He has played well, in spots, but clearly he lost the Commanders game, the Raiders game and the Seahawks game. With him, it's not just the passes that he throws, but he holds the ball too long at times which gets him sacked and everyone blames the offensive line. Was it the O-line's fault he didn't see Witten in the end zone? His biggest problem is his decision-making and that's not acceptable for a 12 year vet. People keep talking about that if he's protected, he'll be fine, but Carter didn't have great protection from the O-line or any half-way decent backs, and he still got us to the playoffs, including come from behind wins against the Panthers and Eagles who played in the conference championship game. We had no running game either time.
You're right,he is better than a third of the starting qb's today and better than 3/4 of the backups(did you see the Jets last night?), but lots of players have off-field issues and are still allowed to play(Ricky Williams,Leonard Little,Brian Griese and Kerry Collins).