Oh so you brought up what would happen if Manning was available without trying to put it into context of what it wuld be like if RW were available. The only thing that is stupid is you saying that is not a comparison. You did not bring up Manning in respect to nothing.
You always try to use meaningless red herrings. The point is that if RW were to become available it would be nothing like if Manning were to be available. You can argue the semantics of the word compare all day long. You bringing up Manning is meaningless. Youre right there is no comparison.