PFW Super 50 - Top 50 Players in '07 (6 'Boys)

[superpunk]

Could not disagree with you more. Walter Jones is probably the best overall LT in the whole league. Davis might not have been the best RG but tell me who was so much better that you'd have rather had them then Davis.

I don't know who I'd take over Davis. I'm just not sure he was the best. There were alot of teams that had alot more success up the gut than us. Although not many that were better running to the right side.

As for Jones, having watched him there are plenty of tackles I would take. His level of play ahs dropped considerably. That still makes him good, but at this point I'd take Flo over Jones.

I don't know what Brett Farve you saw this year but I thought he was pretty darn good, once more, this year. Of course I'm sure most people are on that idea that some how based off of one half of football that Rogers will be better than him.

I think he got lucky for most of the year. Teams couldn't make him pay for being Favre. A few teams could, and we saw the result. I don't think he did anything deserving of #3 in the league, besides get the ball into WRs hands who abused the league with YAC.

I do somewhat agree with you on Big Ben though. I think he's a very good QB but i dont know if he's top 10 players in the league worthy.

Ben is a decently mobile Drew Bledsoe. He didn't belong in the top 30, much less #7.

Bob Sanders...hmmmm....I don't know. It's hard to go against him cause he is a HUGE difference between the Colts defense with him and without him.

There's a huge difference in our defense with and without Greg Ellis. Is Greg Ellis the league's fifth best player?

 

[quincyyyyy]

Andre Johnson is better than Braylon Edwards and definitely better than Brandon Marshall.

 

[CrazyCowboy]

Gotta love ROMO getting some smack back.

 

[AdamJT13]

Anyone care to explain how Favre was better than Romo this season?

 

[jterrell]

I thought it might be interesting to see the break down per position. Not sure if I got them all though.

1. QB Tom Brady | New England Patriots
2. QB Peyton Manning | Indianapolis Colts
3. QB Brett Favre | Green Bay Packers
6. QB Tony Romo | Dallas Cowboys
7. QB Ben Roethlisberger | Pittsburgh Steelers
25. QB Matt Hasselbeck | Seattle Seahawks
35. QB David Garrard | Jacksonville Jaguars
41. QB Jeff Garcia | Tampa Bay Buccaneers

8. RB Brian Westbrook | Philadelphia Eagles
9. RB LaDainian Tomlinson | San Diego Chargers
15. RB Joseph Addai | Indianapolis Colts
16. RB Adrian Peterson | Minnesota Vikings
21. RB Willie Parker | Pittsburgh Steelers
26. RB Marion Barber | Dallas Cowboys
50. RB Fred Taylor | Jacksonville Jaguars

4. WR Randy Moss | New England Patriots
13. WR Reggie Wayne | Indianapolis Colts
14. WR Terrell Owens | Dallas Cowboys
19. WR Larry Fitzgerald | Arizona Cardinals
24. WR Wes Welker | New England Patriots
27. RS-WR Devin Hester | Chicago Bears
28. WR Braylon Edwards | Cleveland Browns
40. WR Brandon Marshall | Denver Broncos

17. TE Antonio Gates | San Diego Chargers
38. TE Jason Witten | Dallas Cowboys
42. TE Kellen Winslow | Cleveland Browns

10. DE Jared Allen | Kansas City Chiefs
34. DE Kyle Vanden Bosch | Tennessee Titans
37. DE Mario Williams | Houston Texans
39. DE Jason Taylor | Miami Dolphins
43. DE Patrick Kerney | Seattle Seahawks
46. DE Osi Umenyiora | New York Giants
48. DE Aaron Kampman | Green Bay Packers

11. OLB DeMarcus Ware | Dallas Cowboys
20. OLB Shawne Merriman | San Diego Chargers
29. ILB Patrick Willis | San Francisco 49ers
30. MLB Lofa Tatupu | Seattle Seahawks
33. OLB Julian Peterson | Seattle Seahawks
45. OLB Mike Vrabel | New England Patriots
49. OLB James Harrison | Pittsburgh Steelers

36. OG Leonard Davis | Dallas Cowboys

12. DT Albert Haynesworth | Tennessee Titans
22. DT Kevin Williams | Minnesota Vikings
32. DT Pat Williams | Minnesota Vikings

very nicely done on separating by position.

thanks!

they seriously value Qbs

 

[Bob Sacamano]

at least they ranked Ware over Merriman