Rank these running backs

[jblaze2004]

Leonard Fournette (they are saying he is AP like)
nick chubb
ezekiel elliott
derrick henry
todd gurley
melvin gordon
dalvin cook
Christian McCaffrey

Go

 

[jazzcat22]

Fournette / Elliot...toss up right now to me. But I seen Elliott play much more than Fournette, and know Elliott can do it all. Seen where Fournette needs to work on a few things. So based on that, and nothing else.
Gurley / Henry, with edge to Gurley

Not sure after that.

 

[Sydla]

Leonard Fournette (they are saying he is AP like)
nick chubb
ezekiel elliott
derrick henry
todd gurley
melvin gordon
dalvin cook
Christian McCaffrey

Go

Fournette
Chubb
Elliott
Gurley (and behind Elliott only because of his knee injury history)
Cook
Henry
Gordon
McCaffery

 

[reddyuta]

Gurley
Ee
Cook
Fournette
Chubb- injury concern
Gprdon
Mccafery

 

[DeaconMoss]

Leonard Fournette (they are saying he is AP like)
nick chubb
ezekiel elliott
derrick henry
todd gurley
melvin gordon
dalvin cook
Christian McCaffrey

Go

Fournette-this dude. Man oh man. he would definitely be worth the 4th pick
gurley
chubb
zeke
gordon
henry
cook
McC - love the player but I need to see more

 

[DeaconMoss]

Fournette / Elliot...toss up right now to me. But I seen Elliott play much more than Fournette, and know Elliott can do it all. Seen where Fournette needs to work on a few things. So based on that, and nothing else.
Gurley / Henry, with edge to Gurley

Not sure after that.

Are you friggin kidding me? LSU has one game plan. Hand it, Pass it, toss it, snap it to Fournette. Every team knows the game plan. 10 in the box. Still cant stop him.

 

[okstateCowboy]

Fournette is a once in a generation type player. The other guys are not close

 

[jazzcat22]

Are you friggin kidding me? LSU has one game plan. Hand it, Pass it, toss it, snap it to Fournette. Every team knows the game plan. 10 in the box. Still cant stop him.

So the argument that Fournette is great he can't be stopped is used FOR him, however, the argument for Elliott is weaker because of the talent level he played against, is used AGAINST him.
Well, ok, whatever.
not saying you say this, but others have

college talent is college talent, I look at it as a whole, it works for every player
what is good or bad for one, it goes for the other

 

[jazzcat22]

Fournette is a year away, Elliot & Henry are now, Gurley was last year.

Let's compare Wentz to Staubach while we area t it....

 

[DFWJC]

Fournette
Gurley
Elliott
Cook
Chubb
Henry
Gordon
McCaffrey

 

[Sydla]

Fournette is a year away, Elliot & Henry are now, Gurley was last year.

Let's compare Wentz to Staubach while we area t it....

LOL.

Elliott and Henry have played the same number of NFL games Fournette has.

And another LOL at your Wentz to Staubach comment considering you've been referencing Emmitt Smith in your defense of Elliott at 4.

 

[HomeBiscuit]

Cook
Fournette
Gurley
Henry
Chubb
Gordon
McFadden
Morris
Zeke

 

[baltcowboy]

Leonard Fournette (they are saying he is AP like)
nick chubb
ezekiel elliott
derrick henry
todd gurley
melvin gordon
dalvin cook
Christian McCaffrey

Go

Dalvin Cook is the best reminds me of Toney Dorsett. He does not get caught from behind. Don't want to go through the whole group but 5 rbs could be drafted in the first next year. The question about Ezekiel is that option offense he was in. Reminds me of Alfred Morris with RG3.

 

[hornitosmonster]

Are you friggin kidding me? LSU has one game plan. Hand it, Pass it, toss it, snap it to Fournette. Every team knows the game plan. 10 in the box. Still cant stop him.

Alabama. They did nothing special and shut him down. Alabama is the closest to the type of defenses Fournette will face in the NFL.

 

[conner01]

McC is a very interesting guy. As a RB I wouldn't rank his with the guys like EE, Gurley and fournette but as a playmaker he is pretty amazing

 

[DeaconMoss]

Alabama. They did nothing special and shut him down. Alabama is the closest to the type of defenses Fournette will face in the NFL.

Alabama is probably better than the Dallas Defense. And Im not joking

 

[DeaconMoss]

So the argument that Fournette is great he can't be stopped is used FOR him, however, the argument for Elliott is weaker because of the talent level he played against, is used AGAINST him.
Well, ok, whatever.
not saying you say this, but others have

college talent is college talent, I look at it as a whole, it works for every player
what is good or bad for one, it goes for the other

If Fournette played in the Big10 he wouldve gotten 2500 yards last year

Zeke was on a team that had 3 guys that could have won the heisman

 

[DeaconMoss]

Fournette is a once in a generation type player. The other guys are not close

 

[darthseinfeld]

Until they touch what Gurley did in STL last year, iys Gurley by a mile

 

[Plankton]

Ezekiel Elliott
Todd Gurley
Dalvin Cook
Leonard Fournette
Christian McCaffrey
Nick Chubb (due to uncertain status with knee injury)
Derrick Henry
Melvin Gordon