Positives and negatives from this game vs Seattle?

I liked both Howell and Milton.

About what I expected from Howell.
Milton much improved from last year. And had some very good touch passes.
Only seen one where he threw to hard and high. But all QB’s do that from time,to time.
That was my take as well.

Howell was solid tonight but Milton impressed me as he looked like he improved a lot since last year.

Milton's touch on passes is way ahead of last year and his direct passes are faster and tighter than Howell's were.

That said, it's nice to see the Cowboys finally put two solid backup quarterbacks on the field in preseason for a change.
 
Positives

Camden Brown is making a statement. Two touchdowns, including a spectacular 39-yard one-handed catch. He’s easily one of the biggest winners of the night.

The backup QB competition looks interesting. Sam Howell threw the 39-yard TD to Brown, and Joe Milton followed with another scoring drive. Both have shown some things to like.

The offense has sustained drives. Dallas put together scoring drives of 74, 65 and 84 yards, including an impressive 13-play, 84-yard TD drive.

The defense settled down after the opening drive. Seattle's opening TD came on a 13-play, 80-yard drive, but Dallas has shut them out since.

James Houston made a play. He recorded a sack of Jalen Milroe, which is exactly the kind of splash play he needs in this competition.

Negatives

The opening defensive series was ugly. Seattle went 80 yards in more than seven minutes and scored a TD, with Dallas also committing two penalties on the drive.

Penalties are worth watching. Giving Seattle free yardage on that opening possession is exactly the kind of thing that can become a bigger issue once the regular season starts.

It's difficult to evaluate the defense against Seattle's backups. The second half has been more encouraging, but we shouldn't overreact to a preseason performance against players fighting for roster spots.

The offensive line still deserves scrutiny. Dallas has moved the ball, but I'd be watching the protection and run blocking closely rather than judging the unit simply by the scoring drives.

Of course injuries are the biggest concern. Several Cowboys are listed with injuries during the game, including Jalen Thompson, Princeton Fant, Zion Childress, James Houston and P.J. Locke.

⭐ My biggest winners tonight

Camden Brown — A+
Sam Howell — A-
Joe Milton — B+
James Houston — B+
Overall defense — B
Offensive line — Incomplete/B-

The Camden Brown performance is the story of the night for me. A two-TD game with that one-handed catch is exactly how a young receiver gets people talking about a roster spot.
Woods had the defensive tackle of the game in my opinion
 
Competence. Thats what I took away. Looking like a professional franchise. They looked like they knew their assignments. Even Milton looked night and day compared to last season.

Long way to go. But maybe this time, they are on the right track.

At least it wasnt the **** show we have been accustomed to.
 
Positives and negatives-

Both QBs looked good.
Brown and Trigg were really good and can make the 53.
Drew Shelton needs 1 year of Gym time.
Special teams were beyond terrible .
Julius Wood is a fringe 53 guy for me.
Malik Davis may make the team over Mafah.
Yeah but I think that people are keeping out this Israel kid everyone's calling him Izzy that running back I saw him flashed in practice to scrimmage and in this game it does not matter that it's against backups they're all playing against backups I think he's taking someone's spot he looks like he's built more like Williams but runs like Davis..

He's a more nimble big back I mean I believe that's what this coaching staff likes big backs but how about A big back with a little bit more speed than the starter for your backup so yeah as much as I'm high on Phil that chest injury it might lose him his job because inasmuch as I like Davis Izzy look better than all of them in camp and in this game and I know it was against further backups but they should start him instead of blue In this next game they gave Blue way too many regular running back snaps and I know he can do that but I think they're wasting time behind a backup line giving your smallest fast back that's supposed to be your 3rd down type change of pace back all these up the middle runs you're just wasting snaps..

If you're gonna do that give it to somebody like Izzy who's bigger or phil should have started one way Or the other I just feel like they wasted those early series trying to make Blue is starting running back I know maybe it's for contact maybe it's to help him get used to holding on the ball but whatever it was it just didn't feel right I love the kid I hope Blue makes the team but I just don't think you use him in those situations so why even practice him there..
 
I think that Davis could very well make the team. Overall our backup running backs are solid.
I think they keep Davis as the primary backup but keep Blue for the one thing you can't teach... speed and lots of it. Mafah is headed to the practice squad. And NO, he won't be snapped up. He doesn't have a single trait that is good enuff to make other teams want him more than what they have. He is big but slow and doesn't have contact balance. Sorry but I just don't see anything special about him. I didn't see it during the draft runup last year and I don't see anything now. I don't get what the talking heads see in him.
 
I like the strength of Mafuh, the Speed of Blue,,,, but Davis and Abanikanda see and hit the holes, they were just better runners.
I didn't see the strength of Mafah that you did. He went down easier than Blue. Blue was being tackled by DT's on inside runs. I believe the coaches were trying to test his ball safety. Mafah was getting the outside shots that Blue should have been getting and was being tackled by DB's. Just don't see the strength.
 
First game of preseason and backups and yet the team and QBs didn’t look like an utter clownshow as they have in many previous years. I call that a big win.
 
Areas of weakness in this game that stood out early was, special teams' coverage on punt/kick returns, secondary awareness.

The OL were steadily wearing down the interior of Seattle's D when we leaned on the run which is a positive towards scheme, and some decent looking depth on OL finally might be emerging.

Milton looked decent, has a bullet arm, seems vastly improved over last year, still young with only entering year 3, has a good frame, good size at 6'4" @ 248lbs, with fast feet.

Would be nice to see him take a step up this season, its year 3 so time to see something positive and he flashed that tonight.

I liked the good shows from Blue, Mafa, and always seems as though Davis would be eventually drifting out, but he has some solid game, he has a good burst and another gear, Davis isn't throwing in the white flag by no means.

So with Williams, Blue, Mafa, Davis is deep, where does Lupke fit into the equation?

Nice to have some problems with a slight log jam at a position but Mingo looked good tonight he didn't hurt himself, and the rookie looks like a very interesting prospect Campton Brown with a pair of TDs and a spectacular one-handed Odell special.
Can't coach raw talent, some are just born with it, he flashed that skill tonight.
CD
Pickens
Flournoy
V-Scantling
Turpin
C Brown
Mingo
A Smith
Jayden Smith
Mims
Holden, but he did not help himself at all vs Seattle

They will stash a few, but nice to see some young talent at WR stepping up, and just as nice as having a bit of an issue on final cuts.
Davis was the best back on the field.
 
Carson was committing penalties, but he was tackling extremely well. They all were.

That was the biggest highlight for me.
 
A lot of A gap runs last night.

Blue has 4.3 speed.

Put him in space.
That's easier said than done in the NFL. A running back that can't run between the tackles in useless.

You can't use Blue much. He'll get Dak maimed.
 
Carson was most of the penalties. They seemed to settle down in the second half.
And not nearly as many as I thought there would be.
It bothered me that we never got a replay on any of those penalties. It felt like there was some ‘home cooking’ going on.
 
Carson was committing penalties, but he was tackling extremely well. They all were.

That was the biggest highlight for me.
Caron is frustrating, will make a good play then a bad play. But bottom line you can not commit that many penalties even though not sure the PI was a PI. But you can't hurt your team with penalties.
 
Yeah but I think that people are keeping out this Israel kid everyone's calling him Izzy that running back I saw him flashed in practice to scrimmage and in this game it does not matter that it's against backups they're all playing against backups I think he's taking someone's spot he looks like he's built more like Williams but runs like Davis..

He's a more nimble big back I mean I believe that's what this coaching staff likes big backs but how about A big back with a little bit more speed than the starter for your backup so yeah as much as I'm high on Phil that chest injury it might lose him his job because inasmuch as I like Davis Izzy look better than all of them in camp and in this game and I know it was against further backups but they should start him instead of blue In this next game they gave Blue way too many regular running back snaps and I know he can do that but I think they're wasting time behind a backup line giving your smallest fast back that's supposed to be your 3rd down type change of pace back all these up the middle runs you're just wasting snaps..

If you're gonna do that give it to somebody like Izzy who's bigger or phil should have started one way Or the other I just feel like they wasted those early series trying to make Blue is starting running back I know maybe it's for contact maybe it's to help him get used to holding on the ball but whatever it was it just didn't feel right I love the kid I hope Blue makes the team but I just don't think you use him in those situations so why even practice him there..
Izzy looked good.

https://www.nfl.com/prospects/israel-abanikanda/32004142-4115-9567-2e24-0eab29f6a4b9
 
While Camden Brown likely played his way onto the team, Holden may have played his way off.
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
474,757
Messages
14,558,090
Members
24,213
Latest member
Debi
Back
Top