Poll: Rank Staubach's, Aikman's & Romo's Pro Bowler Teammates Collective Talent

[DallasEast]

List of Pro Bowlers

1978 Roger Staubach: Randy White, Cliff Harris, Charlie Waters, Billy Joe DuPree, Tony Dorsett, Tony Hill, Thomas Henderson & Harvey Martin

1993 Troy Aikman: Emmitt Smith, Erik Williams, Mark Stepnoski, Nate Newton, Michael Irvin, Ken Norton, Thomas Everett, Daryl Johnston, Russell Maryland & Jay Novacek

2007 Tony Romo: DeMarcus Ware, Jason Witten, Terrell Owens, Andre Gurode, Flozell Adams, Leonard Davis, Marion Barber, Greg Ellis, Nick Folk, Ken Hamlin, Terence Newman & Roy Williams

Note: Poll option allows for changing of your vote at a later time.

 

[Ranching]

List of Pro Bowlers

1978 Roger Staubach: Randy White, Cliff Harris, Charlie Waters, Billy Joe DuPree, Tony Dorsett, Tony Hill, Thomas Henderson & Harvey Martin

1993 Troy Aikman: Emmitt Smith, Erik Williams, Mark Stepnoski, Nate Newton, Michael Irvin, Ken Norton, Thomas Everett, Daryl Johnston, Russell Maryland & Jay Novacek

2007 Tony Romo: DeMarcus Ware, Jason Witten, Terrell Owens, Andre Gurode, Flozell Adams, Leonard Davis, Marion Barber, Greg Ellis, Nick Folk, Ken Hamlin, Terence Newman & Roy Williams

Note: Poll option allows for changing of your vote at a later time.

I guess you're a bit bored.

 

[HowardC]

It's hard to argue against the talent of those early 90s teams. So awesome that they created the salary cap to dismantle it.

 

[DallasEast]

I guess you're a bit bored.

Says the guy with enough time to joke about Garrett looking like Napoleon Dynamite.

 

[Ranching]

Says the guy with enough time to joke about Garrett looking like Napoleon Dynamite.

Soooo, that wasn't Garrett in HS?????

 

[Ranching]

It's hard to argue against the talent of those early 90s teams. So awesome that they created the salary cap to dismantle it.

Any team with Roger, Tony and Randy has to be number one.

 

[DallasEast]

It's hard to argue against the talent of those early 90s teams. So awesome that they created the salary cap to dismantle it.

The dismantling was a by-product. The goal then, as it is now, was all about the Benjamins--sought and gained by both the owners and the NFLPA.

 

[Ranching]

Roger > Aikman
Tony = Emmitt
Irvin > Drew
Randy White > than any DLlineman
Larry Allen ( not on the list ) > than any OLinemam

I choose Roger's team.

 

[DallasEast]

Soooo, that wasn't Garrett in HS?????

Nope. Key clue are the eyes:



Different drugs were experimented with.

 

[DallasEast]

Any team with Roger, Tony and Randy has to be number one.

Like I said in another thread, I could switch the 1993 squad with 1978's without any personal problem whatsoever.

 

[DFWJC]

Pro Bowls have decreased in meaning over time.
More than half of those 2007 Pro Bowler had no business being on that team, for example.

Aikman
Staubach


Romo

 

[CF74]

I can’t. Too much talent over load...

 

[NumOneQB]

Romo by a long shot. Make all the excuses you want, he failed miserably in the post season.


I would then put 2.Eightball 3.Staubizzy

 

[cowboyec]

#12's.

 

[CF74]

Romo by a long shot. Make all the excuses you want, he failed miserably in the post season.


I would then put 2.Eightball 3.Staubizzy

In 2007 we had two receivers and one TE come up small. The man can’t catch his own passes but whatever, ancient history...

 

[doomsday9084]

1993 team ended up looking worse than it was based on that list. The guys left off that list include Darren Woodson, Leon Lett, Mark Tuinei, Kevin Smith, Larry Brown, Harper and several more very good players.

If we are just supposed to debate the guys on that list Roger might have the best support but when you look at the whole team, the 93 Cowboys lap the field. I doubt the NFL ever sees another team as deep and talented vs. the rest of the league as that group. The cap will likely prevent it. The only thing that could cause another one would be a Herschel Walker type deal where some team gives up 7 high draft picks for one player and the team with those picks drafts near perfectly.

Edit add: Some of the guys on Romo's list are like "***? He made a pro bowl?!?!?!"

 

[Bullflop]

Nope. Key clue are the eyes:



Different drugs were experimented with.

Looks like he might be hypnotized!!!

 

[Super_Kazuya]

List of Pro Bowlers

1978 Roger Staubach: Randy White, Cliff Harris, Charlie Waters, Billy Joe DuPree, Tony Dorsett, Tony Hill, Thomas Henderson & Harvey Martin

1993 Troy Aikman: Emmitt Smith, Erik Williams, Mark Stepnoski, Nate Newton, Michael Irvin, Ken Norton, Thomas Everett, Daryl Johnston, Russell Maryland & Jay Novacek

2007 Tony Romo: DeMarcus Ware, Jason Witten, Terrell Owens, Andre Gurode, Flozell Adams, Leonard Davis, Marion Barber, Greg Ellis, Nick Folk, Ken Hamlin, Terence Newman & Roy Williams

Note: Poll option allows for changing of your vote at a later time.

Should be pointed out that if comparing to the others that the 2007 team really had 11 players (Greg and Roy were replacements), plus one was a kicker who wasn’t even close to being the best kicker in the league.

 

[pete026]

I don't have a dog in the fight but if I understand the premise from the other thread, it's asking which QB got the most support from their fellow teammates.

The problem is it asks to rank them based on a single year but most, if not all posters are ranking that QBs support based on their knowledge of the players careers. That is because only 1 of the player's is presently active and it is hard to separate a single year of a player's career without some bias, especially the further you look back. Evaluating each of the players based on that single year may produce a different result.

 

[StarBoyz83]

Romo is easily 3rd