his comments during the March league meetings in Arizona, Cowboys owner Jerry Jones made the case to his colleagues for getting out of the business of conducting internal investigations that supplement the work of the criminal justice system. And while Jones clearly has a vested interest in the current machinations of that specific mechanism, he made a valid point.

With Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliott, who according to Clarence E. Hill, Jr. of the Fort Worth Star-Telegram previously was told he’d be cleared, now bracing for a suspension under the Personal Conduct Policy for alleged misconduct that resulted in neither an arrest nor charges, the league finds itself clumsily trying to balance conflicting business considerations while attempting to engage in what should be (but never can be) an objective, dispassionate assessment of the facts. On one hand, the league needs to placate Jones, who has more power than ever and who, we’re told, made it clear to the powers-that-be a year ago that he won’t be as gracious and compliant as Patriots owner Robert Kraft if a star player gets banned for something the boss thinks is bogus. On the other hand, the league needs to be cognizant of the potential P.R. consequences that would flow from a decision to give Elliott a pass — especially if his alleged victim files a lawsuit and eventually tells a compelling tale of domestic violence that the court of public opinion finds persuasive.

Surely, that’s one of the reasons why this case has taken so long to resolve. Whether the result of delicate negotiation or persistent consternation, the league office has been tiptoeing through a potential minefield, trying to find a path that will appease everyone involved and assuage the possibility of a Ray Rice/Josh Brown-style media firestorm.

Whatever the league does, it needs to do it now. The internal appeals process needs to be resolved before Week One, so that the potential suspension doesn’t hover one week at a time over the 2017 season. A cynic would say that influential Giants co-owner John Mara is pushing for immediate resolution, so that his team won’t have to face Elliott in Week One. Right or wrong, the league’s bungling of other investigations invites skepticism and cynicism when it comes to this one.

So what happens with Elliott? It’s possible that Friday’s report from Adam Schefter of ESPN was the product not of an exasperated Elliott camp accepting the inevitable but a deliberate leak from the league office aimed at gauging public opinion (along with the possible wrath of Jerry) before making a final decision. Whatever the motivation, a decision must come ASAFP if the league hopes for its internal investigation process to preserve any credibility whatsoever.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BAT
Messages
2,928
Reaction score
3,858
So basically Goodell is holding Zeke's career hostage out of fear of being yelled at by bitter old feminists?
if that's what you think of JJ and considering the culture of an organization flows down stream, why don't you go pick another, more socially conscience team to pull for.
 

robjay04

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,240
Reaction score
14,068
Holding this over Zeke's head for a solid year should outrage every player in the league.

Zeke is getting endorsements but would he be getting more if he didn't have a pending DV case? The guy is very marketable and he plays for America's Team, his endorsement potential is universal. Roger Goodell is costing this young man potentially millions of dollars.
 

pugilist

Stick N Move
Messages
7,427
Reaction score
10,367
imo, if he is suspended that will set a unique (and not necessarily good) precedence for further suspensions under the conduct detrimental blanket

What happens to Joe Mixon?
What will happen to future players that have criminal allegations before being drafted?
 

Plankton

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,260
Reaction score
18,651
imo, if he is suspended that will set a unique (and not necessarily good) precedence for further suspensions under the conduct detrimental blanket

What happens to Joe Mixon?
What will happen to future players that have criminal allegations before being drafted?

This keeps getting missed in all of this - the investigation is about the allegations made in July, 2016, after he signed a contract with the Cowboys. The other allegations can be used to point to an overall pattern of behavior tied to the incident that allegedly happened when in the employ of the NFL.
 

Pabst

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,441
Reaction score
1,060
Just a friendly reminder that Lisa Friel, the NFL's Domestic Violence Investigator, is a huge Giants fan who has had season tickets in her family for generations, and whose office is adorned with Giants paraphernalia.

I'm sure there's absolutely no conflict of interest in insuring Elliot does not play week one.
 

Silver Surfer

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,699
Reaction score
7,415
So basically Goodell is holding Zeke's career hostage out of fear of being yelled at by bitter old feminists?

I think its the younger feminists they're worried about and those feminists' influence on their husbands and children. If your brand is tarnished in the eyes of your customers (existing and especially prospective), your future earnings will probably suffer.
 

links18

Well-Known Member
Messages
24,325
Reaction score
20,105
Just a friendly reminder that Lisa Friel, the NFL's Domestic Violence Investigator, is a huge Giants fan who has had season tickets in her family for generations, and whose office is adorned with Giants paraphernalia.

I'm sure there's absolutely no conflict of interest in insuring Elliot does not play week one.

Is there a link to that?
 

Toro9

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,958
Reaction score
1,771
Say Zeke is suspended, what could Jerry do, realistically, if he disagrees, aside from being involved in an appeal of some sort?
 

links18

Well-Known Member
Messages
24,325
Reaction score
20,105
This is why the disciplinary process can't be "fair"--the league has a vested interest in protecting its public image. But, I guess in a way so do the players and in the end the NFLPA agreed to this arrangement. Still, the league better start worrying about the image and credibility of its competitive product with its core fan base, who are prone to see this kind of arbitrary and capricious disciplinary process as an attempt to skew results on the field. There is already enough of an issue with officiating and having mysterious faceless officials in New York weighing in on calls on the field.
 

links18

Well-Known Member
Messages
24,325
Reaction score
20,105
Say Zeke is suspended, what could Jerry do, realistically, if he disagrees, aside from being involved in an appeal of some sort?

He owns the most valuable team in professional sports and the NFL's flagship franchise. He should be able to think of something....
 

Reality

Staff member
Messages
31,233
Reaction score
72,785
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Not exactly. Florio has no idea what's going on and is just throwing crap against the wall to see what sticks. There is absolutely zero new information in his article, just more speculation.
He knows that anything Cowboys related, especially negative news, will bring in both the fans and the haters to read. As long as people do so, he'll keep doing it as would most people in his position.
 

Smashin222

Well-Known Member
Messages
773
Reaction score
383
So basically Goodell is holding Zeke's career hostage out of fear of being yelled at by bitter old feminists?
I think its the younger feminists they're worried about and those feminists' influence on their husbands and children. If your brand is tarnished in the eyes of your customers (existing and especially prospective), your future earnings will probably suffer.

I don't think it is "feminists" exerting pressure on the NFL to get serious about DV. You don't need to be a feminist to think the league has a domestic violence problem. I'd expect the number of consumers who think the NFL has a DV problem is probably quite high.
 

Echo9

Erik_H
Messages
3,773
Reaction score
1,814
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.co...es-to-be-a-bizarre-balancing-act-for-the-nfl/
...Whatever the league does, it needs to do it now. The internal appeals process needs to be resolved before Week One, so that the potential suspension doesn’t hover one week at a time over the 2017 season. A cynic would say that influential Giants co-owner John Mara is pushing for immediate resolution, so that his team won’t have to face Elliott in Week One. Right or wrong, the league’s bungling of other investigations invites skepticism and cynicism when it comes to this one.

So what happens with Elliott? It’s possible that Friday’s report from Adam Schefter of ESPN was the product not of an exasperated Elliott camp accepting the inevitable but a deliberate leak from the league office aimed at gauging public opinion (along with the possible wrath of Jerry) before making a final decision. Whatever the motivation, a decision must come ASAFP if the league hopes for its internal investigation process to preserve any credibility whatsoever.
Call me a cynic.
 

Nightman

Capologist
Messages
27,121
Reaction score
24,038
I don't think it is "feminists" exerting pressure on the NFL to get serious about DV. You don't need to be a feminist to think the league has a domestic violence problem. I'd expect the number of consumers who think the NFL has a DV problem is probably quite high.
they don't want to be caught giving a serial DV violator a slap on the wrist one game suspension and then having the world find out the league knew about 20 instances of the same player abusing his wife

the team might even give him a big extension before all this info comes out and embarrasses the NFL, the NYGiants, Mara and Josh Brown

The Giants might even let him still play for them after the truth comes out

That is why the EE case can never be closed....... he might do something in the future that could warrant a suspension and the NFL wants to be ready
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top