rumor-eli manning done for season

chuffly

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,079
Reaction score
115
RoadRunner;3111699 said:
Looks like the Giants are ready to tap out on the 2009 season.

If all this is true, I sure hope the Cowboys send them riding off into the sunset this Sunday.
 

SuspectCorner

Still waiting...
Messages
10,240
Reaction score
2,861
If Dallas rocks the G-men (as I suspect they will) - THEN Eli will sit out the remainder of the season.
 

mldardy

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,614
Reaction score
7,310
I just don't see this happening until after our game with them. If we beat them then they will probably shut him down. I hope they don't because they play the Eagles the week after us.
 

The30YardSlant

Benched
Messages
24,287
Reaction score
0
So wait, we're going to face David Carr on Sunday?

Nevermind what I said earlier, I predict a 2-3 score win. Easy money. :lmao:
 

Eskimo

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,821
Reaction score
496
I don't believe this is going to happen - Eli will play against us and then decide if he wants to take the rest of the year off. If they win, he probably continues to play. If they lose, he'll sit out the rest of the year.
 

Nav22

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,449
Reaction score
17,758
I don't buy this for a second. Eli's playing.
 

viman96

Thread Killer
Messages
21,555
Reaction score
22,657
There is an article on ESPN about Eli and him saying his play is not affected. So which is it?

IMO he will play Sunday.
 

Alweezy

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,692
Reaction score
1,049
whether he plays or not, the fact that he is not healthy heading into our game really shows that New York's backs are not only against the wall, it may damn near be merging with the wall. Dallas has a chance to really smack the life out of the G-men once and for all for the 2009 season. Please don't let them off of life support 'Boys.

And yes, btw, I feel he'll be playing Sunday. No way he sits out a game of this magnitude.
 

davidb257

Benched
Messages
694
Reaction score
0
I'm not sure why everyone is acting like David Carr is mentally ********. The bench can do wonders for a QB like that.
 

Eskimo

Well-Known Member
Messages
12,821
Reaction score
496
davidb257;3111741 said:
I'm not sure why everyone is acting like David Carr is mentally ********. The bench can do wonders for a QB like that.

I agree - Carr had talent but was just wrecked by that OL in Houston and needed a chance to sit and learn and heal. We should have brought him in to backup Romo when he was available.

Besides, I seem to remember him dismantling us in the Texans first ever game.
 

dcfanatic

Benched
Messages
10,408
Reaction score
1
http://wfan.stats.com/fb/story.asp?type=REGION_NY3&i=20091130191001540000101

Manning says injury not affecting play

By BARRY WILNER, AP Football Writer


EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. (AP) Despite the New York Giants' recent slump and his own mediocre performances, quarterback Eli Manning says a stress reaction in his right foot is not affecting his play.

Manning developed the injury while dealing with another problem on the bottom of his foot during a win Oct. 4 at Kansas City. The Giants were 4-0 after that victory, but are now 6-5 as Manning has struggled in recent weeks, even though his inflamed arch has healed.

On Monday, he said his latest health issue has not been a factor on the field.

"In the games it doesn't bother me and I don't think about it. This is not something I am overly concerned with," Manning said. "It has been the same for probably the last three to four weeks, it's nothing new. I can go out and practice and do all I need to do."

Manning doesn't believe he would eventually need surgery on his foot.

"It's one of those things that time and rest is probably the biggest thing," he said. "Having the weekend and the bye week and off week helped some. Time to rest it is helpful. It is not something I think will linger or bother me."

Manning also said he has no pain when walking and there are no concerns that the stress reaction can lead to him being sidelined for any of the remaining five games.

"It is frustrating, kind of one thing leading to another. When you have to go to the training room and get treatment, it throws your schedule out of whack. It kind of pushes things back. I am a guy who doesn't like to be in a training room. That's been probably the biggest annoyance trying to deal with it."

The Giants play Dallas (8-3), Philadelphia (7-4) and Washington (3-7) in the next three weeks and pretty much need a sweep of those games for any chance to the win the NFC East. They beat the Cowboys in Week 2, their most impressive victory of the year, and also won the season opener against Washington. New York lost to Philadelphia 40-17 a month ago in perhaps its worst game of the season.

Right now, the Eagles and Packers lead the wild-card race by one game over the Giants and Falcons. Atlanta has lost to New York, so the Giants have the edge there.

"There's got to be a sense of urgency," Manning said. "We don't have time to kind of figure out and slowly become a better team and make strides. We've got to make a jump, a jump back to playing good football.

"Sometimes you will falter, and we have a lot. But we are still capable of beating teams and playing at a high level."

Manning and defensive end Justin Tuck said the players have held a few meetings during the season, but not since they lost at Denver 26-6 on Thanksgiving night. Tuck noted such meetings are "valuable when it works.
Obviously we didn't (get results) because we lost a few games here."

Manning recognizes that the message among teammates needs to be the same, meetings or not.

"Stick with each other," he said. "We know we have lot of people doubting us now and there are probably reasons for them to. If we want to pull this out and make a run ... it's about the players coming together and trusting each other and going out there and doing it."
 

Hoofbite

Well-Known Member
Messages
40,865
Reaction score
11,566
zrinkill;3111743 said:
This.

Coughlin is known for starting false rumors.

Why would anyone involved in the Giants organization start this rumor?
 

SuspectCorner

Still waiting...
Messages
10,240
Reaction score
2,861
I saw Manning fall to the ground after that late-game pass on Turkey Day... the foot definitely IS affecting his play.

'Nuff said.

[EDIT]
 
Top