QB Combined Statistical Ranking after week 7

StarOfGlory

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,487
Reaction score
4,804
It’s impossible to say how good Romo and Dak would be though. Reid went to the SB with Donovan McNabb throwing to James Trash and Stinkston. Andy Reid is a greedy football mind.
They had T.O. and Brian Westbrook that year. Trash was gone, but they still has Stinkston. But he did get deep in the playoffs before that with some bad receivers like Trash, Stinkston, Smalls, and Mitchell. And he had a running game with Duce Staley before Westbrook took over. I think people forget how good Westbrook was. R.I.P. to all the worms killed by McNabb. How can you have such a good deep ball and can't throw 5 yards from one play to the next?
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,499
Reaction score
76,338
There is a reason the whole world agrees Mahomes is special though. They would be a good team with a lot of QB's. They wouldn't win they way they have though because he does the combination of things that no other QB can do.
I agree they wouldn’t be as good with those guys. But if the question is would Romo and Dak be better with Reid then they were with Jason Garrett or McCarthy? I’d have to say they would based on what I’ve seen Alex Smith and McNabb look like.
 

gtb1943

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,236
Reaction score
6,480
I agree they wouldn’t be as good with those guys. But if the question is would Romo and Dak be better with Reid then they were with Jason Garrett or McCarthy? I’d have to say they would based on what I’ve seen Alex Smith and McNabb look like.
with arguably the top coach in the game compared to what we have had for the last 18 years?
and a GM that actually knows what he is doing?
just hurts to think about it
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,499
Reaction score
76,338
They had T.O. and Brian Westbrook that year. Trash was gone, but they still has Stinkston. But he did get deep in the playoffs before that with some bad receivers like Trash, Stinkston, Smalls, and Mitchell. And he had a running game with Duce Staley before Westbrook took over. I think people forget how good Westbrook was. R.I.P. to all the worms killed by McNabb. How can you have such a good deep ball and can't throw 5 yards from one play to the next?
It wasn’t Stinkston I was thinking about it was Freddie Mitchell who was loud and bad.

Westbrook was a good player he was also good in the receiving game.
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
83,499
Reaction score
76,338
with arguably the top coach in the game compared to what we have had for the last 18 years?
and a GM that actually knows what he is doing?
just hurts to think about it
Yeah we’ve wasted 28 years and probably longer on Jerry. Just disgusting to think about.
 
Top