so much for crowd noise/NFL experiment in europe

LatinMind

iPhotoshop
Messages
17,458
Reaction score
11,571
Contributed by Tyler Donchez Friday, 02 March 2007
Well, news has leaked out that in April, the NFL’s European league will test out some new technology that if successful, could make its’ way over to the NFL. That technology is a radio system, one that would send play calls directly from the coaches, into the helmet of every player on the field. The technology would block out all of the crowd noise, and thus eliminate home field advantage, as we know it in the NFL.
NFL commissioner Roger Goodell feels that the radio system could be very good for the league because it would shorten games by ten or so minutes by cutting down on false start and delay of game penalties. Well, since we are all of a sudden worried about the game length, here are some ideas I think I’m going to shoot over to the commissioner’s office. Call them friendly suggestions.
First, let’s get rid of kickoffs. I mean, these things take up about 14 crucial seconds of the game. Besides, when does anything exciting ever happen on a kickoff anyway? Let’s just give the team receiving the ball at the 25-yard line every time. This would also cut down on fumbles, which can take up to 3 seconds to recover. I’m sure Dante’ Hall and Devin Hester can find work some place else.
Extra points are totally unnecessary too. The things are automatic, who in the world misses an extra point? Simply give the team that just scored 7 points, no questions asked. When in the history has an extra point affected the outcome of an NFL game anyway?
I almost forgot punts, those terribly un-needed punts. What do they serve to the NFL besides a 10 second period to re-fill your beer? Especially those so called “good” punters that kick the ball into the air for 4 seconds…god it just makes my blood boil that the game is going to go that much longer due to a freaking punt. I suggest getting the option of either marking off 40 yards and giving the defense the ball there, or signing a designated thrower to the team and he can just chuck the ball down field as far as he can like all of us used to do during touch football. That way quarterbacks like Michael Vick will keep their job. No returns on these throws by the way…time is money. Perhaps even get a head start on commercials at this time in the game.
If Mr. Goodell doesn’t like any of these ideas, then maybe he will take my advice right now and just get rid of the 1st quarter entirely, making the game 3 quarters long. Nothing good happens until the 4th quarter anyway.
It also seems like the Commissioner wants to take the crowd out of the game as well. I mean, with these radios, players will not be able to hear the fans, and therefore, are completely ineffective as a 12th man. Well, I say if your going to fizzle out the fans, fizzle them out all the way Roger!
Instead of “DEFENSE” and “LOUUUUDER!!!” flashing on the scoreboard during crucial parts of the game, I suggest we simply put “Shhhh, quiet” up there instead. Think golf, when the guy raises his arm with that sign right before a golfer putts. We don’t’ want to throw any of the players off their games right?
Soundproof walls built around the field would not hurt either. Of course they would be see through, giving the fans a reason to spend their money on a ticket, but the players would be totally in effected by the chants of the home crowd. All sides win. The fans get to watch the game, the players can hear themselves, and the league gets to cut down on crucial minutes to the current drag of a game that is pro football.
In 5th grade I remember every day when we went to get packed up to go home, our teacher would give away skittles to the table that put up their seats and got their stuff the quietest. I suggest a “rainbow of fruit flavors” goes to the row that can do this throughout the whole game.
Now, of course all of the above ideas are ridiculous, and almost every single one of them would take away a part of the NFL that we all love. Since when was the game length of an NFL game an issue at all? It is the most watched sport in America and has only gotten bigger over time. The time of the game has little or no effect whatsoever on who watches it and how many people watch it. I can see the NFL’s new slogan now. “NFL SUNDAYS ON FOX: NOW 8 MINUTES SHORTER!” It’s completely ludicrous to think this whole radio system is in the works in order to shorten games by getting rid of false start penalties. If you take away the home field advantage in an NFL game, it’s almost like taking the chocolate icing off of the chocolate cake. Sure, if you take it off it is still cake…but it is not nearly as good or worth my hard earned money to buy.
 

Bob Sacamano

Benched
Messages
57,084
Reaction score
3
LatinMind;1420945 said:
When in the history has an extra point affected the outcome of an NFL game anyway?

witness Dallas vs. Arizona, 2000 or 2001, Toby Gowin or Tim Seder botches a snap, we end up losing 7-6
 

BLT

Member
Messages
807
Reaction score
0
Bob Sacamano;1420948 said:
witness Dallas vs. Arizona, 2000 or 2001, Toby Gowin or Tim Seder botches a snap, we end up losing 7-6

he was being sarcastic.
 

mmillman

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,153
Reaction score
35
Devin Hester would argue with your kickoff theory. I am all for shortening the games and I am sure my wife would be happier. Shortening games by other means usually means less time for advertising so if they can cut down on the nuisance penalties then so be it.
 

LatinMind

iPhotoshop
Messages
17,458
Reaction score
11,571
mmillman;1421026 said:
Devin Hester would argue with your kickoff theory. I am all for shortening the games and I am sure my wife would be happier. Shortening games by other means usually means less time for advertising so if they can cut down on the nuisance penalties then so be it.

its not my theory, and this article was basically being sarcastic to the rule change that the nfl is trying to put into effect. or atleast testing it.
 

xpistofer

Active Member
Messages
999
Reaction score
199
LatinMind;1420945 said:
Contributed by Tyler Donchez Friday, 02 March 2007
Well, news has leaked out that in April, the NFL’s European league will test out some new technology that if successful, could make its’ way over to the NFL. That technology is a radio system, one that would send play calls directly from the coaches, into the helmet of every player on the field. The technology would block out all of the crowd noise, and thus eliminate home field advantage, as we know it in the NFL.
NFL commissioner Roger Goodell feels that the radio system could be very good for the league because it would shorten games by ten or so minutes by cutting down on false start and delay of game penalties. Well, since we are all of a sudden worried about the game length, here are some ideas I think I’m going to shoot over to the commissioner’s office. Call them friendly suggestions.
First, let’s get rid of kickoffs. I mean, these things take up about 14 crucial seconds of the game. Besides, when does anything exciting ever happen on a kickoff anyway? Let’s just give the team receiving the ball at the 25-yard line every time. This would also cut down on fumbles, which can take up to 3 seconds to recover. I’m sure Dante’ Hall and Devin Hester can find work some place else.
Extra points are totally unnecessary too. The things are automatic, who in the world misses an extra point? Simply give the team that just scored 7 points, no questions asked. When in the history has an extra point affected the outcome of an NFL game anyway?
I almost forgot punts, those terribly un-needed punts. What do they serve to the NFL besides a 10 second period to re-fill your beer? Especially those so called “good” punters that kick the ball into the air for 4 seconds…god it just makes my blood boil that the game is going to go that much longer due to a freaking punt. I suggest getting the option of either marking off 40 yards and giving the defense the ball there, or signing a designated thrower to the team and he can just chuck the ball down field as far as he can like all of us used to do during touch football. That way quarterbacks like Michael Vick will keep their job. No returns on these throws by the way…time is money. Perhaps even get a head start on commercials at this time in the game.
If Mr. Goodell doesn’t like any of these ideas, then maybe he will take my advice right now and just get rid of the 1st quarter entirely, making the game 3 quarters long. Nothing good happens until the 4th quarter anyway.
It also seems like the Commissioner wants to take the crowd out of the game as well. I mean, with these radios, players will not be able to hear the fans, and therefore, are completely ineffective as a 12th man. Well, I say if your going to fizzle out the fans, fizzle them out all the way Roger!
Instead of “DEFENSE” and “LOUUUUDER!!!” flashing on the scoreboard during crucial parts of the game, I suggest we simply put “Shhhh, quiet” up there instead. Think golf, when the guy raises his arm with that sign right before a golfer putts. We don’t’ want to throw any of the players off their games right?
Soundproof walls built around the field would not hurt either. Of course they would be see through, giving the fans a reason to spend their money on a ticket, but the players would be totally in effected by the chants of the home crowd. All sides win. The fans get to watch the game, the players can hear themselves, and the league gets to cut down on crucial minutes to the current drag of a game that is pro football.
In 5th grade I remember every day when we went to get packed up to go home, our teacher would give away skittles to the table that put up their seats and got their stuff the quietest. I suggest a “rainbow of fruit flavors” goes to the row that can do this throughout the whole game.
Now, of course all of the above ideas are ridiculous, and almost every single one of them would take away a part of the NFL that we all love. Since when was the game length of an NFL game an issue at all? It is the most watched sport in America and has only gotten bigger over time. The time of the game has little or no effect whatsoever on who watches it and how many people watch it. I can see the NFL’s new slogan now. “NFL SUNDAYS ON FOX: NOW 8 MINUTES SHORTER!” It’s completely ludicrous to think this whole radio system is in the works in order to shorten games by getting rid of false start penalties. If you take away the home field advantage in an NFL game, it’s almost like taking the chocolate icing off of the chocolate cake. Sure, if you take it off it is still cake…but it is not nearly as good or worth my hard earned money to buy.


great article...

if this goes down, then so does Goodell, in my estimation...
 

theogt

Surrealist
Messages
45,846
Reaction score
5,912
False starts are nothing short of annoying. I couldn't care less if it gets rid of crowd noise.
 

arglebargle

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,373
Reaction score
409
Yeah, the article was perhaps a little too sarcastic. And they are testing it elsewhere to see how it works before implementing it.

I guess we should get rid of the anti-concussion helmets as well. The old ways were good enough for....ah...what's his name?
 

Crown Royal

Insulin Beware
Messages
14,229
Reaction score
6,383
arglebargle;1421127 said:
Yeah, the article was perhaps a little too sarcastic. And they are testing it elsewhere to see how it works before implementing it.

I guess we should get rid of the anti-concussion helmets as well. The old ways were good enough for....ah...what's his name?

Excellent post. I have no issue with them testing it elsewhere. If it looks like it would screw up the game in Europe, then I doubt they will bring it here.

The only thing I don't like is that it involves the coaches even more. It's like they are playing madden on the field. Kinda destroys the need for your QB to be a field general.
 

TheSkaven

Last Man Standing
Messages
7,021
Reaction score
5,775
So, lessening the effect of crowd noise eliminates home field advantage? Since when? And why does not allowing the players to hear have any part in the game anyway?

The effect of a hostile crowd is more one of intimidation, taunting, and support for the home team. Not screaming so loud that the opponents can't hear the plays called. JMHO
 

AbeBeta

Well-Known Member
Messages
35,680
Reaction score
12,392
Crown Royal;1421131 said:
If it looks like it would screw up the game in Europe, then I doubt they will bring it here.

If a game in NFLE is screwed up and no one is there to see it does it make an impact on the decision to use the technology?
 

stag hunter

Hater
Messages
612
Reaction score
9
bigbadroy;1421140 said:
keep it the same. no more new stuff in the nfl

If people thought always thought that way, an incomplete pass would still be a turnover, there'd be no hashmarks, and players would still be going both ways
 

cowboysfan31

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,356
Reaction score
126
The players feed off of the energy from the crowd. I can't imagine taking them out of the game...it just wouldn't be football.
 

Clove

Shrinkage
Messages
64,894
Reaction score
27,490
NFL football is all about orginazation and discipline along with the physical play and everything else. If the guy is undiscipline enough to false start, his team pays the price.

If the coaches can't get the plays in on time, their team pays the price. Tons of teams don't have issues with getting plays in, and tons of linemen don't false start nearly as much as others.
 
Top