Peppers-to-Pats losing steam. Now what?
Julius Peppers |
Panthers | Interested:
Dolphins?
Packers?
Broncos?
Cowboys?
Jets?
Patriots?
After Vic Carucci of
NFL.com posted a report earlier this week, saying that the
New England Patriots were close to a deal that would grant them
Carolina Panthers defensive end
Julius Peppers in exchange for a second-round draft pick, it would now appear that this outcome is unlikely, unless the people involved are all in on a ruse.
Karen Guregian of the
Boston Herald cites individuals from both parties who have now publicly stated there has been no discussion about Peppers landing with the Pats. Carl Carey, Peppers' agent, told the Herald that while the Pats had not contacted him about Peppers, "we have had preliminary discussions with GMs from other clubs in the league." Pats coach Bill Belichick, in a radio appearance on WEEI, indicated that the team prefers to deal directly with other teams and not with agents such as in this situation. He then cited
Matt Cassel as an example of what franchised players
should do if they want to be traded: sign the tender, and then ask for the trade.
All of this could be an attempt by Belichick to control the flow of information coming out of New England, and the Patriots could very well be internally considering the trade that has been getting so much play in rumor circles this week. But apparently until Peppers signs the Panthers' franchise tender - a one-year, $16.8 million deal - none of it will come to fruition.
As for the general managers "from other clubs in the league", this could be a number of individuals, but based on what Peppers has said he wants, we can eliminate many. It's likely that Peppers wants a deal similar to what
Albert Haynesworth,
Jared Allen and
Dwight Freeney possess, and he has also stated he wants to play as an outside linebacker in a 3-4 system, and for a contending team. A team that was rumored to be in the hunt was the
Dallas Cowboys, but Jerry Jones and Co. have been committed to working out an extension for
DeMarcus Ware, who is the incumbent sackmaster in Dallas, and having two high-priced players at the same position doesn't make sense. Similarly, the
Miami Dolphins could afford Peppers' price tag, but
Joey Porter is already on the roster, he of the 17.5 sacks in 2008.
This leaves the
New York Jets and the
Green Bay Packers. Some salary cap finagling would have to take place, but Peppers would be welcomed by either organization. The Jets would have a surefire playmaker instead of going forward with the
Vernon Gholston experiment, a situation which could make or break them in 2009. As for the Packers, while
Aaron Kampman is slated to take on the role as the outside rushing linebacker after eight seasons as a defensive end, Peppers is an upgrade.
One final intriguing possibility gaining momentum in rumor circles is a trade of Peppers to the
Denver Broncos for fellow disgruntled player
Jay Cutler. Pat Yasinkas, who covers the NFC South for
ESPN.com, cautions that such a move wouldn't fit the profile of Panthers management. However, it would provide an escape for Cutler, and a chance for Peppers to play in a 3-4 scheme. This would likely mean that
Chris Simms would be starting for the Broncos next season unless
Jake Delhomme was included in the trade package. In either case, it would be hard to argue that the Broncos would be contending any better than the Panthers.