- Messages
- 58,971
- Reaction score
- 60,826
KJJ;3757930 said:Face it you can't poke holes in anything I've said concerning Newman so move on!
You wouldn't know a hole if your head were stuck in one.
This thread is proof.
KJJ;3757930 said:Face it you can't poke holes in anything I've said concerning Newman so move on!
Idgit;3758002 said:You wouldn't know a hole if your head were stuck in one.
This thread is proof.
KJJ;3757979 said:I've haven't been following all your posts on this topic but you seem to think all of us who claim Newman is in decline have an agenda and want him cut.
You won't find one post from me where I want him cut. I don't think he's a horrible player but he's clearly in decline and has been inconsistent. He's going to have to be replaced in the next year or two.
The first players that need to be replaced if our secondary is going to improve are both safeties especially Ball. We went from bad with Hamlin to worse with Ball.
casmith07;3758052 said:Again, read the thread, and read the opinions of people here, and get back to me.
You can't wait until now when people start trumping stupid opinions with facts to try and get all neutral on it and try and use football-speak. The proof is all over this thread.
Posters have an agenda. It's the way of the world. Nobody said anything about YOU having one until you came swooping in like Captain Butthurt to save the few fools here that WERE putting their agendas on display.
If you don't like being lumped into the same category as the rest of the trolls, get out from under the bridge.
casmith07;3758052 said:Come on, the mods had to edit the thread title because the OP couldn't even spell the guy's name right. Pathetic.
casmith07;3758052 said:Again, read the thread, and read the opinions of people here, and get back to me.
I agree that his play has declined this season. I believe he is injured. I provide physical therapy services for a living. A rib injury can result in excruciating pain. I do treat athletes in various sports from time to time. Not every injury is the same and not every person reacts to an injury the same way. The fact that Newman is playing is not proof that his injury isn't affecting him. I don't know how to make that any clearer for you. There's my opinion on it. I don't claim it as fact.KJJ;3757329 said:Are you saying you agree with his argument that Newman has played well this season despite being repeatedly beaten or did you just show up to blow off some steam? The ones who repeatedly argue with me are the ones who's arguments have been repeatedly shot down by me. I suggest you do some research. If my arguments are so flimsy I challenge you to shoot down some of them. Up for the challenge? :toast: By the way if you're going to quote me don't add your own personal touch to my quote!
ninja;3757350 said:From your jibberish post, it appears you took one too many hit to your noggin. Now, go back to watching Karate Kid. "Wax on, wax off."
PBJTime;3758130 said:I agree that his play has declined this season. I believe he is injured. I provide physical therapy services for a living. A rib injury can result in excruciating pain. I do treat athletes in various sports from time to time. Not every injury is the same and not every person reacts to an injury the same way. The fact that Newman is playing is not proof that his injury isn't affecting him. I don't know how to make that any clearer for you. There's my opinion on it. I don't claim it as fact.
You really don't have any substantial points up for any debate. There is no changing your mind. It's difficult to attempt to debate someone who uses multiple logical fallacies as a crutch. You've already made a preemptive strike regarding any use of stats by attacking anyone who believes the stats that Adam posts. So, you've got that base covered. Then, you consistently fall back on your agreement with the perceived majority. There really is no point in wasting any time trying to objectively debate with you.
Just FYI, I've never had any blind love for Newman. I believe he has been a very solid corner for us and still has some tread left on the tires.
Also, I happen to like my personal touch. It stated about as much information as your original post with a fraction of the words.
KJJ;3758083 said:I just went through the thread and most don't agree with you that he's a very good corner who's receiving undo criticism.
PBJTime;3758130 said:I agree that his play has declined this season. I believe he is injured. I provide physical therapy services for a living. A rib injury can result in excruciating pain. I do treat athletes in various sports from time to time. Not every injury is the same and not every person reacts to an injury the same way. The fact that Newman is playing is not proof that his injury isn't affecting him. I don't know how to make that any clearer for you. There's my opinion on it. I don't claim it as fact.
You really don't have any substantial points up for any debate. There is no changing your mind. It's difficult to attempt to debate someone who uses multiple logical fallacies as a crutch. You've already made a preemptive strike regarding any use of stats by attacking anyone who believes the stats that Adam posts. So, you've got that base covered. Then, you consistently fall back on your agreement with the perceived majority. There really is no point in wasting any time trying to objectively debate with you.
Just FYI, I've never had any blind love for Newman. I believe he has been a very solid corner for us and still has some tread left on the tires.
Also, I happen to like my personal touch. It stated about as much information as your original post with a fraction of the words.

jobberone;3758157 said:I've treated professional hockey and soccer players as well as college players.
You cannot reason with unreasonable people. Despite the high probability Newman's substandard play is secondary to his injuries, some would rather attribute it to a sudden decline in play. All this despite the fact he was a Pro Bowl player last year. Their multiple cognitive distortions and willful manipulation of others arguments are side issues. Certainly annoying and frustrating but still side issues.
RoyTheHammer;3758194 said:He was an injury replacement to be precise.
As far as bruised ribs that he had for a few games, that doesn't hamper your play substantially for half a season, especially when you take pain relieving shots prior to each game. Those shots take almost all the soreness away.
If you'd like to blame this entire season of substandard play on injuries, be my guest. But if Newman was seriously hurting, there would be as much reason to have played him this last half of the season as there would have been to play Tony.
PBJTime;3758130 said:I agree that his play has declined this season.
PBJTime;3758130 said:I believe he is injured. I provide physical therapy services for a living. A rib injury can result in excruciating pain. I do treat athletes in various sports from time to time. Not every injury is the same and not every person reacts to an injury the same way.
PBJTime;3758130 said:The fact that Newman is playing is not proof that his injury isn't affecting him. I don't know how to make that any clearer for you. There's my opinion on it. I don't claim it as fact.
PBJTime;3758130 said:You really don't have any substantial points up for any debate.
PBJTime;3758130 said:There is no changing your mind. It's difficult to attempt to debate someone who uses multiple logical fallacies as a crutch. You've already made a preemptive strike regarding any use of stats by attacking anyone who believes the stats that Adam posts. So, you've got that base covered. Then, you consistently fall back on your agreement with the perceived majority. There really is no point in wasting any time trying to objectively debate with you.
PBJTime;3758130 said:Just FYI, I've never had any blind love for Newman. I believe he has been a very solid corner for us and still has some tread left on the tires.
PBJTime;3758130 said:Also, I happen to like my personal touch. It stated about as much information as your original post with a fraction of the words.
CCBoy;3758203 said:Seriously, I think you confuse toughness with a medical evaluation involving elite athletes being paid at top dollar prices. Newman showed that he would put up with the physical pain involved...but that doesn't mean he yet has full ability to turn on a dime and sprint like a deer, yet. Just turning hampered affects a cornerback acutely.
You have allready been presented a reasonable comparison on topic...but chose to ignore the human side to function. Oh, it's real...and lasts longer than your considerations for just being 'tough.'
CCBoy;3758139 said:You did? Then what are your stats in support of your continued agreements with yourself....?![]()
CCBoy;3758139 said:The whole of the entire defense declined, and you merely are trying to cherry pick a removal group, but based upon decline in production, desire for new faces, and age. But here, all mostly abstractly applied...but with the cheer of a continual - tar bucket and feather bucket, mob mentality.
KJJ;3758212 said:The only proof I need is all the times Newman has been beaten this season. It's been a common theme each week watching receivers run by him for big plays. These threads on Newman that keep appearing every week aren't popping up because he's playing well.
Our pathetic pass coverage is the main reason our entire defense has declined, plus teams are paying alot of attention to Ratliff this season and have been able render him ineffective most of the time with numerous double teams and some triple teams.
Most of the points our D is giving up is via the pass. Rex Grossman who's one of the least respected QB's in the NFL just put up over 320 yards and 4 TD's against our defense.
Washington had a FB catch one 30 yards down field against our secondary. By the way you make about as much sense as Leon Spinks after a night on the town.

RoyTheHammer;3758207 said:You really need to work on your english comprehension and grammar.. your posts are brutal.
