Tell me about Shemar Stewart

If we are wiped at 12 and can’t trade back I would consider him. I’d rather than that than a TE. If he hits, wow.
 
Last edited:
atlantacowboy said:
This kid is one to avoid. Great measurable...... has all the physical tools required to be great but he wasn't productive in college. I read he had no sacks in the final 7 games the past 2 years, and he was healthy. I've seen him mocked everywhere from top 5 to round 2. Nobody can figure this guy out.
Click to expand...
If you think in terms of sacks, sure. But he got a lot of pressures and was great at stopping the run. I don't think he's a case of pure projection. He needs work, yes, but he can already make splash plays. This is one risk I'd be willing to take at 12.

 
NDGAEDE said:
If you think in terms of sacks, sure. But he got a lot of pressures and was great at stopping the run. I don't think he's a case of pure projection. He needs work, yes, but he can already make splash plays. This is one risk I'd be willing to take at 12.

Click to expand...

I am starting to like Stewart. If he was a Penn St. instead of A&M would he have been on Carter’s level. If the Cowboys are considering Mikel Williams they better be all over Stewart. I for one would trust Stewart over the wide receivers. You can’t teach his natural talent.
 
Yeah I just don't know, he scares me a little. But if he hits, wow it's a home run.
I know his sacks were way below where his numbers say they should have been, but he seems to be a good run defender, which is something we definitely need. And he definitely can get pressure on QB's too. Will he develop beyond just pressures?

I'd say he could have a floor as high as Marcus Spears, solid DE, good at run defense/setting the edge and with some pressures. But he could have a ceiling as high as Miles Garret, being a dominate DE who just wrecks game plans.
I wouldn't hate the pick at 12, but I would be a little uneasy about it.
 
J-man said:
Yeah I just don't know, he scares me a little. But if he hits, wow it's a home run.
I know his sacks were way below where his numbers say they should have been, but he seems to be a good run defender, which is something we definitely need. And he definitely can get pressure on QB's too. Will he develop beyond just pressures?

I'd say he could have a floor as high as Marcus Spears, solid DE, good at run defense/setting the edge and with some pressures. But he could have a ceiling as high as Miles Garret, being a dominate DE who just wrecks game plans.
I wouldn't hate the pick at 12, but I would be a little uneasy about it.
Click to expand...
Marcus Spears was never this type of athlete. Stewart is more athletic than Miles Garrett ever was. You said it best if he hits, Stewart is not just a home run it’s a grand slam. Easily could be the best player in the draft.
 
baltcowboy said:
Marcus Spears was never this type of athlete. Stewart is more athletic than Miles Garrett ever was. You said it best if he hits, Stewart is not just a home run it’s a grand slam. Easily could be the best player in the draft.
Click to expand...
Yeah I wasn't really comparing atheism, just what type of players they are/could be. Spears was a good run defender who got some pressures. Miles is a game wrecker. He could be either.
 
J-man said:
Yeah I wasn't really comparing atheism, just what type of players they are/could be. Spears was a good run defender who got some pressures. Miles is a game wrecker. He could be either.
Click to expand...
I am sorry I can’t stand Spears ever since he became the Cowboys go to guy on ESPN. He is clueless but he was an athletic freak back in the day.
 
baltcowboy said:
I am starting to like Stewart. If he was a Penn St. instead of A&M would he have been on Carter’s level. If the Cowboys are considering Mikel Williams they better be all over Stewart. I for one would trust Stewart over the wide receivers. You can’t teach his natural talent.
Click to expand...
It really is apparent when you see some of his plays. He can make insane plays but is so unpolished he can't complete them. In our defence, he can create pressure and rest assured that Micah or Osa will finish the sack. It's a huge risk but man he's talented.
 
NDGAEDE said:
It really is apparent when you see some of his plays. He can make insane plays but is so unpolished he can't complete them. In our defence, he can create pressure and rest assured that Micah or Osa will finish the sack. It's a huge risk but man he's talented.
Click to expand...
I am with you. He easily could be our Jalen Carter with Michah, Osa, and Fowler on 3rd and long. Scary…..
 
NDGAEDE said:
If you think in terms of sacks, sure. But he got a lot of pressures and was great at stopping the run. I don't think he's a case of pure projection. He needs work, yes, but he can already make splash plays. This is one risk I'd be willing to take at 12.

Click to expand...

There are plenty of dudes drafting in the top 50 that didn’t have a lot of sacks in college that turned into monsters in the NFL.

NFL teams draft for what they think a player can do not what they’ve done. Stewart will 100% be a first rounder.
 
S
cnuball21 said:
There are plenty of dudes drafting in the top 50 that didn’t have a lot of sacks in college that turned into monsters in the NFL.

NFL teams draft for what they think a player can do not what they’ve done. Stewart will 100% be a first rounder.
Click to expand...
Stewart is the type of player the Steelers, Eagles, Ravens tend to steal every draft it seems.
 
cnuball21 said:
As a Panthers kind of fan living in Charlotte that seems a little rich…I’ve heard Walker to the Panthers.
Click to expand...
Supposedly according to the Cowboys insiders who don’t want Williams to be drafted by the Cowboys, Carolina likes MikeiI Williams. I actually like Stewart more than Williams. Walker is tweener you have to have a plan for him. Is he a linebacker or a defensive end.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Staff online

Members online

... and 116 more.
Total: 4,162 (members: 216, guests: 3,946)

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
464,464
Messages
13,812,590
Members
23,780
Latest member
HoppleSopple
Back
Top