It's worth looking into. Can't say I see a for sure upgrade though.
Upgrade was probably the wrong term. A few of those guys I listed are bigger backs. Something we don't really have. McFadden isn't considered a power runner.
Randle and Williams are kinda the same guy. Not overly big, not overly fast, not overly powerful. Both have concerns regarding pass blocking. Neither seem too bright.
Williams has injury concerns. Randle has knucklehead concerns.
Williams doesn't play special teams. Randle at least does that.
If they like Randle better than Williams, then what? Randle still plays special teams while Williams sits on the bench as the third RB and does nothing?
I'd let Randle and Williams battle it out. I'd try to find a bigger, power back that can play special teams. Make him the third RB.
Branden Oliver is another name that could be available. But he's a smaller guy and may not offer much on special teams.
Anthony Dixon would be an upgrade for us. He's a big guy. Played quite a bit for Buffalo. Buffalo also now has Shady and just drafted Karlos Williams. And they still have Fred Jackson and Bryce Brown. I don't know who stays from that group. Not sure I'd be interested in Jackson. But either Dixon or Brown I'd pick up.
George Winn is a bigger guy - 218. Not real fast, but was very productive in college. I'd be interested in taking a look there.
Mike Gillislee, Damien Williams or LaMichael Jame could be available from Miami. They added Ajayi and have Lamar Miller. At least one of the aforementioned guys will be cut, if not two.
Matthew Tucker is a bigger guy as well. Has some speed.
I'm not considering any of these guys as lead backs. They're not. But they offering a little something different than Randle and Williams. And we don't really have a lead back ourselves. I think we are putting a lot of faith into McFaddens name. I just don't think he's all that. I hope I'm wrong. I hope he comes in here with a new attitude and tears it up. Randle and Williams, who knows. But they are for sure not top 15 RBs in this league. They may not even be top 32.