Patrick, since he was still largely an unknown quantity, despite his promising final few games last season.
I can't vote Newman because Tnew's play was expected of him.
I was never down on him LAST year, and was even more convinced of his ability after reading the section KC Joyner wrote on his 2004 season in "The Football Scientist".
Tnew's short memory and ability to rebound from adversity was obvious, but the sense of how poorly he played last year was way overestimated.
Like Terry Glenn, there is nothing I see this year from Tnew that I don't expect from him...ie, excellence.