Should we have signed Peyton?

[Pessimist_cowboy]

I bet Jerry regrets it now . We would probably win back to back superbowls . We could have had him for free as a free agent and we could have revis teamed up with Brandon Carr . The question isn't when we wouldve won a superbowl with Peyton but how many ?

 

[Vintage]

awesome post. would read again.

 

[Staubacher]

How is Peyton free and how does Revis fit in that thought?

Bar post!

 

[Titleist]

Umm Peyton blew his chance to go to the SB last year on a superior team than the Cowboys. What makes you think he would've brought us to the SB last year behind that dreadful line?

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

Free agent my friend free agent . Toni 6 year 108 mill . Peyton 3 year 35 million u make choice .

 

[khiladi]

Well, yes because that would imply Jason Garrett would be gone, cause Peyton ain't running his crap offense.

 

[khiladi]

Umm Peyton blew his chance to go to the SB last year on a superior team than the Cowboys. What makes you think he would've brought us to the SB last year behind that dreadful line?

Not really, their CB did with that awful coverage...

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

Umm Peyton blew his chance to go to the SB last year on a superior team than the Cowboys. What makes you think he would've brought us to the SB last year behind that dreadful line?

Rahim Moore blew it for the broncos . Peyton was best I've seen him last year . This year 9 tds zero picks .

 

[RS12]

Peyton Manning behind this line? Not so much. BTW we'll see how he does now that Clady is hurt.

 

[lane]

we don't have near enough smart players to work with peyton.......... nor the o- line for him to make it out of the dress rehearsal preseason game.

denver and john elway threw the dice on how bad his neck was injured...

they have rolled 7 or 11 ever since.

denver might go to the dance this year...even with their starting center out for the year.

 

[KJJ]

I bet Jerry regrets it now . We would probably win back to back superbowls . We could have had him for free as a free agent and we could have revis teamed up with Brandon Carr . The question isn't when we wouldve won a superbowl with Peyton but how many ?

Peyton has only won one SB and is 9-11 in the playoffs he has some of the same turnover issues Romo has in do or die games. Besides he wouldn't have wanted to be apart of Jerry's world.

 

[NorthwestDallas40]

I bet Jerry regrets it now . We would probably win back to back superbowls . We could have had him for free as a free agent and we could have revis teamed up with Brandon Carr . The question isn't when we wouldve won a superbowl with Peyton but how many ?

Regrets what? That Peyton did not return his call? There is no way Peyton would have come here over the better franchises and GMs he considered. I'm sure the thought of playing for Dallas never even crossed his mind.

 

[whynot]

geez - and you guys think Romo chokes.

At least Peyton makes the playoffs I suppose.

 

[TheRomoSexual]

Worst. Post. Ever.

 

[Zman5]

Yes. Because we need a QB that can throw better 1 yard slants and 3 yard passes.

 

[RS12]

Yes. Because we need a QB that can throw better 1 and 3 yard passes.

That left a mark.

 

[ShiningStar]

contrary to popular belief, not everyone wants to play for Dallas. WHo knows what else Denver gave up to get him to agree.

 

[The Natural]

Peyton never gave a thought to signing with the Cowboys what in the world is OP talking about

 

[Eanwen]

If he signed with Dallas he would have been in the same division as his brother. IMO his decision to go with Denver over the 49ers would indicate that he didn't even want to be in the same conference as Eli.

 

[dstovall5]

No, not even a chance. First off, when he came back no one knew how healthy he actually was. A lot of people believed that he wouldn't be able to take another hit when he came back, so us signing him would've been foolish. With our woeful o-line problems, Peyton wouldn't of lasted a whole season here.
Also, if he couldn't win with a solid overall team that even Tebow won with, what makes you think he could do the same with a much inferior Dallas team?