Video: SNF Anthem: Faith vs Carrie

[Teren_Kanan]

Not even close. Faith Hill.

This.

Carrie isn't bad, nor is the new rendition. But Faith's voice is so much stronger, and less twang. Also.. those LEGS MAN!

 

[KJJ]

I'm fine with either version read where it was Faith Hills decision to step away.

 

[khiladi]

Carrie>Faith.

Overall their voices are about equal, but we've been listening to Faith hill sing it for the last 6 years or so, so it's ingrained in us that Hill's version is the 'right' version.

But Carrie is better looking and just more... fresh, compared to Hill.

Both are far better than Pink. Pink is one of the worst things in music today.

Pink is one of the worst things in music today, in an industry full of Nicky Menaj's and Miley Cyrus' and a bunch of other non-talented auto-tuned females that can't sing? Pink is a talented singer. Furter, claiming Carrie Underwood is just better looking is a pretty subjective claim. If Carrie Underwood looks that good at that age, come back to me. Faith's legs are on a different level.

 

[Nova]

Pink is one of the worst in an industry full of Nichy Menaj's and Miley Cyrus' nd a bunch of auto-tuned females that can't sing. Pink is an awesome singer and pretty damn talented.
And claiming Carrie Underwood is just better looking is a pretty subjective claim. If Carrie Underwood looks that good at that age, come back to me.

Well, yeah. That's just my opinion with regard to Carrie Underwood being better looking than Faith Hill. If someone prefers Hill over Underwood, then that's fine.

 

[LittleBoyBlue]

I'd buy that for a dollar!

Or Pink.....

You know what... Pink is a good option too!


Truth is... Carrie and Faith don't have the right vocals for that song!

 

[LittleBoyBlue]

Pink is one of the worst things in music today, in an industry full of Nicky Menaj's and Miley Cyrus' and a bunch of other non-talented auto-tuned females that can't sing? Pink is a talented singer. Furter, claiming Carrie Underwood is just better looking is a pretty subjective claim. If Carrie Underwood looks that good at that age, come back to me. Faith's legs are on a different level.

I don't follow... Pink = good or Pink = bad ??

 

[CanadianCowboysFan]

I don't follow... Pink = good or Pink = bad ??

yeah how can Pink be talented but worst thing to happen to music

 

[WoodysGirl]

I don't follow... Pink = good or Pink = bad ??

yeah how can Pink be talented but worst thing to happen to music

He was repeating what the guy said in his quoted response before disputing why she is talented.

 

[Rogah]

Both are good and i like them.

Neither song does it for me.


You need a raspy rocket female voice. Just imagine Joan Jett singing, "I've been waiting all day for Sunday night..... Owwwwwww"

They tried that Year 1 when Pink did the song, and it went over like a lead balloon. Joan Jett may have worked because she is far more talented than Pink, especially considering that that song is based off one she wrote, but I doubt terribly many guys under 35 have a clue who she is.

As for Faith vs. Carrie, it's no contest: Faith.

 

[Lonestar94]

Yeah.. I'll take Carrie.

 

[KJJ]

Yeah.. I'll take Carrie.

Can't find any pics of Carrie without makeup but she's still young enough and has such a sweet wholesome face that she wouldn't scare anyone without it. At 46 Faith needs makeup and plenty of moisturizer. There was a thread with celebrities with and without makeup and it really destroyed the fantasies of a lot of men on here. Jlo looked like a prize fighter without makeup.

 

[arglebargle]

They tried that Year 1 when Pink did the song, and it went over like a lead balloon. Joan Jett may have worked because she is far more talented than Pink, especially considering that that song is based off one she wrote, but I doubt terribly many guys under 35 have a clue who she is.

As for Faith vs. Carrie, it's no contest: Faith.

There was probably a desire to get someone 'edgy' for their first season. Afterwards, I think NFL execs finally watched some of Pink's concert videos and went apoplectic.

 

[khiladi]

Can't find any pics of Carrie without makeup but she's still young enough and has such a sweet wholesome face that she wouldn't scare anyone without it. At 46 Faith needs makeup and plenty of moisturizer. There was a thread with celebrities with and without makeup and it really destroyed the fantasies of a lot of men on here. Jlo looked like a prize fighter without makeup.

 

[KJJ]

Not bad without makeup she looks sexy when she's pissed.

 

[khiladi]

Not bad without makeup she looks sexy when she's pissed.

Blah.. talk about not being the same Carrie on camera...

But, pictures don't often accurately reflect real-life beauty as well. A person could look worse in a picture without make-up than they look in real life without make-up.

 

[KJJ]

Blah.. talk about not being the same Carrie on camera...

But, pictures don't often accurately reflect real-life beauty as well. A person could look worse in a picture without make-up than they look in real life without make-up.

Some people are photogenic and some aren't. There's people who look better in photographs than they do in person and vice versa. I've seen Carrie in real life she looks just as beautiful in person as she does in pictures.

 

[WV Cowboy]

They both are very pretty, but Carrie is 30 and Faith is 46.

Not a fair comparison.

 

[ScipioCowboy]

They're both great. To be honest, though, I was never a fan of the quasi-dubstep sound of the 2012 rendition.

 

[LittleBoyBlue]

Wow. Just saw the Thursday night football song.

They are all horrible.

 

[Rockport]

Carrie