Sporting News Russ Lande ranks WRs

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,528
Reaction score
29,874
Some serious suprises here. Has Tate 6th ahead of team mate Hakeem Nicks. Has Austin Collie of BYU at 8, have seen too many BYU prospects wash out. Patrick Turner 10 from USC. I think he will be there 5th to 7th, has skill and a big body.;)

1. Michael Crabtree, Texas Tech (6-1 3/8, 215)
Crabtree is a strong receiver with deceptive athleticism who knows how to get open. He catches passes in traffic without hesitation and holds on to the ball after he takes a hard hit. After playing in Texas Tech's pass-happy offense, Crabtree must adjust to a pro-style offense but has everything it takes to be successful in the NFL. Teams are not that concerned with his stress fracture in the foot.

2. Kenny Britt, Rutgers (6-2 7/8, 215)
Britt is a big competitor who can change the game in an instant with the ball in his hands. He is productive, has outstanding strength and accelerates to top speed quickly, making him a deep threat. Britt, not Crabtree, might be the best receiver in the draft. There are minor character concerns regarding Britt, but nothing that will keep him from being drafted in the first round.

3. Jeremy Maclin, Missouri (6-0 1/8, 198)
Maclin, a redshirt sophomore, is a threat to score on any touch. In '07, he scored four rushing touchdowns, nine receiving touchdowns, two punt-return touchdowns and one kick-return touchdown. He could make an immediate impact as a No. 3 receiver and kick returner while developing his route-running skills, and in time will become a dangerous weapon as a starter.

4. Percy Harvin, Florida (5-11 1/8, 192)
Harvin was an impact player in college as a receiver and return man. He has more rushing yards than any wideout in Gators history, as well. His versatility as a receiver, slot man, tailback and return man will make him a weapon NFL offensive coordinators will love, and he will create lots of matchup problems. Harvin will be among the best receivers in the draft.


5. Darrius Heyward-Bey, Maryland (6-1 5/8, 212)
There is little doubt he has the physical tools to be a legitimate big-play threat in the NFL. However, to join the ranks of the elite, he must improve his route-running skills and show greater consistency catching the ball. He will need time to develop in those areas, but Heyward-Bey should become a productive starter.

6. Brandon Tate, North Carolina (5-11 7/8, 183)
Going into the '08 season, Tate was viewed primarily as a return man. He stepped up early in the season to emerge as an NFL-caliber receiver. Unfortunately, he played in only six games before injuring his right knee and had surgery to repair his MCL and ACL. Tate must prove his knee is healthy and convince teams he can return to his pre-injury form to remain a high pick. He has the tools to rebound from his injury and become a productive big-play receiver and return man in the NFL.

7. Hakeem Nicks, North Carolina (6-0 3/4, 212)
Nicks made the right decision to leave after his breakout junior season, entering the draft when his stock is the highest. He has everything it takes to make big plays, and he is a rare receiving prospect who should be drafted late in the first round or early in the second.

8. Austin Collie, Brigham Young (6-1 1/8, 196)
Collie is an outstanding athlete with superb speed, agility and body control, and he plays the game fast. He is smart and understands the offense, able to work from multiple positions. However, he must get stronger and work on his blocking technique. Collie will be a solid NFL player and should be a starter his rookie year.

9. Louis Murphy, Florida (6-3 3/8, 203)
Murphy has not gotten much attention because he has played alongside great Gators receivers such as Andre Caldwell (Bengals) and Harvin but has the physical tools to become a solid NFL starter. Although thinner than ideal, Murphy should be able to bulk up to the 210- to 215-pound range.

10. Patrick Turner, Southern Cal (6-5 1/8, 223)
Turner is another USC receiver with the athleticism to compensate for a lack of elite speed. He won't knock anyone's socks off with his workout numbers, but he was a better college receiver than former Trojans Dwayne Jarrett and Steve Smith.
 

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,528
Reaction score
29,874
Uh, maybe I was wrong about Collie. I know he played in the WAC where only Utah and TCU believe in playing defense, but these are some dominant numbers.

Statistics

2008 GAME BY GAME
OPPONENT Rec Yds TD Long Avg/R
NO. IOWA 7 80 0 30 11.4
WASHINGTON 5 74 1 38 14.8
UCLA 10 110 2 37 11.0
WYOMING 8 122 2 62 15.3
UTAH STATE 8 132 2 76 16.5
NEW MEXICO 9 155 1 58 17.2
TCU 6 116 0 49 19.3
UNLV 7 113 0 30 16.7
CSU 9 156 3 58 17.3
SDSU 9 127 2 61 14.1
AIR FORCE 7 130 2 45 18.6
UTAH 10 104 0 19 10.4
ARIZONA 11 119 0 36 10.
 

Bob Sacamano

Benched
Messages
57,084
Reaction score
3
I like Collie, he's 4.5 guy but plays faster than that, and supposedly he put on a clinic catching the football as well as showing great quickness
 

Avery

The Dog that Saved Charleston
Messages
19,465
Reaction score
20,518
I've watched Collie for years and I don't see him being anymore than a #3 in the pros. I'd hardly classify his speed as superb.

He does have good hands, but he's not going to start in the NFL unless your team has injuries/Matt Jones.
 

Common Sense

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,897
Reaction score
2,048
Avery;2698247 said:
He does have good hands, but he's not going to start in the NFL unless your team has injuries/Matt Jones.

What are we waiting for? Sign him up! :D
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,665
Reaction score
86,206
Heyward Bey is really intriguing to me.

He definetely has some skills.
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,971
CATCH17;2699964 said:
Heyward Bey is really intriguing to me.

He definetely has some skills.

but very little production.

he's one of those guys that looks great until you watch him play football. he will rise every day away from his last game because he is a workout warrior.
 

Bob Sacamano

Benched
Messages
57,084
Reaction score
3
jterrell;2699980 said:
but very little production.

he's one of those guys that looks great until you watch him play football. he will rise every day away from his last game because he is a workout warrior.

to be fair, Maryland hasn't had a remotely average QB in forever
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,971
because I hated this list as well here's my top 10 WR:

1) Crabtree --- Big-time playmaker who can break tackles and will go up and get the ball. Has a little T.O. in him from the play make or bust perspective has good hands but does lose concentration. Is a tough kid that plays hurt. Gets in the end zone as well as any college player.

2) Maclin --- A slot type WR who is extremely quick and hard to contain. Plus return guy and excellent all-around player who can be used as a rookie. Reminds me a lot of DeSean Jackson without the extreme attitude.

3) Robiskie --- Ideal size and speed mold player who is sharp on routes and displays good hands. Understands the position and what's required. Tough guy who will play hurt. Can block. Will be hurt by Ohio State's running game and rookie QB as well as playing hurt.

4) Harvin --- Excellent athlete with elite quickness but undersized for a backfield role. Will reward team that uses him in various roles such as slot back and on reverses but probably not ever a front line outside WR.

5) Britt --- Young player with tons of upside who dropped a few easy passes and didn't block well at all for a guy his size and strength. Has some attitude concerns.

6) Nicks --- Good football player who produces. Is not overly elusive or quick but runs routes accurately and has good hands. Does block well and will play hard for you. Not as much upside as some guys but a very capable player right now.

7) Derrick Williams --- Very fast player who is a trooper that ran his combine stuff with the flu. Good all-around player that has good hands, good speed and good quickness. Was a team captain and leader but never a great producer. Occasionally runs before he has secured the ball and runs just ok routes.

8) Heyward-Bey --- Unmatched physical tools but easily matched production. Was very inconsistent week to week. Seemed to need to get going early to keep his head in the game. Didn't use his athleticism in all the little ways as he could have. Career totals would be a good year for Mike Crabtree. But look for Oakland to take him round 2 because of that 4.3 40 yard time.

9) Louis Murphy --- Murphy played in a funky but effective offense. Similar player to Bey above. Boom or bust type prospect. Great physical tools to be sure but limited actual college production. Unlike Bey he wasn't the best player or even WR on the team.

10) Iglesias --- Very good player and better than Malcolm Kelly when both were at OU. Not a top end athlete but a very productive guy who is certainly athletic enough. Benefited form Bradford running that wide open offense but still hard to argue with his size, speed or production. Probbaly a nice number 2 WR in the league.
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,971
JerryAdvocate;2699990 said:
to be fair, Maryland hasn't had a remotely average QB in forever

I do hear ya there and I am sure it effected him but overall he'd have games of 1 catch or no catches mixed in with games of 8 catches. All with the same QBs tossing to him. I watched a couple Maryland games and he was just awful. He didn't look to be running full speed and his block attempts looked like Mike Jenkins trying to tackle Jacobs. Then 20 players later he'd make a great catch and look really good for a single drive where Maryland scored a TD.

I am sure the QB play frustrated him but he really never advanced beyond his frosh production.
 

Bob Sacamano

Benched
Messages
57,084
Reaction score
3
jterrell;2700019 said:
I do hear ya there and I am sure it effected him but overall he'd have games of 1 catch or no catches mixed in with games of 8 catches. All with the same QBs tossing to him. I watched a couple Maryland games and he was just awful. He didn't look to be running full speed and his block attempts looked like Mike Jenkins trying to tackle Jacobs. Then 20 players later he'd make a great catch and look really good for a single drive where Maryland scored a TD.

I am sure the QB play frustrated him but he really never advanced beyond his frosh production.

what do you think of Kenny McKinnley?
 

CATCH17

1st Round Pick
Messages
67,665
Reaction score
86,206
jterrell;2700019 said:
I do hear ya there and I am sure it effected him but overall he'd have games of 1 catch or no catches mixed in with games of 8 catches. All with the same QBs tossing to him. I watched a couple Maryland games and he was just awful. He didn't look to be running full speed and his block attempts looked like Mike Jenkins trying to tackle Jacobs. Then 20 players later he'd make a great catch and look really good for a single drive where Maryland scored a TD.

I am sure the QB play frustrated him but he really never advanced beyond his frosh production.

You gotta look at a lot of these guys from a big picture standpoint.

IMO i'd take Crabtree, Britt, Hayward bey, and Robiskie over Maclin because I believe all 4's game translate better to the league.

I could also be talked into Harvin over Maclin. I know Harvin needs some work as a receiver but its not like Maclin is light years ahead of him.
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,971
JerryAdvocate;2700064 said:
what do you think of Kenny McKinnley?

I am not 100% sure of him. He was out of 1 of the SC games I saw and dropped a pass against lsu that would have been huge. He looked smaller and less athletic in that game than he tested out.

I read that he has small hands so that could affect how he catches the ball.

I rate him about where I do Johnny Knox which is for me somewhat unknown. I haven't seen him play much and didn't focus on him in games I watched and do not have access to game tapes like scouts do.

But in a slow WR class he is fast and is not a short guy either. Maybe a 6th round type.
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,971
CATCH17;2700108 said:
You gotta look at a lot of these guys from a big picture standpoint.

IMO i'd take Crabtree, Britt, Hayward bey, and Robiskie over Maclin because I believe all 4's game translate better to the league.

I could also be talked into Harvin over Maclin. I know Harvin needs some work as a receiver but its not like Maclin is light years ahead of him.

I have to strongly disagree here and in doing so respect your opinion but just trust my own eyes:)

Maclin has not just track speed but actual football speed and quickness. He can run routes, has really good hands and displays phenomenal quickness. He reminds me quite a lot of Terry Glenn. He isn't as slight and he isn't as fast but he has that same extra gear and quickness.

I am a huge fan of Dallas Carter and Texas Tech but actually think Maclin is more dangerous than Mike Crabtree.

This guy ran a mere 4.45 but that is like Felix Jones running a 4.5 imho. He is much faster on a football field than say Heyward-Bey. He caught 95 passes for over 1200 yards and 12 TDs last year as well as returning a kickoff for a TD.
 

Chocolate Lab

Run-loving Dino
Messages
37,116
Reaction score
11,468
I really think Maclin might be the best WR when it's all said and done. He reminds me of Lee Evans.

Crabtree is great at what he does, but I guess I'm biased to more speed. The Fitzgeralds who are truly great with mediocre speed are few and far between.
 
Top