Rank the following players in their position league-wide

[Cowboy Brian]

That's a lengthy title.

It's the off-season so time for pointless games to boost our Cowboys-ego, yay!

Tony Romo, QB -
Dez Bryant, WR -
Terrance Williams, WR -
DeMarco Murray, HB -
Tyron Smith, LT -
Travis Frederick, C -
Sean Lee, ILB -
Brandon Carr, CB -
Morris Claiborne, CB -
Henry Melton, DT -
Dan Bailey, K -

Add whoever you'd like and use whatever criteria you feel is best.

 

[OhSnap]

L.P. Lodouceur is on his second 5 year extension with the Cowboys and is the best long snapper in the NFL or CFL. He also had 7 sacks 48 tackles and a forced fumble his senior year in high school

 

[XxTDxX]

I literally spent some time on this lol. Had to go through every player I felt was better at each position.

Dez Bryant, WR - 2nd ranked WR in the league

Terrance Williams, WR - 42nd ranked WR in the league

DeMarco Murray, HB - 7th ranked RB in the league

Tyron Smith, LT - 3rd ranked OT in the league

Travis Frederick, C - 9th ranked C in the league

Sean Lee, ILB - 10th ranked ILB in the league (Could have been higher..Believe he is better than some guys ahead of him but needs to stay healthy to be ranked ahead of them in my opinion..His lack of availability decreases his value)

Brandon Carr, CB - 33rd ranked CB in the league

Morris Claiborne, CB - 47th ranked CB in the league

Henry Melton, DT - 8th ranked DT in the league

Dan Bailey, K - 4th ranked K in the league

 

[pancakeman]

I literally spent some time on this lol. Had to go through every player I felt was better at each position.

Dez Bryant, WR - 2nd ranked WR in the league

Terrance Williams, WR - 42nd ranked WR in the league

DeMarco Murray, HB - 7th ranked RB in the league

Tyron Smith, LT - 3rd ranked OT in the league

Travis Frederick, C - 9th ranked C in the league

Sean Lee, ILB - 10th ranked ILB in the league (Could have been higher..Believe he is better than some guys ahead of him but needs to stay healthy to be ranked ahead of them in my opinion..His lack of availability decreases his value)

Brandon Carr, CB - 33rd ranked CB in the league

Morris Claiborne, CB - 47th ranked CB in the league

Henry Melton, DT - 8th ranked DT in the league

Dan Bailey, K - 4th ranked K in the league

Wow you spent too long on this! Your rankings pass the eyeball test for me though. You forgot Romo.
All those you ranked 8th or lower I feel could, by the end of the season, likely rise. But then I always feel that way this time of year.

 

[Vanilla2]

Dallas Cowboys 1-53 #1

 

[unionjack8]

Dallas Cowboys 1-53 #1

they must have been serving the wine in your church today..................lol

 

[Nova]

Romo: 7th

Dez: 4th or 5th

TWill: between 30th and 35th

DeMarco Murray : 10th

Tyron: 2nd... Better than Peters. Yeah I said it.

Tfred: hard to say but between 5 and 10.

Lee: 5th when healthy

Carr: around 25th

Claiborne: 50-60th

Melton: somewhere between 5-8th

 

[Bungarian]

Too many for me

 

[casmith07]

Interesting thread concept but I think the player selection is weird.

 

[burmafrd]

Add Witten and he is around 8 or so

 

[Cowboy Brian]

Interesting thread concept but I think the player selection is weird.

I didn't want too many but there were some players I really wanted to get in there.

Add Witten and he is around 8 or so

Removed him by mistake lol. I'd argue he's higher than #8, probably #5.

 

[casmith07]

Witten is #1 IMO. Most complete tight end in the game and has been for quite some time. Durability never an issue, elite route runner and soft hands. Good to great blocker.

You can't ask for a more complete package. Can do things split wide, tight against the line, or out of the backfield.

 

[dallasdave]

I literally spent some time on this lol. Had to go through every player I felt was better at each position.

Dez Bryant, WR - 2nd ranked WR in the league

Terrance Williams, WR - 42nd ranked WR in the league

DeMarco Murray, HB - 7th ranked RB in the league

Tyron Smith, LT - 3rd ranked OT in the league

Travis Frederick, C - 9th ranked C in the league

Sean Lee, ILB - 10th ranked ILB in the league (Could have been higher..Believe he is better than some guys ahead of him but needs to stay healthy to be ranked ahead of them in my opinion..His lack of availability decreases his value)

Brandon Carr, CB - 33rd ranked CB in the league

Morris Claiborne, CB - 47th ranked CB in the league

Henry Melton, DT - 8th ranked DT in the league

Dan Bailey, K - 4th ranked K in the league

Like DEZ at 2- hope he is #1 This year.

 

[dstovall5]

Interesting topic, definitely would be fun to sit down and actually rank a list of the positions. Sadly I don't have enough time because Houston Rockets are about the come on!

Off the top of my head though, *most likely forgetting some great players* I'd rank them like this.

Tony Romo, QB - High = top 6 / Low = top 10

Dez Bryant, WR - High = top 3 / Low = top 6

Terrance Williams, WR - High = top 30 / Low = top 50

DeMarco Murray, HB - High = top 7 / Low = top 12

Tyron Smith, LT - High = top 3 / Low = top 5

Travis Frederick, C - High = top 6 / Low = top 12

Sean Lee, ILB - *If Healthy* High = top 5 / Low = top 10

Brandon Carr, CB - High = top 20 / Low = top 32

Morris Claiborne, CB - High = top 40 / Low = top 64

Henry Melton, DT - ???

Dan Bailey, K - High = top 3 / Low = top 5

 

[Section446]

Tony Romo, QB - 12th.
Dez Bryant, WR - 5th.
Terrance Williams, WR - 45th.
DeMarco Murray, HB - 7th.
Tyron Smith, LT - 3rd.
Travis Frederick, C - 9th.
Sean Lee, ILB - 8th... would be higher, but just can't be depended on.
Brandon Carr, CB - 20th.
Morris Claiborne, CB - 60-70th.
Henry Melton, DT - Pre-injury: 5.
Dan Bailey, K - I really think he's the best K in the game right now.

 

[bh32]

Witten is #1 IMO. Most complete tight end in the game and has been for quite some time. Durability never an issue, elite route runner and soft hands. Good to great blocker.

You can't ask for a more complete package. Can do things split wide, tight against the line, or out of the backfield.

yeah right...lol jimmy graham from the saints kills witten

 

[bh32]

Sorry but dez is not even close to the second best WR...tyron second best LT? I can name at least five better..

 

[Section446]

Sorry but dez is not even close to the second best WR...tyron second best LT? I can name at least five better..

Five? I'll give you a couple, but there aren't five better LT's than Tyron right now.

 

[casmith07]

The great thing about the Rowdy avatar is that it makes it remarkably easy for me to identify who to put on ignore.

 

[Section446]

The great thing about the Rowdy avatar is that it makes it remarkably easy for me to identify who to put on ignore.

I get where he's coming from with Witten, there are definitely better guys playing TE.