Sturm: Tony Romo's Back May Explain Everything

WoodysGirl

U.N.I.T.Y
Staff member
Messages
79,281
Reaction score
45,652
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Let's start with an admission that I am not a doctor, have almost no knowledge of how the human back affects athletes performances, and certainly have no clear details about his surgery from the spring of 2013 that I originally considered nothing more than the cosmetic procedure that they told us it was.

However, for the benefit of this exercise, I was hoping I could receive a little latitude to link some pieces together in hopes of explaining some things (maybe, just to myself) about the odd season of Tony Romo.

Statistically, Romo's season was very solid. In fact, when you look at a +21 TD/INT ratio, a completion percentage up in the range of his career best years, and a passer rating that was in the high 90s again, it would be difficult to say that the offense was not playing optimally because the QB play was poor. And, that is not the intent of this column today.

But, before the season disappears too far into our memories, I want to make sure I put something on paper about what my eyes saw when watching Romo play this year that seemed very disconcerting at the time, but now is perhaps justified by his mental and physical approach that are all resulting in his play slipping a bit. Moving forward, you can understand the entire trend causing questions about what level of play we should expect as he now starts his 6-year extension that he signed, ironically enough, last spring within spitting distance of the back procedure.

Romo is a special player because of his athleticism that allows him to make plays that don't appear to exist. If there is a component of QB play that is vital to almost every player who rises above the pack of ordinary at this position to place them in a category where $100 million contracts are possible, it would have to be the improvisational skills. Just this week, we saw it on full display in the playoffs where Colin Kaepernick and Aaron Rodgers put on a show in arctic temperatures that involved several plays on both sides where the play broke down and the QB figured something out on his own. This, while coached to some extent and practiced to teach the receivers and linemen to respond properly to the "2nd part of a play" comes down to a precious balance of instincts, athleticism, wisdom, and yes, the willingness to risk your own well-being to move the chains.

Read the rest: http://sturminator.blogspot.com/2014/01/tony-romos-back-may-explain-everything.html
 

perrykemp

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,503
Reaction score
9,274
Sorta hints (in my mind) that possibly that back surgery Romo had prior to training camp was not just some simple cyst removal -- that it might be related to the surgery he had again late in the season.

I hope not.
 

foofighters

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,458
Reaction score
7,158
Romo will be missed once he's gone. Everyone wants to compare him to this other "elite" QB's. When people decide to do this, consider the fact that whoever you're comparing him to was drafted. That, in itself should say enough about him.

Romo was pretty cautious this year. If this is the Romo we are going to see from here on out, he's no better than Orton. The offensive play was pretty similar for both QB's. When I say this, I am not bashing on Romo nor am I upgrading Orton. The real issue is the coaching behind our offense. A healthy Romo with no back issues can be successful in spite of JG. That's the big question...is Romo going to get back to that? Too many years with a bad Oline and him getting killed out there could possibly have ended his career this year.
 

dstovall5

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,160
Reaction score
2,211
Nice read, it definitely seems like he was dealing with a back injury all year.

Deep ball off all year.
Checked down more then usual.
"Gave up" on plays he normally wouldn't.

Nonetheless, he still had a very productive year and had us in the playoff hunt week 17.
 

Future

Intramural Legend
Messages
27,566
Reaction score
14,714
Idk, this was too long to read.

My thought is that every decision he made, and even some of the errant throws (he's never been accurate deep) can be attributed to being more cautious with the football. Maybe that's because he didn't want to take any more big hits because he was in pain, he wanted to eliminate turnovers, or both.

I bet its a combination of the two. Tony is a complex guy, and I don't think the answer with him is ever going to be as simple as "he was hurt"
 

TVMan

Active Member
Messages
821
Reaction score
75
If injuries are no excuse for the defense then...
*sarcasm*
 

Tusan_Homichi

Heisenberg
Messages
11,059
Reaction score
3,485
Sorta hints (in my mind) that possibly that back surgery Romo had prior to training camp was not just some simple cyst removal -- that it might be related to the surgery he had again late in the season.

I hope not.

I'm not sure it was directly related and I'm no doctor, but can't cysts be close the spine and be more serious than just a lump just under the skin?
 

Crown Royal

Insulin Beware
Messages
14,229
Reaction score
6,383
Idk, this was too long to read.

My thought is that every decision he made, and even some of the errant throws (he's never been accurate deep) can be attributed to being more cautious with the football. Maybe that's because he didn't want to take any more big hits because he was in pain, he wanted to eliminate turnovers, or both.

I bet its a combination of the two. Tony is a complex guy, and I don't think the answer with him is ever going to be as simple as "he was hurt"

I agree with this. Most of his off throws were off away from the defender. Instead of trusting it to put the ball in a tight window, I think he put it in places that if his WR wasn't getting it, no one does.

I prefer the gunslinger Romo. Playing this type of game isn't for him.

Maybe that pass to end Denver spooked him, and maybe that pass in that situation was wrong. But there are lots of times that's the pass we need our QB to attempt.
 

ufcrules1

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,652
Reaction score
3,800
I'm not a fan of Sturm but that was a decent read from a Romo homer who is starting to see the light for the first time. I found this part below the most interesting. Shows a massive downhill decline and IMO what we are going to see in the future. Except it is going to get worse, not better. That is going to impact his teammates, the fans, and our future since we have so much money tied up into his contract.

"Romo's YPA for his career is 7.8 yards per attempt. From 2006-2009, his YPA for his first 4 years of his career was a stunning 8.1. I say stunning, because that ranks him #1 in the entire NFL for YPA during a 4 year span in front of the likes of Philip Rivers (7.8), Aaron Rodgers (7.8), Drew Brees, Peyton Manning, and Tom Brady (all 7.7). It wasn't just good, it was elite. This offense made the most of its passing attempts and while Romo was having a few more passes picked off than those on that list, he was still making the venture worthwhile with big yards, big plays, and of course, playoffs in 3 of those 4 seasons.

In the next 4 years, from 2010-2013, many of the QBs on that list have remained right where they were, as Brees, Manning, and Brady all remain at about 7.7 YPA. Aaron Rodgers shot up to an absurd 8.5 YPA, Russell Wilson is at 8.1, with Rivers and Kaepernick at 7.9 before the usual suspects. But, what happened to Romo? Once #1, he has dropped down to #11 at 7.57 YPA. That is a drop that is a bit bothersome, but still up in the top half of the league. But, what if we slice it down to 2012-2013, then it is 7.38 for Romo. And just 2013? 7.16. And if we erase the results of the Denver game outlier where he averaged 14.1 YPA and simply focus on the rest of 2013? Then it drops again to 6.65 YPA.

The difference from the 8.1 where he was before 2010 to the 6.6 where he spent much of 2013 is basically the difference in a passing game that features Aaron Rodgers to one that features Ryan Tannehill or Brandon Weeden. In other words, a QB who you happily pay $20m a year versus one that Miami is wondering if they may need to keep shopping."
 

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
It's pretty obvious we made a conscious effort to handle the ball better this season. Both in terms of takeaways (this was what I think was the real reason for the DC switch all along) and, offensively, in terms of the passes we were willing to attempt. I think that has a lot more to do with any issues than the early season issues with Tony's back.

That said, there were a couple games this year where I do remember thinking Tony looked tentative. Mostly following that blown pick up in the DET game where Fairley absolutely leveled him.
 

Idgit

Fattening up
Staff member
Messages
58,971
Reaction score
60,826
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I'm not a fan of Sturm but that was a decent read from a Romo homer who is starting to see the light for the first time. I found this part below the most interesting. Shows a massive downhill decline and IMO what we are going to see in the future. Except it is going to get worse, not better. That is going to impact his teammates, the fans, and our future since we have so much money tied up into his contract.

"Romo's YPA for his career is 7.8 yards per attempt. From 2006-2009, his YPA for his first 4 years of his career was a stunning 8.1. I say stunning, because that ranks him #1 in the entire NFL for YPA during a 4 year span in front of the likes of Philip Rivers (7.8), Aaron Rodgers (7.8), Drew Brees, Peyton Manning, and Tom Brady (all 7.7). It wasn't just good, it was elite. This offense made the most of its passing attempts and while Romo was having a few more passes picked off than those on that list, he was still making the venture worthwhile with big yards, big plays, and of course, playoffs in 3 of those 4 seasons.

In the next 4 years, from 2010-2013, many of the QBs on that list have remained right where they were, as Brees, Manning, and Brady all remain at about 7.7 YPA. Aaron Rodgers shot up to an absurd 8.5 YPA, Russell Wilson is at 8.1, with Rivers and Kaepernick at 7.9 before the usual suspects. But, what happened to Romo? Once #1, he has dropped down to #11 at 7.57 YPA. That is a drop that is a bit bothersome, but still up in the top half of the league. But, what if we slice it down to 2012-2013, then it is 7.38 for Romo. And just 2013? 7.16. And if we erase the results of the Denver game outlier where he averaged 14.1 YPA and simply focus on the rest of 2013? Then it drops again to 6.65 YPA.

The difference from the 8.1 where he was before 2010 to the 6.6 where he spent much of 2013 is basically the difference in a passing game that features Aaron Rodgers to one that features Ryan Tannehill or Brandon Weeden. In other words, a QB who you happily pay $20m a year versus one that Miami is wondering if they may need to keep shopping."

How can anybody not be a fan of Sturm's?
 

ufcrules1

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,652
Reaction score
3,800
How can anybody not be a fan of Sturm's?

Easy, I'm typically not a fan of homers and most of the time that is what he is. Only time he does an article like this is when the evidence is just so overwhelming he just doesn't have a choice. Like the last game of the 2012 season.
 

ufcrules1

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,652
Reaction score
3,800
That said, there were a couple games this year where I do remember thinking Tony looked tentative.

Just a couple? I noticed MANY games where he looked tentative and his deep balls were lacking zip and accuracy too.
 

CashMan

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,555
Reaction score
1,175
Romo will be missed once he's gone. Everyone wants to compare him to this other "elite" QB's. When people decide to do this, consider the fact that whoever you're comparing him to was drafted. That, in itself should say enough about him.

A couple thoughts:

I didn't know, in order to be considered elite, you needed to be drafted. Brady was drafted in the 6th rd, and is elite. I think when you get passed over, it lights a fire in the individual. Romo sat a few years before he started, so did Steve McNair, and he was taken pretty high in the draft.

You get thrown into debate, when you flash ability and are not consistent. In big games, Tony Romo fails. Also, when you are handed elite money, expectations are magnified. Romo was also handed big money, then mysteriously a surgery needs to be done to his back, then magically is an issue at the end of the season as well. Too many questions with Romo, and not enough answers.

Once Romo is gone, will he be missed, yes. Was/is he a good QB, yes. Was/he is a great QB, no. Let us not forget the crap that we had to watch, from Aikman to Romo. If you were to ask people, if you do not want Romo, then who would be the QB? I do not think anyone know, since Jerry does not know how to groom a replacement. He lucked into Romo.
 
Top