We had Witten open in both games and probably would have scored, yet he made misreads. In the Seahawks game, on that last pass, if he throws the ball away, takes a sack or dumps the ball off to a back, we go into overtime. He did the one thing you must not do in that situation, throw the pick, and he threw it to a double-covered receiver who's only 5"10'. His pick led directly to the winning field goal for Seattle. If Q had done that or Vinny, you guys would have been ready to kick them to the curb. There would be none of that, "he's the only reason we're winning crap" because we now have a true top defense, capable of shutting down elite RB's like Alexander and Portis and Tomlinson. Our 2003 defense was pushed all over the field by Jay Fiedler and in the second half of the second Eagles game and in the playoffs against Carolina. Where was that number one defense that carried the team in those games and where was it last year with almost the same personnel. We played against nothing but mediocre offenses in 2003 and got exposed in 2004.
So now we have the kind of qb you want, but he's older,less athletic and makes the same kind of mistakes Q made in his third year in the NFL, and you think this is an upgrade. You make excuses for him like he's your brother and refuse to cut a younger, less experienced qb any slack for making 3rd year qb mistakes. Nonsense, you invented it and have the nerve criticize others.