First I didn't hate Batman vs Superman
I'll put that out there for those in here to understand that fact before I speak about Suicide Squad.
Now Suicide Squad...I watched it last night...it was a decent movie. It wasn't great. It wasn't spectacular and it doesn't wow you. I thought it was decent though.
I felt like Harley Quinn and Dead Shot were, by far, the best characters in the show. They were done very well and I enjoyed them. Robbie and Smith played them absolutely great, IMO.
I felt like the movie made Captain Boomerang actual seem like a decent enough character. Generally speaking I think the character is awful but in this movie he was passable.
Killer Croc was absolutely AWFUL. It wasn't the actor so much, as he doesn't speak a whole lot, but they definitely should have CGI'd the character because he's way, way, way to freaking small to be Killer Croc. It was just bad.
The lady playing Amanda Waller (Viola Davis) was excellent. I thought she absolutely captured the character pretty much to perfection. Extremely well done on her part.
Jared Leto as the Joker...I won't say a let down as I didn't expect much. All I can say really is that he didn't ruin the movie, as I was worried he would, but he wasn't good as The Joker IMO.
The only thing I felt he did well was he showed the crazy person side pretty well but it seemed more like just a regular crazy person. What I mean is if he was just playing in a movie about someone in a nut house and it was just a random movie about a regular crazy person he'd have done a pretty solid job because he captured that part.
But being as that he's playing the Joker, with a particular personality and such I don't feel like he did anything that actually captured the Joker's personality. His laugh was...ehhh. It just wasn't good. The voice was not good. And he completely whiffed, IMO, on the personality of the Joker.
But all that said he wasn't so terrible with any of it that it ruined the movie. Which is good on his part. At least he didn't ruin it.
Overall I feel like the movie was probably deserving of nothing higher than a 6, and if we're being real honest it probably shouldn't even get above a 5.
But the performances of Smith, Robbie and Davis bumps it up a bit more for me simply because I thought they did such a good job with their characters. So I'd give it a 7.5 just because of their performances.