Randy White vs JJ Watt. Streetfight. Who Wins?

[Rayman70]

Randy "Manster" White would beat the living crap out of JJ Watt. Prime vs prime. Some of White's teammates commented on how mean he was, that they would like him on their side in a street fight. Size is not as important as how dirty dog mean and brutal a man is in a fight.

this^ Randy was a junkyard dog. Durable. JJ aint that.

 

[Rayman70]

Randy would not only kick the shiet out of Watt, but would take his woman, family, then his money,House,cars. Watt would even thank him when its all over with.

 

[terra]

Randy would not only kick the shiet out of Watt, but would take his woman, family, then his money,House,cars. Watt would even thank him when its all over with.

and worst of all, his dog.

 

[Rayman70]

and worst of all, his dog.

No doubt

 

[Rayman70]

what randy would do to JJ.

 

[Dalmations202]

Street fight in an alley, or street fight in a mall parking lot ? ?

Ray Lewis and Charles Haley could be nasty good in a parking lot, but Manster, Eric Williams, and LAllen would be very tough in an alley or any area they could get their hands on you and utilize their size and you couldn't get away,.

In their primes, I suspect that Manster would win vs Watt -- but you never know until it happens.

 

[StarOfGlory]

I have a feeling Dick Butkus or Chuck Bednarik could bring some old school *** whooping on a lot of people.

 

[Rayman70]

I have a feeling Dick Butkus or Chuck Bednarik could bring some old school *** whooping on a lot of people.

Chuck reminds me of the guy who picks a steel pipe up and nails ya in the back of the head like a slap jack, with your back turned. Dick was nearly the same. Both nasty thuggish players at that time.Both versatile and smart.Two guys you wanna be in a foxhole with.

 

[Pass2Run]

I hope you're joking about Doug Free...I would take Cole Beasley is a 1 on 1 vs Free and Beasley's wife over both...

Parsons...I wouldn't bet against him in any physical contest.

On the 2022 team, pound for pound, I would pick Noah Brown 2nd after Parsons. In years past he has routinely pancaked many NFL strong safeties and held his own against many LBs and some DEs. This season he won multiple blocks vs Giants DE Kayvon Thibodeaux.

Ware...not mean enough.

You must be too young to have watched Erik Williams or Randy White.

Randy was like the Hulk character...nice guy off the field but something short circuited in his brain when he stepped on the field.

Pound for pound definitely Randy over anybody.

EW scared his own teammates. Darren Woodson in an interview was asked about the meanest player. The interviewer suggested Charles Haley...Woodson laughed and said EW was the meanest player ever...Haley was crazy but didn't scare anybody.

Woodson described EW as an enraged Bull blowing snot out his nose. Woodson said teammates were all scared of him on game day and stayed as far from him as possible. He said rookie Larry Allen was the first player that would get near EW in pre-game warmups. Nate also told that story about how nobody would do the pre-game 1 on 1 warmup drills vs EW until LA arrived.

EW made Reggie White cry on national TV...EW beat the snot out of the 6-5, 300 pound White, play after play. White, the guy that rag dolled rookie Larry Allen.

I'm old enough to have seen them all. Very familiar with Williams. But give me Odighizuwa all day over Erik Williams, because he'd trounce likely anyone on this list due to his background.

You would not want to mess with Osa Odighizuwa in a street fight. Based on what we know about fighting, he'd win every time. Almost impossible to beat someone who knows wrestling on the level that Odighizuwa knows it.

 

[Shane612]

I think Larry Allen would eat Randy White for dinner and have Watts for dessert.

 

[VaqueroTD]

I hope you're joking about Doug Free...I would take Cole Beasley is a 1 on 1 vs Free and Beasley's wife over both...

Parsons...I wouldn't bet against him in any physical contest.

On the 2022 team, pound for pound, I would pick Noah Brown 2nd after Parsons. In years past he has routinely pancaked many NFL strong safeties and held his own against many LBs and some DEs. This season he won multiple blocks vs Giants DE Kayvon Thibodeaux.

Ware...not mean enough.

You must be too young to have watched Erik Williams or Randy White.

Randy was like the Hulk character...nice guy off the field but something short circuited in his brain when he stepped on the field.

Pound for pound definitely Randy over anybody.

EW scared his own teammates. Darren Woodson in an interview was asked about the meanest player. The interviewer suggested Charles Haley...Woodson laughed and said EW was the meanest player ever...Haley was crazy but didn't scare anybody.

Woodson described EW as an enraged Bull blowing snot out his nose. Woodson said teammates were all scared of him on game day and stayed as far from him as possible. He said rookie Larry Allen was the first player that would get near EW in pre-game warmups. Nate also told that story about how nobody would do the pre-game 1 on 1 warmup drills vs EW until LA arrived.

EW made Reggie White cry on national TV...EW beat the snot out of the 6-5, 300 pound White, play after play. White, the guy that rag dolled rookie Larry Allen.

Never heard the Woodson story about BigE and Larry Allen. That’s awesome!

 

[noshame]

White breaks JJ in half

 

[TheHerd]

Odd question.

• All Time Best NFL Players as Street Fighters
  • Erik Williams
  • Larry Allen
  • Randy White
  • Tyler Smith

No argument with #1. E was the nastiest. He ate Reggie White for lunch.

 

[tyke1doe]

Randy is nearly 70 years old.

So my money’s on JJ.

 

[CCBoy]

Randy White is still highly impressive in appearance and actual strength.. His knowledge of aggression is unmatched in any comparison of the projected match-up.

 

[Illiniferret]

Randy White at 62, Still looks like a Manster. Night night JJ

 

[offlimits]

What are your thoughts?

If both are in their prime? Randy White easily. Even his teammates back in the day avoided him. I remember Hollywood Henderson avoided him. Randy White did not play and did not put up with nonsense in the locker room.

 

[BoysForLife]

Randy during, or post roid use?

That would be a key factor in my assessment....

 

[RoboQB]

Watt would be injured and unable to continue.

The mention of Haley in this thread reminded me of
Chad Hennings. Talk about a real tough guy.
Haley was afraid of Hennings.

 

[Hardline]