Scouts Eye:What Impressed And What Didnt From Seattle

darthseinfeld

Groupthink Guru
Messages
33,551
Reaction score
38,182
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
http://www.dallascowboys.com/news/2...t-impressed-what-didnt-thursdays-trip-seattle




Scout's Eye: What Impressed & What Didn't From Thursday's Trip To Seattle
Friday, August 26, 2016 4:19 PM CDT
broaddus.jpg

By Bryan Broaddus
Football Analyst/Scout

@BryanBroaddus
FRISCO, Texas – There’s so much to unpack from Thursday night’s game against Seattle, and that’s without even discussing Tony Romo’s back.

Upon arriving back in Texas, I spent my morning re-watching the game, and – as always – there’s plenty to discuss about what we saw up at CenturyLink Field.

As we prepare for the final week of the preseason, here’s a few notes on what stood out – both good and bad – from the game.
Read

  • Jason Witten continues to amaze me with his ability to make clutch plays in the red zone. His touchdown catch from Dak Prescott was vintage Witten. There are very few pass catchers in this league that have the understanding of how to run routes in space like him. Even at his advanced age, if you try to cover him in zone he going to work for the open spot. If you play man coverage against him like the Seahawks did, he will use his body to separate. K.J. Wright couldn’t have covered Witten any better than he did. The only thing that he didn’t do was intercept the pass from Prescott, and that was because Witten went right over the top of his head and took the ball away from him. What made the finish special was the reaction of Wright sitting on the ground and him just staring at Witten and Brice Butler celebrating the touchdown.
  • Ezekiel Elliott didn’t get many opportunities to carry the ball, but he made the best of it when he did. Elliott had a stretch where he ripped off three straight runs of nine yards or better. Two of those runs were finished with impressive power. First, Elliott was able to capture the edge and turn the corner running behind a Jason Witten seal block. Then he lowered the shoulder on Bobby Wagner and K.J. Wright, sending them flying. Finally he ran through the tackle of Kam Chancellor, who tried to lower the boom on him. The rookie held his own, knocking Chancellor to the ground.
  • It was a shame that Dak Prescott and Terrance Williams couldn’t connect on that long pass early in the second quarter. Williams has had a flair for the dramatic during the preseason, but he let one get away when Prescott put the ball in a perfect spot for him to grab and he dropped it. What hurt even more about the miss, was Williams sold the “Out” route so strongly, he completely turned Jeremy Lane around to where he had four yards of separation between them. Only Kelcie McCray coming from his safety spot saved the day. McCray was able to get just enough of Williams to have him lose concentration on the ball, which resulted in the drop. It was a beautiful throw from Prescott after sliding forward in the pocket in order to get the momentum to get it out there.
  • I thought Terrell McClain was the best defensive lineman of the starters. He was active, quick off the snap and disruptive. He chased plays outside the tackle box -- which put him in position to finish. There were even snaps where Christine Michael tried to cut the ball back and he was square to the line, ready to make the play. The Seahawks guards struggled with him throughout the contest.
  • There was nothing Morris Claiborne could have done any better to defend the pass that Russell Wilson threw to Paul Richardson in the corner of the end zone. The play was well-designed with Wilson rolling to his right with the flow and then having Richardson running to his left. Against a defense that is playing man coverage – it’s tough because the Seahawks run the tight end across the field in the same area to create a downfield pick. Claiborne was able to beat the pick, but the ball was far enough down the field, where Claiborne couldn’t get his off hand to it to knock it down.
  • I know it was only the first preseason game for Justin Durant, but I have seen him play better. It didn’t appear like he had the anticipation that he has shown the past. It was like he was a step slow in reacting when he was in the game. His calling card is his ability to read, react and finish -- and he was lacking in all three. This staff could be betting on what he was instead of what he has might become – need to keep an eye on him.
  • Some really bad run fits by Damien Wilson in this game. If the line is slanting one direction, the linebackers will compensate for the linemen going away. Much too often, Wilson found himself going so far over, he was overlapping Anthony Hitchens and the ball was breaking when he should have been. If Wilson is in the correct position, the runner hits him in the chest and the hole.
  • Russell Wilson hit a huge play to Tanner McEvoy in that was a back breaker for the defense. McEvoy is listed as a receiver, but on this particular play, he lined up tight right in a wing position with his hand on the ground. J.J. Wilcox lined up over him but very deep. It appeared that the secondary lost track of where McEvoy went -- up the field and across. Wilcox turned to adjust, but he was running to the deep middle. Jeff Heath was deep toward the sideline, but he was in no-man’s land -- caught between playing the back out of the backfield and McEvoy. Wilson had his eyes on McEvoy the entire way, like it was a designed route, and delivered a perfect ball between Heath and Olatoye before they could react.
  • I have to give Brice Butler and Lucky Whitehead a lot of credit for the completion that Dak Prescott was able to pull off when Richard Sherman smashed him in the stomach. It was Whitehead who had stayed in to help with the protection that allowed Prescott to get to the outside. His block on Kelcie McCray allowed Prescott to keep his eyes down the field to pick up Butler coming across. Once Butler saw his quarterback in trouble, he never stopped running, which gave Prescott the option to make the throw. It took a lot of courage to make that play before he took the hit.
  • Thought it was a tough chance for Andy Jones on the deep ball from Jameill Showers. Quarterbacks are taught to throw the ball to the outside and away from the defender -- which is where Showers put it. Jones ran his route two-to-three yards off the sideline while the ball ended up just a yard away. Jones tried his best to track it, but his body position was poor. It appeared that he really wasn’t sure where he was on the field as he was trying to drag his feet and adjust at the same time. All of that combined to make the play more difficult than it already was.
  • If I were working in a scouting department for another club and I wasn’t happy with my punt returner – I would see what the Cowboys want for Dax Swanson. I don’t believe that he is going to make the squad as a cornerback, but he has some unique talent as a returner. There is a fearless nature in the way he returns these punts right up the middle of the field. It takes courage, vision along with quickness to do this job and there is a side of me that believes he has all of those traits and maybe a little more.
  • Something to keep an eye on – Austin Traylor took first team snaps with the offense when they went with their “12” and “13” personnel groups. I said this last week that Traylor is the most physical blocker of the tight ends not named Jason Witten and he is capable of doing the things that James Hanna does at the point of attack.
 

jazzcat22

Staff member
Messages
81,310
Reaction score
102,240
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Ok, so is Broaddus giving Durant a pass because it was his 1st game action. But yet in another article he was critical of Malik Collins for his play. And his 1st game action as a rookie coming off of a broken ankle.
Well, as I said, Broaddus has improved from a reporter view, but he needs to lay off the scouting views. LOL.

As for Witten, great job as usual, but if they now can get him to stop those false starts during the regular season. LOL.

Traylor pushing for them to keep 4 TE's, so what happens when Hanna is ready to return. Kind of like the RB group, where do they all fit once all are available. Heck even with DMC on NFI, where do the 4 fit, if they keep 4 TE's. Keeping 5 WR's, 2 QB's, 8 OL will help there.
 

big dog cowboy

THE BIG DOG
Staff member
Messages
101,901
Reaction score
112,893
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Ok, so is Broaddus giving Durant a pass because it was his 1st game action. But yet in another article he was critical of Malik Collins for his play. And his 1st game action as a rookie coming off of a broken ankle.
:hammer:
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
I wish we could see Showers with the 1s.

I can understand giving Dak the bulk but they ought to give him a series or so. If not then they have already decided the issue (who can blame them) and Showers will have to rely on two injuries to get on the field and we know where all stand on that FO and fans alike.
 

Sarek

Povar
Messages
8,032
Reaction score
11,925
I can understand giving Dak the bulk but they ought to give him a series or so. If not then they have already decided the issue (who can blame them) and Showers will have to rely on two injuries to get on the field and we know where all stand on that FO and fans alike.

I think they have decided already.
 

casmith07

Attorney-at-Zone
Messages
31,538
Reaction score
9,312
Ok, so is Broaddus giving Durant a pass because it was his 1st game action. But yet in another article he was critical of Malik Collins for his play. And his 1st game action as a rookie coming off of a broken ankle.
Well, as I said, Broaddus has improved from a reporter view, but he needs to lay off the scouting views. LOL.

As for Witten, great job as usual, but if they now can get him to stop those false starts during the regular season. LOL.

Traylor pushing for them to keep 4 TE's, so what happens when Hanna is ready to return. Kind of like the RB group, where do they all fit once all are available. Heck even with DMC on NFI, where do the 4 fit, if they keep 4 TE's. Keeping 5 WR's, 2 QB's, 8 OL will help there.

It's Broaddus...you take the bad with the bad.

I can understand giving Dak the bulk but they ought to give him a series or so. If not then they have already decided the issue (who can blame them) and Showers will have to rely on two injuries to get on the field and we know where all stand on that FO and fans alike.

Same. It looks like they'll probably be trying to get Showers through to the practice squad again. I think it's a safe bet, looking around at different rosters in the league. Nobody is going to sign him and use a spot on their 53 as a straight backup, and definitely not as a 3rd QB when they can add WRs, etc.
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
It's Broaddus...you take the bad with the bad.



Same. It looks like they'll probably be trying to get Showers through to the practice squad again. I think it's a safe bet, looking around at different rosters in the league. Nobody is going to sign him and use a spot on their 53 as a straight backup, and definitely not as a 3rd QB when they can add WRs, etc.

Agreed. Don't think he got a square shot but Dak stole the show. As lone as he continues to progress then I'm ok. I just feel bad for the kid.
 

casmith07

Attorney-at-Zone
Messages
31,538
Reaction score
9,312
Agreed. Don't think he got a square shot but Dak stole the show. As lone as he continues to progress then I'm ok. I just feel bad for the kid.

I would personally have him on the 53 if they like him. If Romo is out for any length of time, Dak will need a backup.
 

Texas_Pete

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,752
Reaction score
15,777
Ok, so is Broaddus giving Durant a pass because it was his 1st game action. But yet in another article he was critical of Malik Collins for his play. And his 1st game action as a rookie coming off of a broken ankle.
Well, as I said, Broaddus has improved from a reporter view, but he needs to lay off the scouting views. LOL.

As for Witten, great job as usual, but if they now can get him to stop those false starts during the regular season. LOL.

Traylor pushing for them to keep 4 TE's, so what happens when Hanna is ready to return. Kind of like the RB group, where do they all fit once all are available. Heck even with DMC on NFI, where do the 4 fit, if they keep 4 TE's. Keeping 5 WR's, 2 QB's, 8 OL will help there.
Hanna is our best blocking TE. While he is out Traylor may be able to squeeze onto the final 53 (especially if he can play special teams). I anticipate we'll lean heavily on the run to protect Romo and our defense so we need our best blockers on the field. Not sure if he is a better blocker than Swaim though.
 

TwoDeep3

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,506
Reaction score
17,339
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
I wish we could see Showers with the 1s.

I can understand giving Dak the bulk but they ought to give him a series or so. If not then they have already decided the issue (who can blame them) and Showers will have to rely on two injuries to get on the field and we know where all stand on that FO and fans alike.

The coaching staff sees these guys in practice. At what point do you just trust what they think over the intangible of a player that seems to not get on the field?

I struggled with Romo taking over for Bledsoe, for a similar reason that you two have about Showers, but maybe in reverse.

I saw the experienced pro as the more viable player over a guy who warmed the bench. But the coaches had seen enough. It was the right move and I needed to get over it.

So maybe the coaches have seen enough of Dak vs Showers and you get what they think is the best foot forward.

I am not telling you to get over it. I'm just saying their paid opinion is Dak is where they will plant their flag unless something drastically changes.

This is a good thing, by the way.
 

casmith07

Attorney-at-Zone
Messages
31,538
Reaction score
9,312
Personally, I would not even play Romo or Dak the last preseason game. Just go with Showers for the whole game.

I would do the same. Give him a full game with as much talent as possible.
 

casmith07

Attorney-at-Zone
Messages
31,538
Reaction score
9,312
The coaching staff sees these guys in practice. At what point do you just trust what they think over the intangible of a player that seems to not get on the field?

I struggled with Romo taking over for Bledsoe, for a similar reason that you two have about Showers, but maybe in reverse.

I saw the experienced pro as the more viable player over a guy who warmed the bench. But the coaches had seen enough. It was the right move and I needed to get over it.

So maybe the coaches have seen enough of Dak vs Showers and you get what they think is the best foot forward.

I am not telling you to get over it. I'm just saying their paid opinion is Dak is where they will plant their flag unless something drastically changes.

This is a good thing, by the way.

The preseason is practice.
 

Bluefin

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,209
Reaction score
9,677
I would personally have him on the 53 if they like him.

I listened to one of the shows on dallascowboys.com this week, I forget which, and they said some inside Valley Ranch felt Jameill Showers was the same QB as Dak Prescott when the draft board was being put together.

So it appears Showers has some fans in the front office.

Will it be enough to make the 53?

I'm willing to try getting Showers through waivers and on the Practice Squad.
 

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,527
Reaction score
29,874
  • thought Terrell McClain was the best defensive lineman of the starters. He was active, quick off the snap and disruptive. He chased plays outside the tackle box -- which put him in position to finish. There were even snaps where Christine Michael tried to cut the ball back and he was square to the line, ready to make the play. The Seahawks guards struggled with him throughout the contest.

  • There was nothing Morris Claiborne could have done any better to defend the pass that Russell Wilson threw to Paul Richardson in the corner of the end zone. The play was well-designed with Wilson rolling to his right with the flow and then having Richardson running to his left. Against a defense that is playing man coverage – it’s tough because the Seahawks run the tight end across the field in the same area to create a downfield pick. Claiborne was able to beat the pick, but the ball was far enough down the field, where Claiborne couldn’t get his off hand to it to knock it down.

  • I know it was only the first preseason game for Justin Durant, but I have seen him play better. It didn’t appear like he had the anticipation that he has shown the past. It was like he was a step slow in reacting when he was in the game. His calling card is his ability to read, react and finish -- and he was lacking in all three. This staff could be betting on what he was instead of what he has might become – need to keep an eye on him.

 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,982
Reaction score
48,729
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
McClain has been playing well all preseason and camp.
Nice to have him healthy.
 

jobberone

Kane Ala
Messages
54,219
Reaction score
19,659
I would personally have him on the 53 if they like him. If Romo is out for any length of time, Dak will need a backup.

Yeah hadn't thought about a backup for the backup. My guess is he is destined for the PS and will suit up as the emergency QB. If Romo or Dak go out for more than a game then he gets promoted to the 53. JMO.
 
Top